Table.
Study | |||||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Author(s)(Year) Year(s) of Study |
Study Design | Sample Size | Age | Location | School Start Times | Outcomes | Key Findings |
Carskadon et al. (1998)62 Not specified |
Longitudinal (before vs after SST change) |
26 (same students) |
Grades 9–10 | Rhode Island | Year 1–9th grade: 8:25 Year 2–10th grade: 7:20 |
Sleep schedules (sleep diaries and
data from electronic wrist monitors), multiple sleep latency tests, polysomnography. |
Earlier SST associated with earlier rise time
(p < .05), shorter sleep duration (p < .05), shorter REM latency (p < .05), shorter sleep latency on multiple sleep latency tests (p = .004), and more students with REM sleep during multiple sleep latency tests (p NR). |
Epstein et al. (1998)72 Not specified |
Cross-sectional (students in 18 schools) |
572 | Grade 5 | 18 schools throughout Israel |
Early risers: 7:10
(2+ times/week) Regular risers: 8:00 |
Sleep duration, bedtime, rise
time (weekdays and weekends), sleepiness, daytime functioning, sleep difficulties. |
Early risers reported shorter weekday
sleep duration (p = .0004), more complaints of feeling tired throughout the day (p = .045), more daytime sleepiness (p = .004), and more difficulty concentrating and paying attention (p = .0001). |
Wahlstrom et al. (1998)60 Not specified |
Cross-sectional (3 districts) |
NR | Grades 10–12 | Minnesota | District A
(Minneapolis): 8:30 District B: 7:25 District C: 7:15 |
School Sleep Habits Survey35 (study, work, sleep, and school habits, and preferences). |
Later SST corresponded to later rise time (p
< .0001), same bedtime, and longer weeknight sleep duration (p < .0001). Later SST also associated with less daytime sleepiness (p < .0001), less struggling to stay awake during academic tasks (p < .01 for A vs C), fewer tardies (p < .001), less falling asleep in morning classes (p <.005), fewer depressive symptoms (p < .001 for A vs C), less time spent at work during school week (p < .05), and higher self-reported grades (p < .05). |
Wahlstrom et al. (1998)60 Not specified |
Cross-sectional (3 districts) |
NR | Grades 7–8 | Minnesota | District A
(Minneapolis): 7:35 District B: 8:00 District C: 8:00 |
School Sleep Habits Survey35 (study, work, sleep, and school habits, and preferences). |
Similar associations as in HS students. Later
SST corresponded to longer sleep duration (p < .05 for A vs C), same bedtime, and later rise time (p < .05 for A vs C). Later SST also associated with less daytime sleepiness (p < .05 for A vs B), less struggling to stay awake during academic tasks (p < .05 for A vs B), lower depression scores (p < .05 for A vs B), and less hours of homework (p < .05 for A vs B and C). |
Wolfson & Carskadon (1998)35 1994 |
Cross-sectional (students in 4 schools in 3 public school districts) |
3120 | Grades 9–12 | Rhode Island | 7:10 – 7:30 | School Sleep Habits Survey
(study, work, sleep, and school habits and preferences) |
Students at school with earliest SST (7:10)
reported earlier rise times than students at the other schools (p < 0.001). Other sleep related differences did not meet effect size criterion. |
Baldus (2002)63 Not specified |
Longitudinal (before vs after SST change) |
31 (same recruits, 2 sleep schedules) |
US Navy recruits (mean 21.3 years) |
Great Lakes, Illinois |
Early reveille: 9PM-5AM sleep time Late reveille: 10PM-6AM sleep time |
Sleep duration. | Later reveille associated with longer sleep
duration (p = .01). The 10PM bedtime—6AM rise time resulted in 22 more minutes of sleep per night per recruit. |
Wahlstrom (2002)55 1994–2000 |
Longitudinal (before vs after SST change) |
>12 000 (7 HS) | Grades 9–12 | Minneapolis, Minnesota |
Pre-change: 7:15 Post-change: 8:40 |
Class grades, attendance,
tardiness, graduation rates, rates of continuous enrollment. |
After SST change, % continuously
enrolled increased (p < .05), attendance rates increased (among students not continuously enrolled) (p < .001), and letter grades increased slightly (not significant). |
Wahlstrom (2002)55 1997–2001 |
Cross-sectional (Minneapolis HS vs District B) |
467 (Minneapolis HS) 169 (District B) |
Grades 9–12 | Minneapolis, Minnesota |
Minneapolis HS: 8:40 District B: 7:30 |
School Sleep Habits Survey35 (study, work, sleep, and school habits and preferences). |
Later SST corresponded to longer sleep
duration (p < .001), same bedtime, and later rise time (p < .001). Later SST also associated with less daytime sleepiness (p < .01), less struggling to stay awake during academic tasks (p < .01), fewer tardies (p < .01)/absences (p < .05), less falling asleep in morning classes (p < .001), and fewer depressive symptoms (p < .05). |
Dexter et al. (2003)73 2002 |
Cross-sectional (2 schools with different SSTs) |
193 (School 1) 587 (School 2) |
Grades 10–11 | Altoona (1) and Chippewa Falls (2), Wisconsin |
School 1: 7:50 School 2: 8:35 |
Weeknight sleep duration,
Epworth Sleepiness Scale91. |
Mean weeknight sleep duration was longer
in School 2 compared to School 1 (p = .039). |
Arlington Public Schools (2005)81 2000–2002 |
Longitudinal (before vs after SST change) |
3 HS, 5 MS | Grades 7–11 | Arlington County, Virginia |
HS: 7:30 (2000–2001), 8:15 (2001–2002) MS: 8:10 (2000–2001), 7:50 (2001–2002) |
Academic grades (1st
period), attendance, survey of students’ perceptions of how alert and prepared to start school day, survey of teachers’ perceptions of student behavior. Surveys were conducted in 2002 only. Respondents were asked to recall prior to SST changes. |
10th grade students’ 1st period grades
improved after 45 minute SST delay (p < .001), but attendance appeared to decrease. No significant change in 7th grade students’ 1st period grades after 20 minute SST advance. |
Adam et al. (2007)68 2002–2003 |
Cross-sectional | 2454 | 5–z19 years | Nationally (USA) representative |
NR | Sleep duration, bedtime, rise
time (weekdays and weekends). |
For older children (12–19 years), an
hour later SST was associated with 0.57 hour more weekday sleep (p < .01), a 0.62 hour later rise time (p < .01), and no difference in bedtime. |
Wolfson et al. (2007)64 2003–2004 |
Cross-sectional (2 schools with different SSTs) |
205 | Grades 7–8 | Urban New England school district |
Early school: 7:15 Late school: 8:37 |
School Sleep Habits Survey35
(sleep duration, bedtime, rise time—weekdays and weekends, sleepiness, sleep-wake behavior problems, sleep hygiene scale), official academic performance, attendance, tardiness. |
Late SST associated with later bedtimes (in
autumn only) (p < .05), later rise times (p < .001), longer sleep duration (65 minutes) (p < .001), less weekend oversleep (in autumn only)(p < .001), less daytime sleepiness in the autumn (p < .05), fewer sleep-wake behavior problems in the spring (p < .05), higher grades (8th grade only) (p < .01), and fewer tardies (p < .001). Weekend sleep patterns were similar. |
Danner and Phillips (2008)74 1998–1999 |
Longitudinal (before vs after SST change) |
9966 (Year 1) 10 656 (Year 2). Sample size included HS and MS students, but results only presented for HS students. |
Grades 6–12 | Kentucky | Year 1 (Y1): 7:30 (HS) Year 2 (Y2): 8:30 (HS) |
Bedtime and rise time (weekdays
and weekends), number of naps, Epworth Sleepiness Scale91, how time spent before and after school, motor vehicle crash rates among 17- and 18-year-old students. |
Compared to Year 1, in Year 2 students
reported longer average sleep duration (p < .001), less catch- up sleep on weekend nights (p < .001), and lower scores on the Epworth Sleepiness Scale (p < .001). Crash rates in the study county decreased after the SST delay (p < .01). |
O’Malley and O’Malley
(2008)56 2001–2004 |
Longitudinal (before vs after SST change) |
297 (pre-delay) 977 (post-delay) |
Grades 9–12 | Wilton, Connecticut |
Pre-delay: 7:35 Post-delay: 8:15 |
Condensed School Sleep
Habits Questionnaire35. |
Later SST corresponded to longer weeknight
sleep duration (p < .001), later rise time (p < .001), later bedtime (p = .03), and fewer problems with sleepiness (p < .001). |
Owens, Belon, Moss (2010)65 2008–2009 |
Longitudinal (before vs after SST change) |
201 (mostly boarders) |
Grades 9–12 | Rhode Island | Pre-change: 8:00 Post-change: 8:30 |
Bedtime and rise time (weekdays
and weekends), sleepiness-related behaviors, health center visits, absences/tardies. |
Delayed SST associated with longer school
night sleep durations (p < .001), earlier bedtimes (p < .001), later rise times (p < .001), greater sleep satisfaction (p < .001), less sleepiness (p < .001), less sleepiness-related behaviors (p < .001), less depressed mood (p < .001), fewer visits to health center for fatigue-related symptoms (p = 0.03), and fewer absences/tardies (p < .05). |
Zhang et al. (2010)66 Not specified |
Cross-sectional | 4470
(mother- father-child community based trios) |
Mean age 9.2 ± 1.8y |
Hong Kong | Morning school: ~7:35 Whole-day school: ~8:08 Afternoon school: ~12:54pm |
Bedtime, rise time,
time-in-bed (weekday, weekend, & long holidays), napping |
Students in morning schools (earliest SST)
had earliest bedtimes & rise times, shortest time-in-bed, most weekend sleep compensation, and largest proportion of daytime napping. |
Carrell et al. (2011)58 2004–2009 |
Cross-sectional | 6165 | U.S. Air
Force Academy freshmen |
Colorado Springs, Colorado | Early (2004–2005,
2005– 2006): 7:00. Middle (2006– 2007): 7:30. Late (2007– 2008, 2008–2009): 7:50. For each schedule, some students had a first period class while others did not. |
Academic grades by
scheduling characteristics. |
Students assigned to a first period course
had poorer grades; however, this association became weaker and became statistically insignificant as the start time moved from 7:00 AM to 7:50 AM. Students performed worse in first period classes compared to other periods, but those with first period classes also performed worse in their subsequent classes on that schedule day. |
Hinrichs (2011)59 1993–2002 |
Cross-sectional (primarily, but with a longitudinal component) |
196,617 observations (may include repeat test takers) (students from 73 schools) |
Grades 10–12 | Twin Cities metropolitan area (Minneapolis-St. Paul, Minnesota) |
7:15–8:40 | ACT scores, attendance rates | No association between SST and ACT scores
or attendance rates. |
Hinrichs (2011)59 2000–2006 |
Cross-sectional | Approximately 400 public high schools |
Grades 10–12 | Kansas (public high schools in the state) |
Mean (SD): 7:59 (0:15) | School-level test score data on
Kansas Mathematics Assessment, Reading Assessment, Science Assessment, and Social Studies Assessment. |
No association between SST and scores on
reading, mathematics, science, and social studies assessments. |
Hinrichs (2011)59 2000–2007 |
Cross-sectional | 75 schools | Grades 9–12? (not specified in report, but described as high schools) |
Virginia suburbs of Washington D.C. |
Scores on standardized
end-of-course exams. |
No association between SST and test scores. | |
Lufi et al. (2011)70 Not specified |
Longitudinal (before vs after SST change—short term change only) |
47 | Grade 8 | Israel | Early class: 7:30 Late class: 8:30 |
Sleep duration, bedtime, rise time,
sleep efficiency (data from electronic wrist monitors), attention tests. |
Later SST associated with longer sleep
duration (p < .01) and improved attention (p < .01). |
Ming et al. (2011)38 Not specified |
Cross-sectional | 1941 (students from 2 public high schools, 1 vocational high school, and two extracurricular high school programs whose students came from various high schools throughout the state) |
Grades 9–12 | New Jersey | Varied from 7:00 to 8:45 For analyses, early SST (before or at 7:30) vs late SST (after 7:30) |
Sleep duration, bedtime, rise
time, napping, perceived sleep adequacy, night awakenings, prolonged sleep onset |
Early SST associated with short weekday
sleep duration (<7 hours, p < .0001), lower likelihood of receiving adequate night sleep (p < .0001), and higher likelihood of afterschool naps (p < .0001) and night awakenings (p =NR). |
Vorona et al. (2011)87 2007–2008 |
Cross-sectional (2 cities with different SSTs in public schools) |
NR | 16–18 years | Virginia Beach
and Chesapeake, Virginia |
Early schools (Virginia Beach): 7:20–7:25 Late schools (Chesapeake): 8:40–8:45 |
Motor vehicle crash rates in each city. | Crash rates among 16-to 18-year-olds were
higher (p < .01) in Virginia Beach (which has earlier SSTs). |
Yilmaz et al. (2011)75 2008 |
Cross-sectional | 3441 | 15–18 years | Gaziantep, Turkey | Early: 7:00–8:00
(morning) Late: 12:00–12:40 pm (afternoon) |
Bedtime, rise time, sleep
latency (weekdays & weekends), ideal night sleep time, napping, sleep hygiene |
Compared to those with afternoon SSTs,
students with morning SSTs reported shorter night time sleep on weekdays and weekends (p < .001) and shorter ideal night time sleep (p < .001). Early SST students were more likely to report daytime napping and needing help to awaken in the morning (p < .001) and less likely to report a long sleep latency (>30 minutes) on weekdays and weekends (p < .001). |
Vedaa et al (2012)78 Not specified |
Cross-sectional | 55
students (intervention school) 51 students (control school) |
Grade 10 | Norway | Intervention school: 9:30 (Mondays), 8:30 (rest of week) Control school: 8:30 (all days) |
Karolinska Sleepiness Scale92, reaction time tests, Positive and Negative Affect Schedule, sleep diary |
Compared to control school students, students
at intervention school slept >1 hour longer on Sunday night (p < .05), had a smaller difference between Saturday and Sunday night sleep duration (p = .04), and shorter sleep latency on Sunday night. Students at the intervention school had fewer lapses on reaction time tests (p = .02) and faster reaction times (p = .02) on Monday than Friday compared to the control students. No differences in sleepiness or positive or negative affect. |
Edwards (2012)57 1999–2006 |
Cross-sectional component |
20,530
students (1999–2000) 27,686 students (2005–2006) |
Grades 6–8 | Wake County, North Carolina |
7:30–8:45 (53% of
students start at 7:30, 22% start at 8:15) |
End of year standardized test scores
in reading and math; time spent watching television and doing homework; absences |
Later SST corresponded to higher standardized
test scores on both math and reading tests (1 hour later corresponded to 3 percentile increase), less time watching television, more time doing homework, and fewer absences. |
Edwards (2012)57 1999–2006 |
Longitudinal component (before vs after SST change for schools that changed SST between 1999- 2006) |
20,530
students (1999–2000) 27,686 students (2005–2006) |
Grades 6–8 | Wake County, North Carolina |
7:30–8:45 (Some schools started earlier and some started later after SST change) |
End of year standardized test scores
in reading and math; time spent watching television and doing homework |
Later SST corresponded to higher standardized
test scores on both math and reading tests (1 hour later corresponded to 2 percentile increase in math and 1.5 percentile increase in reading), less time watching television, and more time doing homework. |
Borlase et al (2013)69 1999–2008 |
Longitudinal (before vs after SST change in 2006) |
212 students in Grades 9 and 12 (1999) 455 students in Grades 9, 11, and 12 (2008) |
13–17 years | Wellington, New Zealand |
Senior students (Grade 12): 9:00 (pre), 10:30 (post) Junior students (Grades 9, 11): 9:00 (no change) |
School Sleep Habits Survey35 (study, work, sleep, and school habits, and preferences), technology use, Epworth Sleepiness Scale91, morningness- eveningness preference, sleep/fatigue problems |
Grade 12 students after the SST delay (2008)
had longer sleep duration (p < .01), earlier bedtime (p < .01), later rise time (p < .001), less sleep discrepancy (sleep duration on school nights vs. non-school nights)(p < .01), and less sleepiness (p < .01) compared to Grade 12 students before the delay or Grade 11 students (2008). |
Li et al. (2013)36 2007–2009 |
Cross-sectional/ Longitudinal (6 schools before vs after SST change) |
525 (baseline) 553 (2-year follow- up) |
Grades 4–5 (mean age 10.8y) |
Shanghai, China | 2 control schools, no change in SST: 7:30 2 schools, intervention 1: 7:30 (pre), 8:00 (post) 2 schools, intervention 2: 7:30 (pre), 8:30 (post) |
Sleep duration, bedtime, rise
time, daytime sleepiness (Chinese version of Children’s Sleep Habits Questionnaire) |
At baseline, students at the 6 schools had
similar sleep characteristics. At follow-up, later SST associated with later bedtime (p < .05), rise time (p < .001), longer sleep duration (p < .001), and less daytime sleepiness. Comparing baseline to follow- up, mean sleep duration decreased for students at control schools (no change in SST) but increased for students at intervention schools. |
Perkinson-Gloor et al. (2013)34 2010–2011 |
Cross-sectional | 2373 (early) 343 (delayed start) |
Grades 8–9 | Mid-size city
in northwestern Switzerland |
Early: not specified Delayed: 20 minutes later |
Sleep duration, bedtimes, rise
times (weekdays and weekends), daytime sleepiness, behavioral persistence, attitude towards life, school grades (mathematics and German language). |
Later SST associated with longer weeknight
sleep duration (p < .001), later weeknight bedtimes (p = .04 boys, p < .001 girls), later weekday rise times (p < .001), and less daytime sleepiness (p < .001 boys, p = .03 girls). |
Short et al. (2013)76 1997–2000 (U.S.) 2008–2010 (Australia) |
Cross-sectional | 302 (U.S.) 385 (Australia) |
Grades 9–12 (mean age 16.0y) (U.S.) Years 9–11 (mean age 15.6y) (Australia) |
Rhode Island (U.S.) South Australia (Australia) |
U.S.: ~7:45 Australia: 8:20–9:00 |
School Sleep Habits Survey35 (study, work, sleep, and school habits and preferences), 8-day sleep diary |
School night sleep duration correlated with
SST (r = .29, p < .001). SST had largest effect on sleep duration (compared with parent-set bedtimes and extra-curricular load). |
Boergers, Gable, and Owens (2014)67 2010–2011 |
Longitudinal (before vs after SST change) |
197 (boarding students) |
Grades 9–12 | Rhode Island | Pre-delay: 8:00 Post-delay: 8:25 |
School Sleep Habits Survey35 (study, work, sleep, and school habits and preferences), caffeine intake questionnaire |
After SST delay, mean wake times (school
days) were later (p < .001), mean school night sleep duration was longer (p < .001), school night bedtimes did not change. The percentage who slept ≥8 hour on school nights increased from 18% to 44% (p < .001). There were no changes in nonschool night sleep patterns. After delay, sleepiness scores (p < .001), depression scores (p < .001), and caffeine use decreased (p < .05). No changes in number of hours engaged in athletics, extracurricular activities, and homework were reported. No changes in self-reported grades were reported. Weekday sleep duration decreased to baseline after reverting to pre-delay SST. |
Escribano & Diaz-Morales
(2014)77 Not specified |
Cross-sectional (students in 3 schools) |
669 | 12–16 years | Madrid, Spain | 8:00, 8:15, 8:30 | Bedtimes, rise times, sleep
duration, attention task (at 3 times during school day on 2 consecutive Wednesdays), morningness/eveningness, inductive reasoning |
Average school night sleep was more than
30 minutes longer for 8:30 SST than 8:00 SST (p < .001). Attention level highest for 8:15 SST on first Wednesday (p < .001), but no difference by SST on second Wednesday. Inductive reasoning score was lowest for 8:30 SST (p < .01). |
Chen et al. (2014)79 2009 |
Cross-sectional | 4801 (students from 12 senior HS and 12 junior HS) |
11–20 years | Shanghai, China | Dichotimized: Before 7:00 vs. 7:00 or later |
Adolescent Sleep Wake Scale93, bedtimes, wake-up times, sleep duration (weekdays & weekends), parents’ sleep habits |
SST before 7:00 associated with sleeping
<8 hours (p = .015). |
Vorona et al. (2014)88 2009–2011 |
Cross-sectional (2 counties with different SST in public schools) |
16–18 years | Chesterfield County, Virginia and Henrico County, Virginia |
Early (Chesterfield): 7:20 Late (Henrico): 8:45 |
Weekday motor vehicle crash
rates during the school years (September- May) 2009–2010 and 2010–2011. |
In 2009–2010, crash rates among
16–18 year olds were higher (p < .05) in Chesterfield County (which has earlier SST). In 2010–2011, crash rates among 16–17 year olds were higher (p < .05) in Chesterfield County, but difference was not statistically significant when 18 year olds were included in comparison (p = .09). Adult crash rates for the same time periods did not differ between the two counties. |
|
Milic et al. (2014)80 2011 |
Cross-sectional | 821 (students from 4 HS) |
15–19 years | Osijek, Croatia | Early: 7:00 AM or 1:00 PM (alternating weeks) Late: 8:00 AM or 2:00 PM (alternating weeks) |
Epworth Sleepiness Scale91, morningness/eveningness, napping, academics (final semester grade) |
Students with earlier SST performed
better academically and had earlier chronotypes (morning preference) (p < .001). No difference in sleepiness. |
Wahlstrom et al. (2014)61 2011–2013 |
Cross-sectional | 9089 | Grades 9–12 | 5 HS in Minnesota, 2 HS in Colorado, 1 HS in Wyoming |
After delay, SST varied from 8:00 to 8:55 |
Sleep duration, bedtimes, rise
times (weekdays and weekends), sleep-related tardiness, sleeping during class. |
SST associated with percent of students
sleeping ≥8 hours/school night (R2 = .8878, <50% for schools starting before 8:30, 66% for school starting at 8:55). |
Wahlstrom et al. (2014)61 2011–2013 |
Longitudinal (before vs after SST change) |
446 (pre-delay) 459 (post-delay) |
Grades 9–12 | Jackson Hole, Wyoming |
Pre-delay: 7:35 Post-delay: 8:55 |
Sleep duration, bedtimes, rise
times (weekdays and weekends). |
Average school night sleep increased from 7.5h
to 8.2h. Average weekend sleep decreased from 9.3h to 9.0h. |
Wahlstrom et al. (2014)61 2004–2013 |
Longitudinal (before vs after SST change) |
NR | Grades 9–12 | 5 HS in Minnesota, 2 HS in Colorado, 1 HS in Wyoming |
Before delay, SST varied from 7:30 to 7:50 After delay, SST varied from 8:00 to 8:55 |
Attendance, academic performance,
car crashes. |
Most schools saw a decrease in tardiness and
an increase in GPA. Two out of the four areas for which car crash data was available saw a major decrease in car crashes involving 16- to 18-year-old drivers (≥65%). One saw a small decrease (6%), while another saw a small increase (9%). |
Paksarian et al. (2015)71 2001–2004 |
Cross-sectional | 7216 (245 schools) | 13–18 years | Nationally (USA) representative |
Mean: 8:01 Range: 7:05–9:22 |
Weeknight bedtime, sleep
duration (weeknight and weekend), weekend compensatory sleep |
Later SST associated with later bedtime (10
minute later bedtime for each 30 minute delay in SST). Later SST associated with longer sleep duration for SST before 8:01 only (11 minutes for each 30 minute delay in SST). Difference only among boys only and varied by urbanicity. Sleep duration increased for boys in major metropolitan areas and decreased for boys in nonurban counties. SST not associated with weekend compensatory sleep. |
Only Abstracts Available | |||||||
Allen and Mirabile (1989)50 Not specified |
Cross-sectional | 61 | Grades 10–12 (Mean age 17.1 years) |
NR | Early school: 7:30 Late school: 8:00 |
Sleep duration, bedtimes, rise
times (weekdays and weekends). |
Later SST corresponded to later rise times (p
< .05), but no difference in bedtimes. Sleep duration difference not significantly different. |
Allen (1992)51 Not specified |
Cross-sectional | 102 | Grade 12 | NR | Early school: 7:40 Late schools: 8:30 |
Sleep duration, bedtimes, rise
times (weekdays and weekends). |
Earlier SST corresponded to shorter
weeknight sleep duration (p < .035), more sleep problems (p = .04), and later weekend rise times (p = .03). |
Carskadon et al. (1995)53 1994 |
Longitudinal (before vs after SST change) |
7 | Grade 9–10 | Rhode Island | Late (Grade 9): 8:25 Early (Grade 10): 7:20 |
Sleep duration, sleep start time,
sleep offset time (measured with actigraphy) |
Earlier SST (65 minutes) corresponded to
shorter sleep duration (38 minutes, p < .02) due to earlier rise times (59 minutes, p < .005). No significant difference in school night sleep start time. |
Kowalski and Allen52 Not specified (1995) |
Cross-sectional | 97 (early school) 119 (late school) |
Grades 11–12 | NR | Early school: 7:20 Late school: 9:30 |
Sleep duration, bedtimes, rise
times (weekdays and weekends). |
Earlier SST corresponded to shorter
weeknight sleep duration (p = .002). |
Wolfson et al. (1995)54 1994 |
Longitudinal (before vs after SST change) |
15 (May have included students in Carskadon et al.53) |
Grade 9–10 | Rhode Island | Late (Grade 9): 8:25 Early (Grade 10): 7:20 |
Sleep duration, sleep start time,
sleep efficiency (measured with actigraphy); emotional/behavioral problems from Youth Self Report (YSR) summary. |
Earlier SST (65 minutes) corresponded to
shorter sleep duration (39 minutes, p < .001). No significant difference in school night sleep start time or sleep efficiency. YSR total problems and externalizing scores decreased with earlier SST. |
Abbreviations: ACT, originally American College Testing – one of two standardized tests commonly used in college admissions in the United States; HS, high school; MS, middle school; NR, not reported; SD, standard deviation; SST, school start time.