TABLE 5.

EQ-5D Summary of Results

Author, Year	Convergent Validity			Validity—Known Groups				Responsiveness TSS			Responsiveness ES/SRM
H1	H2	H3	H1	H2	H3	H4	H1	H2	H3	H1
Aghayev et al, 201049				√				√	√
Bastiaenen et al, 200824								±	±	X
Berg et al, 200925	√
Berg et al, 200926								√	√	√
Burstrom et al, 200141		√				√
Carr et al, 200527								±	±	√
Casserley-Feeney et al, 201228								±	±	√
Cheshire et al, 201150								√
Chown et al, 200829								√	√	√
Cox et al, 201030									±
Del Pozo-Cruz et al, 201131											√
Djais et al, 200532								±	±	√
Eker et al, 200751	?	X				√
Garratt et al, 200152	√										√
Genevay et al, 201253	√		√
Gilbert et al, 200433								±	√	√
Gilbert et al, 200434								±	√	√
Gutke et al, 201154	√
Gutke et al, 200655				√
Hellum et al, 201135								√	±	√
Hurley et al, 200136								±		√
Jansson et al, 200956						√		±	–
Kendrick et al, 200137										X
Klemenc-Ketis, 201142	√					√
Klemenc-Ketis, 201157	√										√
Kovacs et al, 200558	√	√ X						–		√
Kovacs et al, 200459	√	√ X
Miller et al, 200238										X
Muraki et al, 201143				√	√
Muraki et al, 201044				√	√
Parker et al, 201245				√				√		√
Rivero-Arrias et al, 200639								–
Schluessman et al, 200946								√
Sogaard et al, 200947		X
Suarez-Almazor et al, 200048	√			√							√
Van der Roer et al, 200660				√			√	–
Wilkens et al, 201040								±	±	√ X

Keys: √ Meeting prior expectations; ± trend meeting prior expectation but not statistically significant; - trend meeting prior expectation but no test of statistical significance performed; X trend nonmeeting prior expectations; ? mixed/not possible to assess.

When two keys for the same item are used, it is because more than one result was found.

ES indicates effect size; H1, hypothesis 1; H2, hypothesis 2; H3, hypothesis 3; H4, hypothesis 4; TSS, test of statistical significance.