Table 1.
Design of randomised controlled trials and selected baseline characteristics of eligible trials of dietary calcium
Trial | Design | Calcium dose (mg/d) | Vitamin D dose (IU/d) | Duration | Care setting | Total No of participants* | No in Ca/controls group† | % women | Mean age (years) |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Recker 198516 | 2 arm: milk and control | NS | — | 2 y | Community | 30 | 16/14 | 100 | 59 |
Polley 198717 | 4 arm: dairy, Ca, dairy/salt restrict, control | ≥1250 | — | 9 mo | Community | 269 | 58/52 | 100 | 57 |
Nelson 199118 | 2×2 factorial: ex/milk, ex/control, sed/milk, sed/control | 831 | — | 1 y | Community | 41 | 18/18 | 100 | 60 |
Chevalley 199419 | 3 arm: OMC/D, CaD, P/D | 800 | 300 000 IM stat | 18 mo | Community | 93 | 31/31 | 85 | 72 |
Prince 199520 | 4 arm: milk, Ca, Ca/ex, P | 1000 | — | 2 y | Community | 168 | 42/42 | 100 | 63 |
Storm 199821 | 3 arm: milk, Ca, P | NS | — | 2 y | Community | 40 | 20/20 | 100 | 71 |
Castelo-Branco 199922 | 3 arm: OHC, Ca, control | 3320 | — | 2 y | Community | 60 | 17/16 | 100 | 55 |
Cleghorn 200123 | 2 arm: milk, control | 700 | — | 1 y | Community | 142 | 56/59 | 100 | 52 |
Lau 200124 | 2 arm: milk, control | 800 | — | 24 mo | Community | 200 | 95/90 | 100 | 57 |
Chee 200325 | 2 arm: milk, control | 1200 | — | 24 mo | Community | 200 | 91/82 | 100 | 59 |
Albertazzi 200426 | 3 arm: OHC, Ca, P | 500 | — | 6 mo | Community | 153 | 52/50 | 100 | 68 |
Daly 200627 | 2 arm: milk, control | 1000 | 800 | 2 y | Community | 167 | 85/82 | 0 | 62 |
Manios 200728 | 3 arm: dairy, Ca, control | 1200 | 300 | 12 mo | Community | 112 | 39/36 | 100 | 61 |
Kukuljan 200929 | 2×2 factorial: milk, milk/ex, ex, control | 1000 | 800 | 12 mo | Community | 180 | 90/90 | 0 | 61 |
Gui 201230 | 3 arm: milk, soy milk, control | 250 | — | 18 mo | Community | 141 | 100/41 | 100 | 56 |
Ca=calcium; restrict=restriction; ex=exercise; sed=sedentary; OMC=ossein-mineral complex; D=vitamin D; CaD=co-administered Ca and vitamin D; P=placebo; IM=intramuscular; OHC=ossein-hydroxyapatite complex.
*Total number of randomised participants in all treatment arms.
†Number of participants in relevant arms from trial in whom bone mineral density was reported.