TABLE 3.
Characteristics and approximate costs of screening methods to identify fecal carriage of CPE
Method (reference) | Description | Turnaround time for positive or preliminary positive result (h) | Price (US$)a |
---|---|---|---|
CDC protocol (138) | Broth enrichment of rectal swab in ertapenem medium followed by subculture on MacConkey agar with carbapenem disk, followed by identification of suspect isolates | 48–72e | Negative test result, 1–2b; positive test result, 2–6b |
Supercarba (149) | Direct plating of rectal swab in selective medium | 24–48e | 1c |
Chromogenic medium | Direct plating of rectal swab in selective medium with chromogenic molecule | 24–48e | 4–7 |
Real-time PCRd (in-house methods) | DNA extraction followed by PCR and probe-based detection | 2–5 | 10–30b |
Commercial PCR assayd | DNA extraction followed by PCR and probe-based detection. | 2–3 possible | 30–60b |
U.S. dollars as of 2015.
Based on cost data by Mathers et al. (136).
Supercarba medium has been patented. The cost is that of raw materials; this medium is not available to many laboratories.
The cost of the PCR assay may increase with increased numbers of targets.
Confirmation testing might include singleplex PCR, multiplex PCR, Carba NP, Blue-Carba, or identification and susceptibility testing. The cost may range from an additional $2 to $50, and the turnaround time may range from an additional 2 to 24 h for confirmatory testing, depending on the methods chosen by the laboratory. Hospital epidemiology can act on negative results and preliminary positive results, pending confirmation. Negative NAAT results likely do not require confirmatory testing, but positive results may require confirmation, depending on the false-positive rate of the assay.