Table 2.
Genetic engineering strategies and combinational therapies potentiating CAR T-cell efficacy
(A) Genetic engineering strategies potentiating CAR T cells | |||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|
Transgene Effects | Antigen targeted | Tumor targeted | References | ||
Improve infiltration/migration | CCR2 | Promotes CAR T-cell trafficking to the tumor following systemic administration | MSLN GD2 |
Mesothelioma Neuroblastoma |
(54, 80) |
CCR4 | Promotes CAR T-cell trafficking to the tumor following systemic administration | CD30 | Lymphoma | (92) | |
Heparanase | Degrades the extracellular matrix, thereby improving CAR T-cell tumor infiltration and efficacy | CSPG4 GD2 |
Melanoma Neuroblastoma |
(93) | |
Improve CAR T-cell effector function | Active akt | The constitutive Akt expression improves CAR T-cell survival, proliferation, cytokine secretion and renders them resistant to Treg suppression | GD2 | Neuroblastoma | (82) |
IL-12 | Increases effector cytokine secretion, renders CAR T cells resistant to Treg-mediated inhibition, and induces host innate immune response | CD19 CD30 MUC-16 CEA VEGFR |
Leukemia Lymphoma Ovarian Colon melanoma, sarcoma, and colon cancer stroma |
(94–97) | |
IL-15 | Improves T-cell expansion and reduces PD-1 expression | CD19 | Leukemia | (98, 99) | |
IL-7 or IL-7R | Increases proliferation, survival and effector function of CAR T cells even in the presence of Tregs | CD19 GD2 |
Leukemia Neuroblastoma |
(99, 100) | |
IL-21 | Increases CAR T-cell proliferation and cytotoxic efficacy | CD19 | Leukemia | (99, 101) | |
CD80 or 4-1BBL | Trans-/autocostimulation between CAR T cells enhancing effector functions | PSMA | Prostate | (102) | |
CD40L | Enhances tumor cell immunogenicity, stimulates moDC and increases CAR T-cell cytotoxic efficacy | CD19 | Leukemia | (103) | |
4αβ chimeric cytokine receptor | 4αβ generated by the fusion of IL-4R ectodomain and IL-2R and IL-15R subunit enhances CAR T-cell long term proliferation and cytotoxicity | MUC1 PSMA ERBBR |
Breast Prostate Head and Neck |
(104) | |
Counteract immunosuppression | shRNA CTLA4 | Decreased CTLA4 expression enhances CAR T-cell proliferation and antitumor activity | CD19 | Leukemia | (105) |
Improve specificity and safety | iCAR ‘safety switch’ | iCAR with PD-1 or CTLA-4 inhibitory intracellular domain linked to secondary antigen constrains CAR T-cell specificity to cancer cells expressing the primary antigen | PSMA | Prostate | (106) |
(B) Preclinical investigation of combinational therapies potentiating CAR T-cell efficacy | |||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|
Agents Effects | Antigen targeted | Tumor targeted | References | ||
Preconditioning | Radiotherapy | Total body irradiation (TBI)-induced lymphodepletion in the host promotes CAR T-cell efficacy | EGFRvIII | Glioblastoma | (107) |
Flutamide | Fludamide-induced androgen ablation acts in additive with CAR T cells in vitro | MUC-1 | Prostate | (108) | |
Valproate | Sodium Valproate-induced upregulation of tumor cell-surface NKG2DL expression enhances the immune recognition of CAR T cells in vitro | NKG2DL | Ovarian | (109) | |
Monoclonal antibodies | PD-L1 or PD-1 immune checkpoint blockade | Blocking the PD-1 immunosuppressive signaling enhances CAR T-cell proliferation, cytotoxicity and cytokine secretion | CEA MSLN HER2 |
Liver metastases from colon cancer Mesothelioma Sarcoma |
(48, 65, 110) |
Bispecific antibodies EGFR/cMet or EGFR/Epcam | Bispecific antibodies link EGFR-transduced CAR T cells to antigen-expressing tumor cells enhancing CAR T-cell recruitment/retention and cytotoxicity | CEA cMet Epcam |
Colon | (111) | |
Anti GM-CSF or Gr-1 | Reduction of Myeloid-derived suppressor cells population (MDSC) | CEA | Liver metastases from colon cancer | (65) | |
Small specific inhibitory drug | ABT-737 | Improves CAR T-cell killing by restoring apoptosis pathway in tumor cells | CD19 | Leukemia | (112) |
Rapamycin | Inhibition of mTor kinase decreases the expression of anti-apoptotic molecules and others (VEGF, PD-L1, IL-10) leading to a superior antitumor effect of CAR T cells engineered with mTor resistance | CD19 | Leukemia | (113) | |
BRAFi/MEKi | Inhibition of MAPK pathway blocks tumor cell growth and enhances apoptotic killing by CAR T cells in vitro | GD2 | Melanoma | (114) | |
Oncolytic virus | Adenovirus vector expressing Rantes and IL-15 | Adenovirus vector-mediated Rantes and IL-15 expression in the tumor enhances CAR T-cell infiltration and persistence | GD2 | Neuroblastoma | (115) |
Whole cell vaccine | Irradiated K562 cells expressing CD40L and OX40L | Vaccination boosts antitumor efficacy of CAR T cells | GD2 | Lung Neuroblastoma |
(116) |