Table 1.
Drug/Treatment | Pre-clinical studies | Clinical trial |
---|---|---|
Minocycline | Toxin MSA model (Stefanova et al. 2004b) anti-inflammatory, no neuroprotection Transgenic MSA model (Stefanova et al. 2007) anti-inflammatory, neuroprotection by early application |
MEMSA-trial (Dodel et al. 2010) anti-inflammatory, no change in progression |
Riluzole | Toxin model (Diguet et al. 2005; Scherfler et al. 2005) partial striatal neuroprotection, no motor improvement | NNIPPS study (Bensimon et al. 2009) no neuroprotection |
Rifampicin | Transgenic MSA model (Ubhi et al. 2008) protective | RDCRC (clinicaltrials.gov NCT01287221) no neuroprotection |
Rasagiline | Transgenic MSA model (Stefanova et al. 2008) protective | Multi-center study (Poewe et al. 2012) no change in progression |
Fluoxetine | Transgenic MSA model (Ubhi et al. 2012) protective | French clinical trial (clinicaltrial.gov NCT01146548) negative outcome |
MSCs | Toxin MSA model (Park et al. 2011) Transgenic MSA model (Stemberger et al. 2011) protective, immunomodulatory |
South Korean clinical trial (Lee et al. 2008, 2012) delayed progression |
Summary of putative neuroprotective and neuroimmunomodulatory treatments that were tested in pre-clinical studies. Due to the positive outcome in pre-clinical studies, clinical trials were conducted with the listed promising target drugs, yet the positive results gained in animal studies could not be replicated in MSA patients. Only the Korean study using mesenchymal stem cells (MSCs) could replicate the positive outcome of the pre-clinical trials. MEMSA-trial, Minocycline European Multiple System Atrophy-trial; NNIPPS, Neuroprotection and Natural History in Parkinson Plus Syndromes; RDCRC, Rare Diseases Clinical Research Consortia