Table 1.
Criteria and Prevalence for Consensus Definitions of Sarcopenia in the Osteoporotic Fractures in Men (MrOS) Study
| Slowness Definition | Prevalence | Weakness Definition | Prevalence | Low lean mass Definition | Prevalence | Summary definition Definition | Prevalence | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| International Working Group (IWG) | Gait speed <1.0 m/s | 17.4% (N=1034) | Not included | N/A | ALM/ht2 ≤7.23 kg/m2 | 20.9% (N=1239) | Sarcopenia: both slowness and low lean mass | 4.7% (N=277) |
| European Working Group on Sarcopenia Older Persons (EWGSOP) | Gait speed ≤0.8 m/s | 4.4% (N=262) | Grip strength <30 kg | 8.0% (N=474) | ALM/ht2 ≤7.23 kg/m2 | 20.9% (N=1239) | 1) Sarcopenia: low lean mass plus either slowness or weakness 2) Severe sarcopenia: all three criteriaa |
1) 4.3% (N=257) 2) 0.4% (N=26) |
| Foundation for the NIH (FNIH) Sarcopenia Project primary definition | Gait speed ≤0.8 m/s | 4.4% (N=262) | Grip strength <26 kg | 3.9% (N=233) | ALM/BMI <0.789b | 17.3% (N=1025) | 1) weakness and low lean mass 2) slowness with weakness and low lean mass |
1) 1.5% (N=88) 2) 0.3% (N=18) |
| Baumgartner | Not included | N/A | Not included | N/A | ALM/ht2 ≤7.23 kg/m2 | 20.9% (N=1239) | Presence of low lean mass | 20.9% (N=1239) |
| Newman | Not included | N/A | Not included | N/A | Residual of actual ALM - predicted ALM from equationc | 20.0% (N=1186) | Presence of low lean mass | 20.0% (N=1186) |
Since prevalence of EWGSOP severe sarcopenia was low, both sarcopenia and severe sarcopenia were analyzed together
The FNIH Sarcopenia Project also proposed an alternative definition using ALM<19.75 kg for low lean mass (prevalence: 8.9%, N=525). Using the alternative definition, prevalence of “weakness and low lean mass” was 1.1% (N=67) and prevalence of “slowness with weakness and low lean mass” was 0.3% (N=16).
The equation used to calculate residuals was ALM (kg) =− 22.48 +24.14*height(m) + 0.21*total fat mass (kg) as derived for men in the Health ABC study (17); the cut-point for the residual was ≤−0.204 kg/m2
ALM=appendicular lean mass, NIH = National Institute of Health