Skip to main content
. 2016 Mar 7;11(3):e0148496. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0148496

Table 1. Assessment of the quality of the studies.

Studies included in the meta-analysis
Study Was the research question stated clearly? Were the patients with stroke recruited in an acceptable way? Is the control group a non-clinical population? Is the control group adequately described? Was sleep assessed and reported comprehensively?* What confounding variables have the authors accounted for?
Arzt et al. 2010 [21] Yes Yes Yes Yes1 Yes BMI (m ± sd)
Terzoudi et al. 2009 [26] Yes Yes No Yes Yes Barthel Index, m score
Gottselig et al. 2002 [27] Yes Yes No Yes Yes /
Müller et al. 2002 [28] Yes Yes No Yes Yes /
Bassetti and Aldrich 2001 [29] Yes Yes No Yes1 Yes Scandinavian Stroke Scale (m ± sd)
Santamaria et al. 2000 [30] Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes n for hypertension, diabetes, smoking
Mohsenin and Valor 1995 [33] Yes Yes No No Yes BMI (m ± sd); hypertension %; smoking; snoring %; cardiovascular disorder
Hudgel et al. 1993 [34] Yes Yes Yes No Yes BMI can be calculated
Giubilei et al. 1992 [32] Yes Yes No No Yes /
Studies excluded in the meta-analysis (but included in systematic review)
Coelho et al. 2010 [22] Yes No No No Yes hypertension %; polyneuropathy %; anemia %; antidepressants %; fatigue %
Siccoli et al. 2008 [25] Yes Yes No No No3 m and range for BDI
Bliwise et al. 2002 [23] Yes Yes No Yes2 Yes /
Vock et al. 2002 [31] Yes Yes No Yes No3 /
Pinto et al. 2000 [35] Yes Yes Yes Yes No3 /
Yokoyama et al. 1996 [24] Yes Yes Yes No No4 /

* For comprehensively is meant that the study reported means with all data necessary to conduct meta-analytic calculations. 1 = no information about clinical assessment reported. 2 = control group characterized but comprising two groups of patients with Alzheimer and Parkinson diseases. 3 = not possible to calculate the effect size. 4 = sleep variables not considered in other studies, thus not possible to conduct meta-analytic calculations for only one study.