Skip to main content
. 2016 Mar 25;54(4):1051–1057. doi: 10.1128/JCM.02847-15

TABLE 2.

Biosafety experiment: ability to detect viability of M. tuberculosis after paper-based DNA extraction

Inoculum (CFU/ml) Amount of material inoculated into MGIT viala MGIT culture Time to positivity Bacterial load/MGIT vial Confirmation (CT)b
107 3 punchesc (replicate a) Positive 7 days, 1 h 3 × 104 Xpert MTB (17.8)
107 3 punchesc (replicate b) Positive 8 days, 10 h 3 × 104
107 Entire membrane (1 by 1 cm) Positive 6 days, 1 h 1 × 105
107 Washings from SLCd Positive 8 days, 10 h
107 20-μl culture + plain membrane Positive 4 days, 10 h 2 × 105
107 20-μl culture (positive control) Positive 5 days 2 × 105
106 3 punchesc (replicate a) Positive 9 days, 13 h 3 × 103 Xpert MTB (22.3)
106 3 punchesc (replicate b) Positive 12 days, 7 h 3 × 103
106 Entire membrane (1 by 1 cm) Positive 7 days, 17 h 1 × 104 Xpert MTB (18.2)
106 Washings from SLC Positive 9 days, 9 h
106 20-μl culture + plain membrane Positive 7 days 2 × 104
105 3 punchesc (replicate a) Positive 25 days, 1 h 3 × 102
105 3 punchesc (replicate b) Positive 25 days, 13 h 3 × 102
105 Entire membrane (1 cm by 1 cm) Positive 10 days, 11 h 1 × 103 Xpert MTB (20.1)
105 20 μl Culture (positive control) Positive 7 days, 17 h 2 × 103
Negative control (replicate a) Negative No growth at the end of 42 days
Negative control (replicate b) Negative
a

Experiments conducted in duplicate are labeled as replicate a and b.

b

CT, Xpert cycle threshold defined as the number of cycles required for the fluorescent signal to cross the threshold (i.e., exceed background level).

c

Three punches were cut from the center of the Genedrive sample loading cassette and inoculated into the MGIT vial.

d

SLC, sample loading cassette.