Table 2.
Facilitators and barriers for e-mental health utilization (N=17).
| Reference | E-therapy utilization: Facilitators | E-therapy utilization: Barriers | Non-significant factors |
| [23] | Motivated to seek face-to-face help rather than receive no help | Not preferring online treatment | Self-reliance |
| Females prefer face-to-face help | Shyness | ||
| Males who would have otherwise chosen no help | Lower mental health literacy | Stigma | |
| Higher mental health literacy | Viewing e-therapy as impersonal |
|
|
| Anonymity of the Internet | Lack of trust | ||
| Accessibility of information | Not knowing who you are talking to | ||
| Connecting with others who have been through the same thing | Lack of customized feedback | ||
| [24] | Knowledge about e-mental health through provision of textual information | Lack of knowledge about e-mental health | Type of e-mental health service |
|
|
Attitude that online programs without therapist assistance are not helpful |
|
|
| [26] | Female | Male | — |
| Higher education | Low education | ||
| Not married | Young age | ||
| History of depression | Lack of interest | ||
| Higher depressive symptoms | Stigma | ||
| More free time | Too busy | ||
|
|
Prefer to deal alone | ||
| [27] | High adherence | — | — |
| High satisfaction linked to likelihood of recommending to others | |||
| [28] | High satisfaction linked to likelihood of recommending to others | — | — |
| [29] | Attractive visual appeal | Technology issues | Individual mental health issues |
| Ease of use | Time constraints for service providers | Age | |
| Culturally appropriate | Concern for job security | Sex | |
| Enjoyable / fun | Translation into Indigenous languages |
|
|
| Appropriate training for service providers |
|
||
| [31] | Positive attitudes towards e-mental health in general | Male | — |
| Interactive games were not preferred | |||
| [32] | Privacy and anonymity | Ideas about masculinity | — |
|
|
Preference for reliance on informal networks | ||
| Preference for self-help | |||
| Generalized scepticism of “interventions” | |||
| [33] | Low severity of mental health symptoms | Lack of information about effectiveness of e-mental health | The need for reliable Internet |
|
|
Lack of knowledge about treatments available | Lack of computer skills | |
| Lack of established guidelines | IT support | ||
| Unclear about legal issues involved or liabilities of recommending e-therapies |
|
||
| Lack of training for health professionals | |||
| Preference for not seeking help at all over using e-mental health | |||
| Lack of experience in using e-mental health treatments | |||
| [34] | Good adherence | — | Low acceptability |
| High satisfaction, linked to likelihood of recommending e-mental health |
|
||
| [35] | Female | Male | Metropolitan versus rural location of residence |
| Younger age (15-54) | Older age | ||
| Low overall usage | |||
| [36] | High satisfaction | Therapist initial scepticism | — |
| [42] | Monitored settings, such as school-based settings | Unmonitored-settings | History of depression |
| Female | Male |
|
|
| Living in rural areas |
|
||
| [45] | Symptoms of depression, anxiety, or stress were more likely to be interested in mobile mental health | Perceived as not helpful | Sex |
| Negative attitudes towards technology | Age | ||
| Speed and convenience | Privacy concerns | Employment | |
| Ease of access | Lack of Internet access on mobile phone | Marital status | |
| Positive attitude towards self-help | Small screen of mobile phone |
|
|
| At least some access |
|
||
| Less confronting than face-to-face-consultation | |||
| [47] | Usability, privacy | Inadequate (private) Internet access in some rural settings | — |
| Provides some services to rural areas where there is a lack of service | Reading difficulties among consumers | ||
| Training for clinicians | Computer literacy | ||
| Provision of informational materials for providers and consumers | Difficulty accessing training in the rural environment | ||
| Ability for e-mental health to be integrated with existing care | Practitioner concerns about lack of feedback from clients, rumination or social isolation | ||
| Promotion of e-mental health as an effective treatment | Scepticism about the effectiveness of e-mental health treatments | ||
|
|
Lack of time to explore resources | ||
| [49] | Embarrassment of face-to-face | Prefer face-to-face | Got told not to use |
| Believed that e-mental health would be useful | Embarrassment | Lack of access to computer/Internet | |
| Privacy and anonymity | Perceived as not effective |
|
|
| Convenience | Cannot see a person | ||
| Bridges travel issues | Inferior to communication with therapist | ||
| Reduced costs | Do not know what e-mental health care is | ||
| Willingness to try | Prefer self-management | ||
| Useful for mild symptoms | Too confronting | ||
|
|
Problems not severe enough | ||
| Prefer medications | |||
| Sounds too risky | |||
| Lack of time | |||
| [50] | High level of satisfaction, related to likelihood of recommending treatment to a friend. | — | — |