Table 2. Properties of the optical clearing agents and clearing procedures utilized within the present study.
Processing + Clearing Time3 | ||||||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Clearing (and Mounting) Agents | Concentration1 and Molecular Weight (g/mol) of Final Clearing Agent | RI2 | Aqueous vs. Non-Aqueous | Single- or Multi-step Procedure | Murine Bone Segments | Intact Murine Knee Joints | Cost of Clearing Agents4 ($US/mL) | References |
Water5 | 100% Water (MW 18.02) | 1.34 | Aq | Single | Not Applicable | Not Applicable | Not Applicable | |
Visikol | 100% Visikol (Makeup and MWs are Proprietary) | 1.45 | Aq | Single | ~24-hrs | 4-d | $1.20 | www.visikol.com |
Clear T2 | 50% formamide (MW 45.04) + 20% PEG (MW ~8000) | 1.45 | Aq | Multi | ~48-hrs | 6-d | $0.41 | [39] |
Focus Clear | 100% Focus Clear (Makeup and MWs are Proprietary) | 1.46 | Aq | Single | 2-d | 6-d | $78.00 | www.cedarlanelabs.com |
2, 2'-thiodiethanol (TDE) | 97% TDE (MW 122.19) in water | 1.47 | Aq | Multi | 2-d | 4-d | $1.04 | [41] |
See Deep Brain (SeeDB) | 80.2% D-fructose wt/wt (MW 180.16) in water | 1.50 | Aq | Multi | 4-d | 14-d | $0.29 | [40] |
Methyl salicylate (MS) | 100% MS (MW 152.15) | 1.51 | Non-Aq | Multi | 4-d | 7-d | $0.31 | [58] |
Benzyl benzoate-benzyl alcohol (BABB) | 25% benzyl alcohol (MW 108.14) + 75% benzyl benzoate (MW 212.24) | 1.53 | Non-Aq | Multi | 4-d | 7-d | $0.30 | [43] |
Tetrahydrofuran-dibenzyl ether (THF-DBE) | 100% DBE (MW 198.26) | 1.56 | Non-Aq | Multi | 4-d | 7-d | $0.16 | [42] |
Acrylic6 | 85% methyl methacrylate (MW 100.12) + 15% n-butyl phthalate (MW 278.34) + 2% benzoyl peroxide (wt/vol) (MW 242.23) | 1.49 | Non-Aq | Multi | 9-d | 14-d | $1.13 | [26] |
1All concentrations are indicated as vol/vol unless otherwise noted
2RI values obtained from literature
3Values indicate approximate total time required for full processing and clearing protocol
4Reference provided is for the cost of clearing reagents only at the time of the study; cost of common processing reagents (e.g. ethanol, etc.) was not included
5Water refers to non-cleared samples immersed in deionized water
6Acrylic refers to the plastic embedding procedure; samples are infiltrated with the indicated agents and then polymerized within the solid support matrix