Skip to main content
. 2016 Jan 13;11(1):e0144198. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0144198

Table 1. Table of events of strong trends of early warning signals.

Event number Duration of high-Kendall in Power spectrum Nearest recorded crash (start date & source) EWS (time to crash) or False alarm
1 17/08/1906 to 09/11/1906 Panic of 1907 (14/03/1907) EWS (4 months)
2 26/07/1916 to 06/10/1916 none False alarm
3 29/06/1926 to 05/05/1927 1929 Crash (24/10/1929) EWS (3 years)
4 29/02/1929 to 14/10/1929 1929 Crash (24/10/1929) EWS (9 months)
5 13/04/1937 to 23/02/1939 1937 recession (26/9/1937) EWS (5 months)
6 30/07/1946 to 08/10/1947 none False alarm
7 30/08/1951 to 15/05/1952 none False alarm
8 26/11/1954 to 10/05/1957 none False alarm
9 02/11/1959 to 14/04/1961 none False alarm
10 26/09/1966 to 06/03/1968 none False alarm
11 06/09/1973 to 09/03/1975 Oil shock (2/11/1973) EWS (3 months)
12 15/07/1983 to 27/06/1984 Israel oil crisis (10/10/1983) EWS (3 months)
13 12/11/1986 to 04/08/1988 1987 Crash (19/10/1987) EWS (11 months)
14 12/10/1990 to 30/08/1991 none False alarm
15 26/12/1995 to 09/08/2000 Dot-com crash (21/03/2000) EWS (5 years)
16 15/02/2008 to 14/07/2009 2008 Crash (01/10/2008) EWS (9 months)

Table of events of strong trends, as determined by Kendall-τ exceeding a threshold value of 0.9 in both variance and power spectrum (see caption for Fig 2). Event numbers in this table correspond to those identified in Fig 2. Note that there are several false alarms, as discussed in the text. In addition, there were persistent EWS for five years preceding 2000 crash. Whereas, in most cases of EWS the crashes occurred within an year or so of the signal. This indicates that occurrence of an EWS is not a predictive measure of when the crash will occur.