Skip to main content
. 2016 Feb 3;11(2):e0148025. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0148025

Table 3. DMI resistance phenotype and cyp51 sequence information for Erysiphe necator isolates with various DMI sensitivities.

Isolate RF a 136th Codon in Cyp51 Other SNPs Mean RQg
Teb Myc Fen Sequencingb Repeat sequencingc Genotypingd nt 1119e nt 1170f
BLP1 1 0.4 0.3 TAT nt wild-type A G 1.00e
BLP4 1 3 0.7 TAT TAT wild-type A G nt
MVP9 1 1 2 TAT nt wild-type A A 1.10e
PBP1 1 0.6 1 TAT nt wild-type A A 1.34e
SCCP4 2 0.05 2 TAT TAT wild-type A A nt
SNP1 1 nt nt TAT TAT wild-type nt nt nt
SNP3 0.6 nt nt TAT TAT wild-type nt nt nt
FH9-1 0.4 nt nt TAT TAT nt nt nt nt
VAHP6 24 33 20 TAT TAT mix/wild-type C G nt
BXP1A 7 6 7 TTT TTT pure mutant A A 6.03d
GRP15 12 0.02 17 TTT nt pure mutant A A nt
GRP18 18 59 11 TTT TTT pure mutant A A nt
IVP3 2 0.2 2 TTT nt pure mutant A A 1.40e
IVP11 66 nt 15 TTT nt pure mutant A A nt
MDMRP5 22 35 7 TTT nt pure mutant A A 10.98c
MDMRP7 25 68 24 TTT TTT pure mutant A A 12.92b
PRP7 46 104 15 TTT nt pure mutant A A nt
ROP14 27 53 11 TTT TTT pure mutant A A nt
SUP13-2 11 34 5 TTT nt pure mutant A A nt
VAHP1 10 6 5 TTT nt pure mutant A A 1.85e
AMP1 65 23 59 TAT TWT mix C R 12.06c
IVP4 23 53 29 TAT TWT mix C R 10.73bc
JRP3 29 68 44 TAT TWT mix C R nt
VAHP4 25 27 32 TWT TWT mix C R 11.58bc
JRP1 32 87 8 TWT nt mix C R nt
JRP4 38 64 27 TWT TWT mix C R 18.85a
JWP1 137 45 79 TWT nt mix C R nt

nt–not tested; cultures were either lost or isolates not selected for assays

a Resistance factor from EC50 mean of three assays per culture; Teb = tebuconazole; Myc = myclobutanil; Fen = fenarimol

b Corresponding to codon 136; TAT = tyrosine (Y), TTT = phenylalanine (F), TWT = double peak for middle nucleotide in sequence chromatograph

c Repeat sequencing with primer pair L419/R419

d Genotyping at the 136th codon: wild-type = TAT; pure mutant = TTT; mix = TTT/TAT or TWT

e Nucleotide 1119 displaying synonymous mutation at codon 326 (Ala-GCC/A; standard ambiguity code M for A/C)

f Nucleotide 1170 displaying a synonymous mutation at codon 343 (Gly = GGG/A; standard ambiguity code R for A/G)

g Cyp51 cDNA levels were quantified by the comparative CT method (∆∆CT) in the StepOne Plus instrument (Applied Biosystems). Relative expression (relative quantification, RQ) was calculated as 2-∆∆CT. Means with the same letter are not significantly different at ∝ = 0.05