Table 1.
Study-specific requirements | |
---|---|
1. Are the study design and sampling method appropriate for the research question? | Is it an observational study? And is there an adequate sample of the total population studied in the research question? |
2. Is the sampling frame appropriate? | Is the ‘list for study recruitment’ from which subjects are selected (sampling frame) appropriate? (no under- or overrepresentation of the problem in the subpopulation?) |
3. Is the sample size adequate? | An adequate sample size calculation in this study and/or n > 100 |
4. Are objective suitable and standard criteria used for measurement of the health outcome? | Are validated questionnaires used? |
5. Is the health outcome measured in an unbiased fashion? | Is there a possible bias in the interpretation of the results? |
6. Is the response rate adequate? Are the refusers described? | >66.6 % response rate and dropouts described and compared with the study population |
7. Are the estimates of prevalence or incidence given with confidence intervals and in detail by subgroup if appropriate? | |
8. Are the study subjects and the setting described in detail and similar to those of interest to you? | Are the sociodemographic characteristics adequately described? |
Total | 0–8 Points Scoring system: 0–4 points = low; 5–8 points = high |