Table 2.
Comparative studies between topical and IV TXA administration regimes.
Study | Control | Topical | IV pre | IV intra | IV multiple | Results |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Topical versus IV intra | ||||||
[1] N: 150 |
N: 50 • 100 ml NS |
N: 50 • 1.5 g TXA in 100 ml NS • While suturing |
N: 50 • 1.5 g TXA in 100 ml NS • After closing surgical sites |
Topical more effective | ||
[2] N: 89 | No |
N: 47 • 2.0 g TXA in 100 ml NS • 2 min before tourniquet release |
N: 42 • 10 mg/kg TXA • 10 min before tourniquet release |
Topical and IV equally effective | ||
[3] N: 200 |
N: 50 • No treatment |
N: 50 • 3 g TXA in 100 ml NS • Before suturing, clamp drain 1 h, then fully open |
N: 50 • 500 mg TXA in 100 ml NS • After closing the wound immediately |
• TXA: statistical significant effect • IV TXA much more effective |
||
N: 50 • 1.5 g TXA in 100 ml NS • Injected through the drain after wound closure | ||||||
[4] N: 571 |
N: 198 • 3 g TXA in 100 ml NS • After capsular closure |
N: 373 • 1.5 g TXA at time of incision |
Both routes are safe and effective | |||
Topical versus IV pre | ||||||
[5] N: 90 Simultaneous bilateral computer assisted TKR – no drain |
N: 30 • 10 ml NS IV • 20 min before tourniquet inflation |
N: 30 • 1 g TXA in each knee • After wound closure |
N: 30 • 1 g TXA • 20 min before tourniquet inflation |
• TXA: significant benefit • Local versus IV: no difference |
||
Topical versus IV multiple | ||||||
[6] N: 78 |
N: 39 • 3 g TXA in 100 ml NS • After capsular closure |
N: 39 • IV intra, 15 mg/kg in 100 ml NS before tourniquet deflation and • IV post, 10 mg/kg TXA, 3 h after surgery |
Similar results | |||
[7] N: 60 |
N: 30 • 3 g TXA in 100 ml NS • At least 5 min before tourniquet deflation |
N: 30 • IV pre, 10 mg/kg TXA, 20 min before tourniquet inflation and • IV intra, 10 mg/kg TXA, 15 min before tourniquet deflation and • IV post, 10 mg/kg TXA, 3 h after intra dose |
Topical TXA is equally effective as 3 doses of IV regimen | |||
[8] N: 150 |
N: 50 • Routine hemostasis |
N: 50 • 3 g TXA in 100 ml NS • After capsular closure |
N: 50 • IV pre, 1 g TXA before tourniquet inflation and • IV post, 1 g TXA after tourniquet removal |
• Both regimens are more effective than routine hemostasis • No significant difference between the two TXA groups |
||
[9] N: 240 |
N: 40 • No treatment |
Group 5, N: 40 • 2.0 g TXA in 100 ml NS • At least 5 min before tourniquet release |
Group 1, N: 40 • 10 mg/kg TXA • 15 min before tourniquet deflation |
Group 2, N: 40 • IV pre, 10 mg/kg TXA, 20 min before tourniquet inflation and • IV intra, 10 mg/kg TXA, 15 min before tourniquet deflation |
• Single dose: not effective • Two dose: the least amount necessary for effective results • Three dose: the maximum effective |
|
Group 3, N: 40 • IV intra, 10 mg/kg, TXA, 15 min before tourniquet deflation and • IV post, 10 mg/kg TXA, 3 h after first dose | ||||||
Group 4, N: 40 • IV pre, 10 mg/kg TXA, 20 min before tourniquet inflation and • IV intra, 10 mg/kg TXA, 15 min before tourniquet deflation • IV post, 10 mg/kg TXA, 3 h after first dose |
IV: intra-venous; pre: pre-operative; intra: intra-operative; post: post-operative; N: number of patients; NS: normal saline; min: minutes.