Table 2.
Prospective cohort studies of the impact of perinatal body image on risk of depression
Body image |
Depression |
||||||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Timing of assessment |
Timing of assessment |
||||||||
Author, year | Study population | Instrument | Prenatal | Postpartum | Instrument | Prenatal | Postpartum | Covariates | Results |
Rauff and Downs 2011 | 151 women (92 % Caucasian): PA, USA |
BASS: higher scores indicate greater satisfaction |
First trimester Second trimester |
CES-D: higher scores indicate more severe depressive symptoms |
Second trimester Third trimester |
Pre-pregnancy BMI. education, race/ethnicity |
First trimester BI and Second trimester D: β=−0.22* Second trimester BI and Third trimester D: β=−0.33* |
||
Duncombe et al. 2008 | 158 women; Australia | BAQ subscales: Feeling fat Salience. Attractiveness. Strength |
Pre-pregnancy (retrospective) 16–23 weeks 24–31 weeks |
BDI short form: higher scores indicate more severe depressive symptoms |
16–23 weeks 32–38 weeks |
None | Feeling fat: r=0.32–0.45* Salience: r=0.31–0.38* Attractiveness: r=−0.29 to −0.46* Strength: r=−0.26 to −0.34* |
||
Anderson et al. 1994 | 30 women (97 % Caucasian); Canada |
Attitudes scale: higher scores indicate more negative attitudes |
Third trimester (2–94 days before birth) |
BDI: higher scores indicate more severe depressive symptoms |
Mean: 13.2 (8–21.9 weeks) |
None | r=0.43* | ||
Clark et al. 2009 | 116 women; Australia | BAQ subscales: feeling fat Salience. Attractiveness, Strength |
17–21 weeks 32–35 weeks |
6 weeks 12 months |
BDI short form: higher scores indicate more severe depressive symptoms |
32–35 weeks | 6 weeks 12 months |
Prior D | Feeling fat: r=0.03–0.15n.s Other subscales: n.s. (results not shown) |
Downs et al. 2008 | 230 women (92 % Caucasian); PA, USA |
BASS: higher scores indicate greater satisfaction |
First trimester Second trimester Third trimester |
CES-D: higher scores indicate more severe depressive symptoms |
Second trimester Third trimester |
6 months | Exercise behavior, first trimester BMI, prior D |
First trimester BI and second trimester D:β=−0.10n.s Second trimester BI and third trimester D: β=−0.19* Third trimester BI and postpartum D: β=−0.34* First + second + third trimester BI and postpartum D: β=−0.37* |
|
Sweeney et al. 2014 | 46 women (52 % non-Hispanic Caucasian); PA, USA |
BAQ: higher scores indicate greater dissatisfaction |
Third trimester (>28 weeks) |
EPDS: higher scores indicate more severe depressive symptoms |
2 months | Postpartum depression predictors, maladaptive perfectionism |
β=0.49* |
BI body image, BASS Body Areas Satisfaction Scale, BAQ Body Attitudes Questionnaire, D depressive symptoms, CES-D Center for Epidemiologic Studies-Depression, BDI Beck Depression Inventory, EPDS Edinburgh Postnatal Depression Scale,
BMI body mass index,
n.s. not statistically significant
Results statistically significant at P< .05