Table 1. Summary of the demographic information for studies included in the meta-analysis.
Study | Level of evidence | No. of patients | Age (y) | Duration of follow-up (mo) | Fracture type | Neurologic deficit | Fusion | Operative fixation |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Vanek et al 201413 | II | A: 18; B:17 | A: 39.4; B: 45.6 | 24 | Thoracolumbar AO A3.1–A3.3 | No | No | A: open short-segment pedicle screw; B: MIS short-segment pedicle screw |
Wang et al 201414 | III | A: 22; B: 39 | A: 46; B: 41.3 | A: 22.6; B: 21.7 | Thoracolumbar AO type A | No | No | A: open short-segment 4 pedicle screws; B: MIS short-segment 4 or 6 pedicle screws |
Dong et al 201315 | III | A: 17; B: 21 | A: 36.3; B: 36.3 | 17.3 | Thoracolumbar AO type A, B1.2, or B2.3 | No | No | A: open short-segment pedicle screw; B: MIS short-segment pedicle screw |
Lee et al 20135 | III | A: 32; B: 27 | A: 36.3; B: 36.3 | A: 30.2; B: 39.7 | Single-level thoracolumbar (T11–T12) | No | No | A: open short-segment pedicle screw; B: MIS short-segment pedicle screw |
Grossbach et al 201312 | III | A: 11; B: 27 | A: 40.1; B: 27.4 | A: 9; B: 18.5 | Thoracolumbar flexion-distraction (AO B1.2 most common) | No | No | A: open short-segment pedicle screw; B: MIS short-segment pedicle screw |
Jiang et al 201211 | I | A: 31; B: 30 | A: 42.4; B: 42.4 | 59 | Single-level thoracolumbar (T11–L2) | No | No | A: open short-segment pedicle screw; B: MIS short-segment pedicle screw |
Abbreviations: A, group A, open pedicle screw placement; B, group B, percutaneous pedicle screw placement; MIS, minimally invasive surgery.