Skip to main content
. 2015 Dec;13(3-4):117–138. doi: 10.3121/cmr.2015.1272

Table S4.

Data Abstraction table B: Treatment outcomes (48 data sets).

Reference numbers Sample size of treated pan susceptible pulmonary TB and all forms of resistance except MDR-TB (N) N treated with each regimen Treatment outcomes Remarks
Completed Not completed
Success (cured and completed) Failed Died Relapsed Defaulted
[1] 105 57 25 7 7 1 18 Total on FDC 57
48 25 4 2 0 16 Total on separate formulation 48
[2] 67 67 58 3 0 6 0 67 patients on 2EHRZ/4RH
[3] 1355 456 231 47 17 20 74 The study included some HIV positives.
466 248 32 9 30 89
433 249 36 12 9 74
[4] 146 39 39 0 0 0 0
[5] 1585 798 591 19 8 48 9 39 on FDC and 38 patients on separate drugs were HIV positive.
787 589 16 8 42 1
[6] 837 415 347 32 26 0 27
422 320 27 21 0 55
[7] 198 198 193 0 0 4 0 67 of 198 patients were smear negative
[8] 360 162 152 5 2 0 2 Two patients on NTP regimen excluded due jaundice are reflected under TO
198 188 8 3 0 1
[9] 520 175 171 2 1 1 0
174 171 1 1 2 0
171 161 3 3 2 0
[10] 100 34 26 2 0 0 4
34 26 0 0 0 6
32 24 2 0 0 6
[11] 122 61 44 4 2 0 5
61 53 2 0 0 4
[12] 141 141 127 0 1 4 0
[13] 1159 582 468 24 11 7 43 FDC
577 477 16 4 4 41 ST
[14] 467 450 393 33 4 20 0
[15] 825 305 279 11 0 15 0 112 patients excluded due to ineligibility
263 234 1 0 28 0
[16] 170 165 144 5 1 10 2
[17] 497 170 113 7 6 0 46
165 103 7 7 0 53
162 105 3 3 0 53
[18] 434 236 208 12 3 10 4 FDC-119 have no bacteriological follow up data
198 179 7 3 2 4 Loose drugs-108 have no bacteriological follow up data
[19] 168 61 61 6 0 0 0 Detailed outcomes not given for all patients by regimen
58 58 20 0 0 0
[20] 1240 407 338 37 0 32 0 A third of included in the analysis were previously treated.
415 363 26 0 26 0
418 334 48 0 36 0
[21] 188 188 171 5 0 10 2
[22] 399 199 193 1 0 5 0 64 of drug sensitive and 13 of drug resistant had previous chemotherapy
200 199 0 0 1 0
[23] 98 87 86 1 0 0 0 32 patients were HIV positive
[24] 88 88 87 0 0 1 0
[25] 156 156 106 12 2 4 12 Rifampicin group
142 142 102 5 2 5 12 Rifabutin group
[26] 102 102 97 1 0 4 0
[27] 67 67 67 0 0 0 0