Acquisition and extinction of responding in Experiment 2. a.) Procurement and consumption response rate elevation scores. b.) Average response rate on each manipulandum in pre-procurement, procurement, and consumption SD periods (pre-SP, SP, and SC, respectively) collapsed over group. L and R refer to the different chains with left and right lever consumption manipulanda, respectively, “+” and “−” refer to response rates in reinforced and non-reinforced trials, respectively. c.) Accuracy on probe trials during acquisition. d.) Elevation scores of each consumption response in 4-trial blocks across sessions of extinction. “L” and “R” refer to consumption responses that were preceded by left- and right-lever procurement responses in acquisition, respectively. Error bars are the standard error of the mean, and only appropriate for between-group visual comparisons.