Skip to main content
. 2015 Dec 24;5(12):e008073. doi: 10.1136/bmjopen-2015-008073

Table 4.

Results of the risk of bias assessment

Study ID Reporting External validity Internal validity—bias Internal validity— confounding Total
Ament et al22 Unclear High High High High
Benenson et al23 Unclear High High High High
Cates24 High Unclear High High High
Enriquez-Puga et al25 Unclear High High Unclear High
Forsner et al26 Unclear Low High High High
Gerber et al35 Low Low High High High
Higuchi et al27 High High High High High
Kelly28 High High High High High
Knops et al29 High Low High High High
Loszadi et al30 Unclear High Unclear High High
McLaws et al31 High Low Unclear High High
Stéphan et al32 High High Unclear High High
Wakefield et al33 High High High High High
Williams et al34 High High Unclear High High
Total High High High High High