TABLE 2—
Characteristics of Longitudinal Studies With Health, Medical Care, Adherence, and Risk Behavior Outcomes: 1996–2014
Study and Location | Focus | Study Design and Sample | Housing Measures | Outcomes | Main Housing-Related Findingsa |
RCT housing interventions: multiple outcomes | |||||
Wolitski et al.26; Baltimore, MD; Chicago, IL; Los Angeles, CA | To assess the effects of permanent rental housing assistance on the health and risk behaviors of homeless and unstably housed PWH | RCT of housing intervention Convenience sample recruited by agencies providing housing assistance and social services to PWH |
In past 90 d: homeless ≥ 1 nights: slept in shelter or places not suitable for human habitation; unstably housed: temporarily doubled up with others, lived in a transitional or transitory setting; stable housing: had own place, a room, apartment, or house that is your home | HIV clinical health Other health outcomes Medical care ED and inpatient use Risk behaviors |
Improved housing status resulted in substantial reductions in medical care utilization and improvements in self-reported physical and mental health functioning; significant differential change benefiting the intervention group for mental health indicators Significant differences between homeless and stably housed participants found in as-treated analyses for ED use, mental health, and detectable viral load |
Buchanan et al.29; Chicago | To determine the health benefits of permanent supportive housing among homeless persons hospitalized with a chronic medical illness | RCT of housing intervention convenience sample from the inpatient medical and surgical service |
Homeless: no source of stable housing (with no time limits, for which the person has adequate resources) at hospital discharge and during 30 d before admission | HIV clinical health | At 12 mo, intervention group significantly more likely to be alive with intact immunity, with significantly lower median viral loads |
Longitudinal design: HIV health care access and utilization and ED and inpatient use | |||||
Muthulingam et al.71; San Francisco, CA | To measure sociodemographic and risk disparities in timely linkage to care, retention in care, and viral suppression among persons with HIV | Prospective cohort study Surveillance data from San Francisco Department of Health |
Housing status: homeless, not homeless, unknown at HIV diagnosis; homelessness noted on medical record or address was homeless shelter, a health clinic, or free postal address not connected to a residence | HIV medical care HIV clinical health |
Unknown housing status at diagnosis associated with lower rates of linkage to care; homelessness and unknown housing status independent predictors of failure to achieve viral suppression 12 mo after diagnosis |
Weiser et al.72; San Francisco | To examine the association between food insecurity and health care utilization, hospitalizations, and ED visits, among homeless and marginally housed PWH | Prospective cohort study Probability sampling from homeless shelters, free food programs and SROs in 3 low-income neighborhoods |
Homeless: slept on the street or in a homeless shelter in the past 90 d | ED and inpatient use | Homelessness significantly associated with hospitalization in the unadjusted model and significantly associated with ED use in both unadjusted and adjusted models |
Fairbairn et al.75; Vancouver, BC | To examine prevalence and correlates of ED use, ED diagnoses, and hospital admission rates among HIV-positive IDUs | Prospective cohort study Convenience sample recruited in a low-income central city neighborhood through word of mouth and street outreach |
Unstable housing: SRO hotel, shelter, recovery or transition house, jail, on the street, or having no fixed address | ED and inpatient use | Living in unstable housing independently associated with higher cumulative incidence rate of ED use and shorter time to first ED visit during the study period |
Knowlton et al.52; Baltimore; Miami, FL; New York City; San Francisco | To identify multilevel factors associated with HAART use among a community sample of active IDUs recruited from US urban epicenters | Prospective cohort study Convenience sample active and passive recruitment at AIDS service organizations, medical clinics, methadone clinics, homeless shelters, and street-based settings |
Stable housing: self-report currently has a place to stay 5–7 d/wk | HIV medical care | Participants with stable housing had double the odds of HAART use than did those without stable housing |
Arnold et al.46; San Francisco | To assess the role of neighborhood socioeconomic context on racial/ethnic disparities in ART initiation and AIDS survival | Prospective cohort study HIV surveillance data reported to San Francisco Department of Health 1996–2001 followed through 2006 |
Homeless: at the time of HIV diagnosis homelessness noted on medical record or address was homeless shelter, a health clinic, or free postal address not connected to a residence | HIV medical care HIV clinical health (mortality) |
Homeless at time of AIDS diagnosis significantly associated with being uninsured; homelessness at diagnosis had an independent effect on delayed or no ART initiation, controlling for neighborhood socioeconomic context Homelessness associated with mortality within 30 d of AIDS diagnosis; excluding persons who died within 30 d, homeless at diagnosis not associated with 5-year survival |
Gardner et al.49; Atlanta, GA; Baltimore; Los Angeles, Miami | To identify demographic, structural, behavioral, and psychological subgroups for whom intervention had differential effects in linking PWH to care | Pre–post intervention study of linkage to care intervention Convenience sample recruited from sexually transmitted disease clinics, hospitals, and community-based organizations |
Unstable housing: on the street, in shelter, or other temporary housing, in an institution (treatment facility, halfway house, group home, hospital or nursing home); stable housing: in a house or apartment alone or with others | HIV medical care | PWH with unstable housing at baseline were less likely than were those with stable housing to link with HIV primary care In multivariate analysis of effect modification, intervention had a stronger effect on linkage to primary care for unstably housed participants than for stably housed |
Aidala et al.17; New York City | To examine housing and connection to care in a probability sample of PWH tracking housing status and medical care utilization over an extended period | Prospective cohort study Multistage probability sampling using sequential enrollment or list-based systematic random sampling of clients from a stratified sample of medical and social service agencies |
Homeless: sleeping on the street, drop-in center, shelter, SRO, place not meant for sleeping Unstably housed: transitional housing, jail, treatment facility doubled up; stably housed: permanent housing in own house or apartment; housing assistance: receipt of rental or other direct housing assistance; housing need: homeless, unstably housed, need assistance to maintain housing |
HIV medical care | PWH who are homeless, unstably housed, or with other housing needs significantly less likely to have received HIV medical care; receipt of housing assistance significantly increases the odds of visits for HIV care Analysis over time shows housing needs are associated with lack of continuity of HIV care; receipt of housing assistance predicts retention in care Among PWH unconnected to HIV care, those who have housing needs are half as likely to enter care within 12 mo; receipt of housing assistance predicts transition into care |
Nosyk et al.83; Vancouver | To determine the effect of homelessness and neighborhood SES on hospitalization patterns and costs in patients with HIV and AIDS | Retrospective cohort study Recruitment method: convenience sample of hospitalized PWH patients residing in downtown Vancouver, Canada |
Homeless: patients without a fixed address during ≥ 1 admissions within a particular calendar year; DTES: patients with a fixed address within the most impoverished neighborhood in a particular calendar year | ED and Inpatient Use | Homeless patients had more ED admissions; homeless males had longer length of hospital stay and homeless IDUs had more hospitalization than did PWH in high SES neighborhoods PWH residing in the low-SES neighborhood had more ED admissions, and males had longer length of hospital stay than did PWH living in high SES neighborhoods |
Rumptz et al.42; 10 US urban centers | To examine factors associated with engaging socially marginalized PWH in primary care | Pre–post intervention study Convenience sample of participants in 10 urban interventions to improve primary care engagement; recruited via outreach and referral from service providers |
Housing arrangements in previous 6 mo: own home or apartment, someone else’s home, or temporary arrangement; unmet needs for housing: not otherwise defined | HIV medical care | PWH with unmet needs for housing less likely to improve engagement with HIV primary care in bivariate analysis Decrease in composite measure of unmet needs (including housing needs) significantly associated with improved engagement with care in multivariate models |
Wilkinson et al.44; Baltimore, Miami, New York City, San Francisco | To identify factors associated with medical care utilization by IDUs PWH participating in adherence and risk reduction intervention | Prospective cohort study Convenience sample using active and passive recruitment at AIDS service organizations, medical clinics, methadone clinics, and street-based settings |
Stable housing: self-report has a place to stay 5–7 d/wk | HIV medical care ED and inpatient use |
Obtaining or maintaining stable housing associated with using an outpatient setting rather than the ED as the usual source of care at 12-mo follow-up |
Kim et al.37; Boston, MA | To examine whether episodes of homelessness are independently associated with suboptimal medical utilization among problem alcohol users | Prospective cohort study Convenience sample of PWH with alcohol problems indicated by screener questionnaire or physician assessment, recruited from HIV primary care and specialty clinics |
Homelessness Self-report of any night spent on the street or in a shelter in the past 6 mo |
HIV medical care ED and inpatient use |
No significant difference found in primary care visits between homeless and housed periods in longitudinal regression model Homelessness significantly associated with higher ED utilization rates and rates of inpatient hospitalization Length of time homeless associated with higher utilization of both ED and inpatient hospitalization |
Kushel et al.38; San Francisco | To determine if case management associated with acute medical care use and improved clinical outcomes in homeless and marginally housed PWH | Prospective cohort study Probability sampling from homeless shelters, free food programs and SROs in 3 low-income neighborhoods |
Marginally housed: at least 90% of nights spent in a residential hotel or an apartment; homeless: < 90% of nights spent in a residential hotel and ≥ 1 nights slept on the street or in a shelter, in the past 90 d | HIV medical care ED and inpatient use Adherence HIV clinical outcomes |
Homelessness negatively associated with receipt of routine primary care in bivariate but not full adjusted models No difference in the uniformly low rates of viral suppression among marginally housed and homeless participants |
Palepu et al.32; Boston | To examine the association of substance abuse treatment services with hospitalization among PWH with a history of alcohol problems | Prospective cohort study Convenience sample of PWH screening positive for alcohol problems; recruited from medical settings serving PWH, including respite care facility |
Homeless: ≥ 1 nights on the street or in a shelter in the past 6 mo | HIV medical care ED and inpatient use |
Rates of hospitalization higher among homeless PWH with alcohol problems Recent homelessness significantly increased odds of hospitalization in longitudinal analysis |
Masson et al.30; San Francisco | To examine factors affecting medical service use among PWH with substance abuse disorder | Prospective cohort study: pooled data from RCT case management intervention study Targeted and purposive recruitment from ED, inpatient wards, and outpatient detox clinic of a public hospital |
Current living situation: homeless: living in a shelter, car or outdoors; institution: such as jail or hospital Room in a hotel or motel; halfway house or residential treatment; house or apartment of a friend or relative; house or apartment you rent or own |
HIV medical care ED and inpatient use |
Homelessness associated with significantly higher utilization of both ED and inpatient services among PWH with a substance abuse disorder |
Messeri et al.29; New York City | To examine the impact of nonmedical supportive services on engagement with HIV medical care | Prospective cohort study Multistage probability sampling using sequential enrollment or list-based systematic random sampling of clients from a stratified sample of medical and social service agencies |
Housing need: self-report experienced housing problems or need for assistance with housing in past 6 mo; housing services: received help or assistance with housing in past 6 mo | HIV medical care | Housing services have a weak positive effect on entry into any medical care but none on entry into appropriate HIV care Individuals who receive housing services are more than twice as likely to retain appropriate medical care as those not receiving housing services |
Longitudinal design: ART adherence | |||||
Weiser et al.66; San Francisco | To examine food insecurity and HIV outcomes in a longitudinal study of marginally housed PWH | Prospective cohort study Probability sampling from homeless shelters, free food programs, and SROs in 3 low-income neighborhoods |
Homeless: sleeping on the street or in a shelter in the past 90 d | ART adherence HIV clinical health |
Recent homelessness was associated with less than optimal adherence and having a detectable viral load |
O’Neil et al.134; BC | To determine factors associated with adherence among PWH receiving ART therapy | Prospective cohort study Convenience sample recruited through providers, community advertising, and referral |
Unstable housing: living in a SRO hotel, shelter, hostel, treatment center or prison, or having no fixed address | ART adherence | PWH with optimal adherence more likely to be stably housed, but housing status not a significant predictor of ART adherence in adjusted models |
Roux et al.67; 17 outpatient hospital services in France | To investigate the relationship between initiating HCV treatment and ART adherence HIV and HCV coinfected patients | Prospective cohort study Convenience sample of PWH recruited in outpatient hospital services delivering HIV and HCV care in France |
Good housing conditions: participant answered “quite comfortable” or “very comfortable” vs “uncomfortable” or “very uncomfortable” housing conditions | ART adherence | Good housing conditions were associated with reduced risk of nonadherence to ART, regardless of treatment of HCV |
Milloy et al.58; Vancouver | To investigate the impact of homelessness on viral suppression among illicit drug users initiating ART in a setting with universal access to HIV care | Prospective cohort study HIV-positive illicit drug users recruited via outreach and snowball sampling from street and service settings in a disadvantaged urban neighborhood |
Homelessness: living on the street with no fixed address at any time in the past 6 mo | ART adherence HIV clinical health |
Homelessness independently associated with lower levels of ART adherence Homelessness significantly associated with lower likelihood of achieving viral suppression and with longer time to viral suppression after initiation of treatment |
Palepu et al.85; Vancouver | To determine the longitudinal impact of homelessness on adherence to ART therapy | Retrospective cohort study Snowball sample of IDUs recruited through street outreach |
Homelessness: living on the street or no fixed address in the past 6 mo | ART adherence | Homelessness significantly negatively associated with ART adherence |
Kalichman et al.56; Atlanta | To examine the association of social, health, and poverty-related stressors on ART adherence in PWH with low literacy | Prospective cohort study Convenience sample recruited through service organizations, health care providers, and word of mouth |
Housing poverty experience: worried about having a place to stay; poverty experiences: sum of poverty-related stressors, including housing poverty | ART adherence | Poverty experiences significantly associated with poorer ART adherence in a group with low adherence rates; being worried about a place to stay not significantly associated with ART adherence as independent predictor |
Lima et al.84; BC | To determine the scale of regional migration and its association with ART adherence patterns over time | Retrospective cohort study Medical record review of all patients initiating ART therapy through regional HIV/AIDS treatment and medication distribution sites |
Migration: cumulative number of residential address changes during course of HIV treatment | ART adherence | Migration was associated with nonadherence to ART; increase in number of address changes associated with greater odds of nonadherence |
Kim et al.41; Boston | To investigate predictors of discontinuing ART in PWH with alcohol problems | Prospective cohort study Convenience sample recruited from health care centers, homeless shelters, drug treatment programs, community advertisements, and a previous study of PWH and alcohol problems |
Homelessness: any night spent in a shelter or on the street in the past 6 mo | ART adherence | Homelessness predicts discontinued ART therapy in the unadjusted analysis; not significant in fully adjusted models |
Berg et al.53; New York City | To identify gender differences in social and behavioral factors, including drug or alcohol use associated with ART adherence | Prospective cohort study Convenience sample of current or former HIV-positive IDUs recruited from outpatient methadone-maintenance treatment program |
Housing status: own apartment, other’s apartment, or temporary housing (in a hotel, motel, shelter, temporarily with someone, or being without shelter) long-term housing: in current residence ≥ 3 y | ART adherence | Lack of long-term housing stability was significantly associated with worse ART adherence for both men and women |
Spire et al.55; 47 locations in France | To analyze relationships between ART adherence and PWH characteristics and experiences before and after ART initiation | Prospective cohort study Convenience sample of PWH initiating an ART regimen 1997–1999, recruited from 47 clinical centers |
Housing condition: self-report current housing unstable housing, stable but poor housing, or stable (adequate) housing | ART adherence | Both stably but poorly housed participants and unstably housed participants had higher risk of not adhering to ARTs than did PWH with stable, adequate housing |
Longitudinal design: HIV clinical health outcomes | |||||
Anema et al.64; BC | To assess the potential relationship between food insecurity and all-cause mortality among HIV-positive IDUs initiating ART in BC | Prospective cohort study Sample population of IDU, PWH initiating ART across BC 1998–2011 |
Unstable housing: living in a hotel, boarding house, group home, jail, on the street, or having no fixed address at the time of program entry | HIV clinical health (mortality) | No significant association between unstable housing at treatment program enrollment and all-cause mortality over median 133 y of follow-up |
Fuster et al.79; Boston | To assess association between HCV infection and overall and liver-related death in PWH with alcohol problems | Prospective cohort study Convenience sample recruited at HIV clinics, hospitals, and homeless and drug treatment programs |
Homeless: ≥ 1 nights in a shelter or on the street 6 mo before assessment period | HIV clinical health (mortality) Other health |
Recent homelessness associated with HCV infections among PWH with alcohol problems; homelessness not associated with all-cause mortality |
Meyer et al.60; 9-state multicenter study in US | To examine HIV treatment outcomes among PWH released from jail participating in care linkage intervention | Pre–post intervention study Convenience sample of PWH from 10 prisons taking part in intervention to transition from the jail to postrelease services |
Homeless: self-report being homeless or sleeping in a shelter or public space 30 d before incarceration or 30 d before follow-up interview | HIV clinical health | Prejail homelessness inversely correlated with baseline viral load suppression; not significant in adjusted models; housing status not associated with viral load suppression at 6-mo postintervention follow-up |
McMahon et al.69; Boston; Providence, RI | To investigate whether SES predicts mortality in HIV-positive persons in the era of HAART | Prospective cohort study Convenience sample recruited through advertisements, posters, presentations at HIV organizations, primary care clinics, and public media |
Homeless: no fixed and regular nighttime residence, sleeping in a shelter, welfare hotel, boarding house, or place not normally used for sleeping | HIV clinical health (mortality) | Homelessness independently associated with increased risk of mortality controlling for HIV disease markers |
Schwarcz et al.89; San Francisco | To examine the effect of homelessness on the mortality of persons diagnosed with AIDS and measure the effect of receipt of supportive housing on AIDS survival | Case–control study Public health department records identifying AIDS-diagnosed adults and adolescents 1996–2006; persons who entered a supportive housing program at any point after AIDS diagnosis |
Homeless: address recorded in AIDS registry as homeless, a known homeless shelter, a medical care clinic, or a free postal address not connected to a residence; receipt of supportive housing: entry into supportive housing program | HIV clinical health (mortality) | Homelessness significantly increased the risk of death within 5 y of AIDS diagnosis Homeless persons with AIDS who obtained supportive housing had significantly lower risk of death than did those who did not |
Oppenheimer50; Austin, TX | To examine the effect of demographics, stress, coping strategies, and clinical medical support on HIV progression | Prospective cohort study Convenience sample of patients visiting a publicly funded HIV/AIDS treatment clinic |
Housing status: currently having a home: renting or owning a home or staying with family or friends; vs not having a home (homeless) | HIV clinical health | Homelessness significantly negatively correlated with CD4 count over 15 mo Homelessness the only significant predictor of decrease in CD4 over time among patients with inconsistent clinic visits |
Walley et al.45; Boston | To assess the impact of recent heavy alcohol use, heroin or cocaine use, and homelessness on short-term mortality in PWH with alcohol problems | Prospective cohort study Convenience sample recruited by multiple methods from service sites and community referral |
Recent homelessness: ≥ 1 nights in an overnight shelter or on the street in the past 6 mo | HIV clinical health (mortality) | Over a 10-y period, recent homelessness significantly associated with increased risk of short-term mortality among PWH with current or past alcohol problems |
Miller et al.82; BC | To provide a profile of Aboriginal people initiating ART and their response to treatment | Retrospective cohort study Convenience sample identified through Medical records review of all patients initiating ART therapy through regional HIV treatment sites who completed a baseline survey |
Unstable housing: living in a hotel, jail, boarding house, group home, on the street, or having no fixed address at time of ART initiation | HIV clinical health | PWH with unstable housing at baseline were less likely to achieve viral suppression |
Riley et al.34; San Francisco | To estimate mortality rates and examine the effect of sustained treatment exposure on survival rates of homeless or marginally housed PWH | Prospective cohort study Probability sampling from homeless shelters, free food programs, and SROs in 3 low-income neighborhoods |
Currently homeless: spend most nights on the street or in a shelter; lifetime homeless experience: homeless > 1 y as an adult | HIV clinical health (mortality) | There were no differences in risk of death within 6 y between those who were homeless at baseline and the unstably housed; lifetime homeless experience was not associated with increased mortality risk Sustained ART treatment significantly reduced the risk of death regardless of recent or lifetime homeless experience |
Lieb et al.90; 4 Florida cities | To evaluate modifiable factors associated with HIV/AIDS mortality in a nonresearch setting | Case–control study Statewide HIV/AIDS reporting system and medical records used to identify all PWH treated at 4 health clinics who died during 1999, and control participants randomly selected from other PWH seen at the clinics |
Housing status; medical record indicates homelessness on the basis of description of living situation during the 1-y period before last clinic visit | HIV clinical health (mortality) | Recent homelessness an independent predictor of mortality among PWH In multivariate model with treatment variables and behavioral factors related to treatment, homelessness increased risk of mortality almost 10-fold |
Longitudinal design: other health outcomes | |||||
Rourke et al.59; ON | To examine the relationship between material, meaningful, and spatial dimensions of housing and health-related quality of life among adult PWH | Prospective cohort study Stratified purposive recruitment through community-based AIDS service organizations, including efforts to locate and recruit PWH not in services |
Homelessness: emergency shelter, living in a car, on the streets, or couch surfing; inadequate housing: motel, hotel, or boarding house | Other health outcomes: Physical and mental health functioning; quality of life |
Baseline housing and neighborhood variables associated with physical and mental health quality of life Difficulty paying housing costs associated with worse mental health over time Satisfaction with housing associated with improved mental health score |
Riley et al.57; San Francisco | To identify and empirically rank factors that longitudinally affect the physical and mental health status of HIV-positive homeless and unstably housed women | Prospective cohort study Probability time and location sampling by a mobile outreach team at homeless shelters, free food programs, and low-income hotels |
In prior 90 d: homeless: slept on the street or in shelter; unstably housed: slept in SRO hotel or other marginal housing; unmet subsistence needs: composite measure includes difficulty with a place to sleep | Other health outcomes: Physical and mental health functioning; gynecological symptoms |
Homelessness significantly associated with worse mental health functioning Unmet subsistence needs had the strongest effect on mental health, gynecologic symptoms, and overall physical health functioning in adjusted models |
Popovich et al.88; Chicago | To assess population-level incidence of HIV+ patients with community-associated methicillin-resistant CA-MRSA | Case–control study Identification of cases and controls using electronic data from all patients receiving medical care in a multicenter regional safety net hospital and ambulatory care system |
Alternative housing: Current residence in subsidized housing, shelters, or substance abuse centers |
Other health outcomes: CA-MRSA |
Residence in alternative housing (shelters) independently associated with increased risk of CA-MRSA among PWH |
Chin et al.47; New York City | To examine the impact of substance use status, ART treatment status, and housing stability on physical and mental health–related quality of life | Prospective cohort study Sequential enrollment of participants in social service intervention programs over a 5-y period |
Unstably housed: homeless, living in a residential or SRO hotel, shelter, or emergency housing Stably housed: rent or own an apartment or home, live with family or friends, or reside in HIV housing |
Other health outcomes: Physical and mental health functioning; quality of life |
Consistently unstable housing or change from stable to unstable housing associated with lower quality of life scores Change in housing status from unstable to stable housing associated with improved physical and mental quality of life scores but not statistically significant in full adjusted models |
Mrus et al.39; Cincinnati, OH; Pittsburgh, PA; Washington, DC | To compare health-related quality of life and predictors of quality of life among PWH receiving care in VA settings and non-VA settings | Prospective cohort study Convenience sample of patients visiting HIV outpatient clinics at 4 sites in 3 cities |
Unstable housing: self-report housing situation as “transient and live in shelter” or “homeless” among other housing options | Other health outcomes: Quality of life |
Stable housing significantly associated with better self-reported health status at baseline and with indicators of better health quality of life in longitudinal analysis |
Hall et al.54; San Francisco | To investigate HCV prevalence, incidence, and treatment in an HIV-positive cohort of the urban poor | Prospective cohort study Probability sampling from homeless shelters, free food programs and SROs in 3 low-income neighborhoods |
Recently homeless: spent a night on the street or in a shelter in the past 30 d; lifetime homeless experience: total time homeless > 1 y | Other health outcomes: HCV |
Lifetime homeless experience significantly associated with baseline HCV-positive status Lifetime or recent homeless experience not associated with incident HCV infection during follow-up period |
Longitudinal studies: HIV risk behaviors | |||||
Cox et al.63; Canada | To examine the occurrence of drug use cessation and its correlates in a Canadian cohort of HIV–HCV coinfected drug users | Prospective cohort study Convenience sample of HIV–HCV coinfected IDUs or crack users, recruited from existing clinic populations |
Unstable housing: not having a fixed address (a personal address where mail can be delivered) | Risk behaviors Drug use |
Cessation of drug use was significantly more likely among participants with a fixed address |
Krishnan et al.61; CT, GA, IL, MA, NY, OH, PA, RI, SC | To examine substance abuse outcomes among a large cohort of HIV-infected jail detainees after release | Pre–post intervention study Convenience sample of PWH from 10 prisons taking part in intervention to transition from the jail to postrelease services |
Homeless: self-report being homeless or sleeping in a shelter or public space 30 d before incarceration; or 30 d before follow-up interview | Risk behaviors Drug use |
PWH who were homeless 30 d before incarceration were significantly more likely to use cocaine after release than were participants housed before incarceration PWH homeless at 6-mo follow-up were significantly more likely to use cocaine and opioids than were those stably housed |
Vijayaraghavanet al.65; San Francisco | To examine rates of and factors associated with opioid analgesic misuse in a community-sampled cohort of indigent adult PWH | Prospective cohort study Probability sampling from homeless shelters, free food programs and SROs in 3 low-income neighborhoods |
Currently homeless: sleeping on the street or in a shelter in the past 90 d | Risk behaviors Drug use |
In multivariate analysis, current homelessness was associated with opioid misuse |
Zelenev et al.80; CT, GA, IL, MA, NY, OH, PA, SC, RI | To examine correlates of homelessness and housing transitions and effect of housing status on HIV treatment outcomes | Pre–post intervention study Convenience sample of PWH from 10 prisons taking part in intervention to transition from the jail setting to postrelease services |
Homeless: self-report being homeless or sleeping in a shelter or public space 30 d before incarceration or 30 d before follow-up interview | Risk behaviors Drug use Other health Health QOL HIV clinical health |
Homelessness after incarceration was associated with higher odds of heroin, cocaine, and alcohol use and higher drug use and alcohol severity Homelessness after incarceration was associated with higher odds of depression and psychiatric severity and lower odds of physical and mental health quality of life PWH homeless at baseline less likely to have HIV provider, be on ART, or be adherent; individuals who were homeless at 6-mo follow-up had lower probability of being viral suppressed |
Shannon et al.76; Vancouver | Longitudinal examination of the impact of severe food insecurity on sexual risk taking among HIV-positive IDUs both on and not on HAART | Prospective cohort study Convenience sample of PWH recruited through snowball sampling and extensive street outreach methods in the city’s DTES (the drug use and HIV epicenter) |
Homeless: living primarily on the streets or staying in SROs | Risk behaviors Sex behavior |
Homelessness was not a significant predictor of unprotected sex |
Aidala et al.35; New York City | To examine overtime patterns of sexual behavior and sexual risk among a large, representative cohort of HIV-positive adults | Prospective cohort study Multistage probability sampling using sequential enrollment or list-based systematic random sampling of clients from a stratified sample of medical and social service agencies |
Homeless: sleeping on the street, drop-in center, or shelter, SRO, place not intended for sleeping Unstably housed: transitional housing, jail, treatment facility with no other place to live, temporarily doubled up in someone else’s home Own place and stably housed: permanent housing in an apartment, house, or congregate setting |
Risk behaviors Sex behavior |
Recent homelessness was associated with unprotected sex with HIV-negative or status unknown partner among men sexually active with women in unadjusted but not adjusted models Recent homelessness was associated with unprotected sex among sexually active women in both unadjusted and adjusted models Women who experienced recent homelessness were significantly more likely to exchange sex for money or drugs in both unadjusted and adjusted models |
Aidala et al.36; New York City | To examine sexual relationships and sexual behaviors among HIV-positive men sexually active with women and racial/ethnic differences in sexual behavior and sexual risk | Prospective cohort study Multistage probability sampling using sequential enrollment or list-based systematic random sampling of clients from a stratified sample of medical and social service agencies |
Homeless: sleeping on the street, drop-in center or shelter, SRO, place not intended for sleeping Unstably housed: transitional housing, jail, halfway house, treatment facility, doubled up in someone else’s home; own place and stably housed: permanent housing in an apartment, house, or congregate setting |
Risk behaviors Sex behavior |
In analyses over time, recent homelessness was associated with unprotected sex with an HIV-negative or status unknown woman partner among the total sample and among the subsample of African American men |
Aidala et al.31; 18 primarily urban US service areas | To examine HIV drug and sex risk behaviors among PWH with no or inadequate housing compared with PWH with stable housing; to examine change in risk behavior associated with change in housing status | Prospective cohort–pooled data from multisite intervention study Sequential enrollment at first visit for medical or social services during study period |
Homeless: sleeping on the street, place not intended for sleeping, shelter, SRO; unstably housed: in a temporary housing, jail, drug treatment with no other address, doubled up with others; improved housing status: change from homeless to unstably housed or stably housed, or from unstably housed to stably housed; worse housing status: change from stably housed to unstably housed or homeless, or from unstably housed to homeless | Risk behaviors Drug and sex behavior |
Recent drug use, needle use, or sex exchange at baseline higher among homeless and unstably housed PWH than among PWH with stable housing PWH whose housing status improved between baseline and follow-up significantly reduced drug use, needle use, needle sharing, and unprotected sex; PWH whose housing status worsened were more likely to engage in sex exchange In both cross-sectional and longitudinal analyses, homeless PWH had higher rates of risk behavior than did unstably housed PWH and both had higher rates of risk behaviors than did stably housed PWH |
Palepu et al.33; Boston | To examine the association of substance abuse treatment with sexual and drug use risk behaviors among PWH with a history of alcohol problems | Prospective cohort study Convenience sample of PWH screening positive for alcohol problems; recruited from primarily medical settings serving PWH including a respite care facility |
Homeless: ≥ 1 nights on the street or in a shelter in the past 6 mo | Risk behaviors Drug and sex behavior |
At baseline, homeless PWH with alcohol problems had higher drug risk scores than did those with no recent homeless experience; sexual risk scores were similar In overtime models, homeless status was associated with higher drug risk scores, regardless of receipt of alcohol or drug treatment |
Note. ART = antiretroviral treatment; CA-MRSA = community-associated methicillin-resistant Staphylococcus aureus; DTES = Downtown Eastside; ED = emergency department; HAART = highly active ART; IDU = injection drug user; PWH = people with HIV or AIDS; QOL = quality of life; RCT = randomized controlled trial; SES = socioeconomic status; SRO = single-room occupancy; VA = Veterans Affairs.