Skip to main content
. 2015 Jul 15;101(1):F31–F36. doi: 10.1136/archdischild-2014-308071

Table 4.

Mean level of consensus for statements by factor 3 participants (mean levels of consensus for statements by factor 1 and 2 participants in parentheses for comparison)13

Factor 3 (n=6) F3 (F1, F2)
Technological developments mean that heroic means of extraordinary means of support are overused 5 (1, 2)
Parents who do not want a disabled child should be able to make the decision to withhold or withdraw full intensive care treatment 5 (1, 1)
It is wrong to knowingly bring a disabled child into this world 2 (−5, −1)
Resuscitation at <24/40 weeks is for the parents benefit, not for the infants 1 (−2, −1)
The most important factor when deciding on resuscitation is the parents decision 1 (−1, −1)
Babies born at <24/40 weeks gestation should always be resuscitated if the mother is too old to have any more children 0 (−3, −5)
Parents are given a false hope when they see all of the equipment used on their extremely preterm infant −1 (2, 1)
Life satisfaction is not possible if you have a disability −1 (−6, −3)
Women who try to conceive post menopause are not thinking about the best interests of the infant −1 (2, 1)
The philosophy underpinning nursing and medical care is the same in all healthcare settings, including neonatal and abortion services −2* (0, 1)
Women should have the right to choose abortion up until 24/40 weeks −2* (0, 5)
The amount of technology used in the neonatal unit is a barrier which is detrimental to parents infant bonding −2 (0, 1)
Deciding whether to withhold or withdraw treatment is too stressful for parents and should be done by the health care professionals −3 (0, 0)
Technology should be advanced to allow the most premature of infants to survive −4* (2, −1)
Infants born extremely preterm with life-limiting illness should still be given full intensive care treatment −5* (0, −3)
It is better to have a disabled child, no matter how disabled, than no child at all −6* (−2, −4)

All factors <0.05.

*Factors with p<0.01.