Skip to main content
. 2016 Feb 5;11(2):e0148671. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0148671

Table 3. Most significant (top 10) QTLs and representative SNPs for field and seedling traits.

Trait QTL Marker blast Chr Position p.MLM p.QGLM RSQ eff R Sub pop1 Sub pop2 Sub pop3 postulation reference
Race.1 1B_2 IWB13336 NA 1B 85.57 7.84E-05 1.39E-06 0.05 2.76 C 78 99 108 Lr26? Kolmer 2003
Race.1 1D_t1 IWB14612 1DS_1885467 1D 45.44 3.85E-04 2.77E-05 0.04 2.48 A 77 107 101 Lr42? Liu et al 2013
Race.1 4A_t2 IWB3569 4AL_v2_7176180 4A 144.38 5.59E-04 1.08E-05 0.04 2.32 A 10 107 83 Lr28? Bipinraj et al 2011
Race.1 5B_2 IWB9055 NA 5B 49.65 5.08E-05 1.44E-06 0.06 2.35 G 76 101 78 QLr. cdl-5BL? Kolmer 2015
Race.1 5D_1 IWB53861 NA 5D 203.88 1.17E-04 2.32E-05 0.05 -2.58 A 3 16 30 Lr1 Kolmer 2003
Race.1 6A_2 IWB625.2 NA 6A 100.62 2.23E-04 5.76E-06 0.05 1.97 G 75 57 87 Lr64? -
Race.1 6B_1 IWB65148 NA 6B 16.76 9.43E-04 4.82E-06 0.04 2.51 G 9 114 102 - -
Race.1 6B_3 IWB65914 6BL_4378239 6B 66.36 2.33E-03 3.06E-04 0.03 1.83 G 43 110 112 Lr9? Kolmer 2003
Race.1 6B_4 IWB3292 6BL_4278271 6B 122.92 6.02E-07 1.18E-07 0.09 -3.43 C 4 14 23 Lr3 Kolmer 2003
Race.1 7B_3 IWA306 7BL_6747122 7B 76.31 2.09E-04 9.56E-07 0.05 3.16 G 75 115 115 Lr14? Kolmer 2003
Race.CA1.2 1B_1 IWB19584 NA 1B 63.91 9.21E-03 3.24E-04 0.02 -2.46 G 4 3 20 QLr.cimmyt-1BS Rosewarne 2012
Race.CA1.2 1D_3 IWB35520 1DL_2290849 1D 89.58 3.96E-04 5.16E-08 0.04 2.42 A 79 113 94 Lr21?
Race.CA1.2 2A_3 IWA3151 2AL_6426630 2A 108.46 5.61E-03 2.97E-05 0.03 -1.40 T 4 49 104 Lr11.Lr38? Darino 2015
Race.CA1.2 2B_2 IWB37811 2BS_5186722 2B 93.47 9.08E-05 8.75E-08 0.05 1.91 G 73 47 82 Lr13.Lr23.Lr16? Oelke & Kolmer 2005
Race.CA1.2 4A_2 IWB40915 4AS_v2_6008166 4A 48.52 6.04E-03 1.13E-04 0.03 1.95 T 79 116 95 - -
Race.CA1.2 4A_t2 IWB3569 4AL_V2_7176180 4A 144.38 7.94E-03 1.86E-04 0.02 1.57 A 10 107 83 Lr28? Bipinraj et al 2011
Race.CA1.2 6B_3 IWB65914 6BL_4378239 6B 66.36 5.05E-04 1.16E-06 0.04 1.89 G 43 110 112 Lr9? Kolmer 2003
Race.CA1.2 6B_4 IWB6474 NA 6B 119.73 8.78E-05 1.53E-05 0.06 2.27 G 9 110 95 Lr3 Kolmer 2003
Race.CA1.2 7B_1 IWB39492 7BS_3168118 7B 58.17 4.03E-03 1.60E-02 0.03 1.76 A 72 111 113 Lr72? Herrera-Foessel et al. 2014
Race.CA1.2 7B_2 IWB68484 7BS_3079273 7B 66.62 1.22E-04 3.19E-07 0.05 4.06 T 80 111 126 Lr14? Singh et al. 2009
Race.Mix 1A_3 IWB48030 1AL_3976804 1A 149.82 3.55E-03 5.99E-04 0.03 1.72 G 10 113 103 QLr.umn-1AL *
Race.Mix 1B_1 IWB19584 NA 1B 63.91 3.77E-04 2.67E-07 0.05 -3.44 G 4 3 20 QLr.cimmyt-1BS Rosewarne et al 2012
Race.Mix 1D_1 IWB44021 1DS_1912623 1D 8.71 1.46E-03 9.51E-07 0.04 -3.22 T 4 3 17 Lr42? Liu et al 2013
Race.Mix 2A_1 IWB74529 NA 2A 20.14 2.58E-04 4.56E-06 0.05 2.10 C 79 36 121 Lr17? Kolmer 2003
Race.Mix 3A_t2 IWB34789 3AL_4449581 3A 169.89 1.16E-03 3.57E-05 0.04 1.57 G 8 61 105 QLr.fcu-3AL? Chu et al. 2009
Race.Mix 3B_t2 IWB74350 3B_10762316 3B 51.07 6.69E-04 8.56E-05 0.04 1.74 A 73 83 85 - -
Race.Mix 4B_3 IWB72129 4BL_7035179 4B 86.55 2.93E-03 4.75E-06 0.03 1.55 G 76 80 103 Lr30? Draz et al 2015
Race.Mix 4D_1 IWB17540 4DS_2288313 4D 70.59 2.31E-04 1.78E-07 0.05 -3.35 T 6 3 19 ?
Race.Mix 6A_3 IWA7764 6AL_5772638 6A 119.64 2.28E-04 1.13E-06 0.06 2.12 C 74 60 83 - -
Race.Mix 6B_3 IWB11702 6BL_4398818 6B 66.36 7.02E-04 5.60E-05 0.04 1.86 T 43 111 125 Lr9? Kolmer 2003
Field.COI 1A_3 IWB48030 1AL_3976804 1A 149.82 1.11E-04 7.23E-06 0.05 12.98 G 10 113 103 QLr.umn-1AL *
Field.COI 2A_3 IWA3151 2AL_6426630 2A 108.46 4.38E-04 1.17E-06 0.04 -10.14 T 4 49 104 Lr11? Darino et al 2015
Field.COI 2B_2 IWB22236 2BS_5202128 2B 88.44 4.52E-04 6.65E-06 0.04 10.02 T 13 79 104 Lr13.Lr23.Lr16? Oelke & Kolmer 2005
Field.COI 3A_t2 IWB34789 3AL_4449581 3A 169.89 4.31E-04 8.19E-06 0.04 9.48 G 8 61 105 QLr.fcu-3AL? Chu et al. 2009
Field.COI 4A_1 IWB59410 4AS_v2_5925149 4A 37.05 4.17E-05 7.73E-06 0.05 11.23 T 7 74 99 QLr.umn-4AS *
Field.COI 4A_3 IWB7998 NA 4A 51.7 6.67E-04 1.11E-04 0.04 -9.63 T 38 38 16 - -
Field.COI 4B_3 IWB7278 4BL_6967384 4B 78.96 1.56E-04 6.47E-06 0.04 13.46 T 81 108 103 QLr.cimmyt-4BL? William et al 2006
Field.COI 5B_2 IWB39735 5BL_10794137 5B 49.01 1.69E-04 6.69E-06 0.04 20.17 C 80 115 124 QLr. cdl-5BL? Kolmer 2015
Field.COI 6A_t1 IWB40242 NA 6A 48.09 4.97E-04 3.26E-04 0.04 -11.69 T 4 10 61 - -
Field.COI 7B_4 IWB64015 7BL_6699942 7B 166.99 5.03E-04 9.98E-05 0.04 10.87 T 75 107 81 Lr68 Herrera-Foessel et al 2012

Column "Marker", underlining indicates SNPs detected by or significant in stepwise regression models.

Columns "p.MLM" and "p.QGLM" reflect p-values from the MLM and QGLM methods, underlining indicates p-values passing the simpleM threshold.

Column R indicates resistance (or favorable) allele.

Columns “RSQ” and “eff” indicate marker R2 and effects based on MLM models.

Columns “Sub pop1”, “Sub pop2” and “Sub pop3” indicate number of favorable allele within each sub-populations. Column "postulation" are postulated genes or QTLs based on position, infection type, and donor parents or pedigree information. Some of the loci names were adopted from Li et al [41]. The postulated gene or QTLs followed by questions marks "?" are primarily based on position and infection type (pedigree or donor line information was unobtainable).

Column "reference" shows literature reports that support our loci postulation. Dash "-" signs indicate that the corresponding p-values are below the simpleM threshold and loci identity were not postulated. Asterisks "*" indicate potentially novel loci identified through this study.