Table 4.
Outcomes
| Study | Groupa | Return to sports | AOFAS | Satisfactionb | Redislocation |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Adachi et al. [2] | A | 83 % | Pre m = 76, post m = 93 | N = 0 | |
| Cho et al. [5] | A | 100 %, mean 3.0 months | Pre m = 60, post m = 93 | E = 4, G = 10, p = 2 | N = 1 |
| Cho et al. [5] | B | 100 %, mean 3.1 months | Pre m = 59, post m = 91 | E = 3, G = 9, p = 1 | N = 0 |
| Hui et al. [10] | A | 86 | N = 0 | ||
| Karlsson et al. [12] | B | 100 %, mean 4.5 months | N = 0 | ||
| Kollias et al. [13] | B | 91 %, mean 9.1 month | Pre m 53, post m 96 | N = 0 | |
| Maffulli et al. [18] | A | Pre m = 5, post m = 95 | E = 12, G = 2 | N = 0 | |
| Ogawa et al. [25] | B | Post m = 87 | N = 0 | ||
| Porter et al. [27] | B | 100 %, mean 3.0 months | N = 0 | ||
| Raikin et al. [29] | B | Pre m = 61, post m = 93 | E = 9, G = 4, F = 1 | N = 1 | |
| Saxena et al. [33] | B | 100 %, mean 3.2 months | Pre m = 58, post m = 97 | N = 1 | |
| Tomihara et al. [39] | A | 80 %, mean 2.9 month | Pre m = 78, post m = 93 | N = 0 | |
| Tomihara et al. [39] | C | 54.40 %, mean 3.9 months | Pre m = 77, post m = 89 | N = 2 | |
| Walther et al. [41] | B | 100 % | Pre m = 69, post m = 95 | N = 0 | |
| Wang et al. [42] | D | 100 %, mean 2.8 months | Pre m = 73, post m = 100 | E = 17 | N = 0 |
| Zhenbo et al. [43] | C | 88 %, mean 4.4 months | Pre m = 56, post m = 88 | E = 12, G = 11, F = 3 | N = 0 |
a Group A SPR repair, Group B groove deepening and SPR repair, Group C bony procedure, Group D rerouting procedure
b E excellent, G good, F fair, P poor