Skip to main content
. 2015 Dec 23;36(1):14–24. doi: 10.1177/1539449215618625

Table 3.

Risk of Bias Within and Across Studies.

Studies Random sequence generation Allocation concealment Blinding of participants and personnel Blinding of outcome assessment Incomplete outcome data Selective reporting
Full studies in alphabetical order (except where protocol and finding reports are grouped and had different first authors)
Bundy et al. (2011), Engelen et al. (2013) ? graphic file with name 10.1177_1539449215618625-img1.jpg graphic file with name 10.1177_1539449215618625-img2.jpg graphic file with name 10.1177_1539449215618625-img2.jpg graphic file with name 10.1177_1539449215618625-img1.jpg graphic file with name 10.1177_1539449215618625-img1.jpg
Dopp et al. (2011), Döpp et al. (2014) ? ? graphic file with name 10.1177_1539449215618625-img2.jpg graphic file with name 10.1177_1539449215618625-img1.jpg graphic file with name 10.1177_1539449215618625-img2.jpg graphic file with name 10.1177_1539449215618625-img1.jpg
Eklund, Gunnarsson, Sandlund, and Leufstadius (2014) graphic file with name 10.1177_1539449215618625-img2.jpg graphic file with name 10.1177_1539449215618625-img1.jpg graphic file with name 10.1177_1539449215618625-img2.jpg ? ? graphic file with name 10.1177_1539449215618625-img1.jpg
Eyssen et al. (2013) graphic file with name 10.1177_1539449215618625-img1.jpg graphic file with name 10.1177_1539449215618625-img1.jpg graphic file with name 10.1177_1539449215618625-img1.jpg graphic file with name 10.1177_1539449215618625-img1.jpg ? graphic file with name 10.1177_1539449215618625-img1.jpg
Law et al. (2007), Law et al. (2011) graphic file with name 10.1177_1539449215618625-img1.jpg graphic file with name 10.1177_1539449215618625-img1.jpg graphic file with name 10.1177_1539449215618625-img2.jpg graphic file with name 10.1177_1539449215618625-img1.jpg graphic file with name 10.1177_1539449215618625-img2.jpg graphic file with name 10.1177_1539449215618625-img1.jpg
Mozley et al. (2007) graphic file with name 10.1177_1539449215618625-img1.jpg graphic file with name 10.1177_1539449215618625-img1.jpg graphic file with name 10.1177_1539449215618625-img2.jpg graphic file with name 10.1177_1539449215618625-img2.jpg ? graphic file with name 10.1177_1539449215618625-img1.jpg
Sackley et al. (2006) graphic file with name 10.1177_1539449215618625-img1.jpg graphic file with name 10.1177_1539449215618625-img1.jpg graphic file with name 10.1177_1539449215618625-img2.jpg graphic file with name 10.1177_1539449215618625-img1.jpg ? graphic file with name 10.1177_1539449215618625-img1.jpg
Sackley et al. (2012), Sackley et al. (2015) graphic file with name 10.1177_1539449215618625-img1.jpg graphic file with name 10.1177_1539449215618625-img1.jpg graphic file with name 10.1177_1539449215618625-img2.jpg graphic file with name 10.1177_1539449215618625-img1.jpg graphic file with name 10.1177_1539449215618625-img1.jpg graphic file with name 10.1177_1539449215618625-img1.jpg
Taylor et al. (2012) graphic file with name 10.1177_1539449215618625-img1.jpg graphic file with name 10.1177_1539449215618625-img2.jpg graphic file with name 10.1177_1539449215618625-img2.jpg ? graphic file with name 10.1177_1539449215618625-img1.jpg graphic file with name 10.1177_1539449215618625-img1.jpg
Wenborn et al. (2013) ? graphic file with name 10.1177_1539449215618625-img1.jpg graphic file with name 10.1177_1539449215618625-img2.jpg ? ? graphic file with name 10.1177_1539449215618625-img1.jpg
Protocols
Barzel et al. (2013) ? graphic file with name 10.1177_1539449215618625-img1.jpg graphic file with name 10.1177_1539449215618625-img2.jpg graphic file with name 10.1177_1539449215618625-img1.jpg graphic file with name 10.1177_1539449215618625-img1.jpg graphic file with name 10.1177_1539449215618625-img1.jpg
Killaspy et al. (2013) ? ? graphic file with name 10.1177_1539449215618625-img2.jpg graphic file with name 10.1177_1539449215618625-img1.jpg graphic file with name 10.1177_1539449215618625-img1.jpg graphic file with name 10.1177_1539449215618625-img1.jpg
McCluskey, et al. (2013) graphic file with name 10.1177_1539449215618625-img1.jpg graphic file with name 10.1177_1539449215618625-img1.jpg graphic file with name 10.1177_1539449215618625-img1.jpg graphic file with name 10.1177_1539449215618625-img1.jpg graphic file with name 10.1177_1539449215618625-img1.jpg graphic file with name 10.1177_1539449215618625-img1.jpg
Tokolahi, Hocking, Kersten, and Vandal (2014) graphic file with name 10.1177_1539449215618625-img1.jpg graphic file with name 10.1177_1539449215618625-img1.jpg graphic file with name 10.1177_1539449215618625-img2.jpg graphic file with name 10.1177_1539449215618625-img1.jpg graphic file with name 10.1177_1539449215618625-img1.jpg graphic file with name 10.1177_1539449215618625-img1.jpg

Note. ? = risk of bias unclear; Inline graphic = low risk of bias; Inline graphic = high risk of bias.