Skip to main content
. Author manuscript; available in PMC: 2017 Mar 29.
Published in final edited form as: Vaccine. 2016 Feb 23;34(14):1672–1679. doi: 10.1016/j.vaccine.2016.02.039

Table 1.

Comparison of study design between inpatient and outpatient settings from 14 publications.

Study Country Season Setting Case definition Interval since onset Dominant type/subtypeb Vaccine matchc Time in model Comorbid in model % with high-risk condition
Cheng et al. [12] Australia 2010 Inpatient Admission Unrestricted H1pdm Yes Fortnight Yes 79%
Levy et al. [13] Western Australia Outpatient ILI ≤4d Week No NA
Fielding et al. [20] Victoria, Australia Outpatient ILI ≤4d Month No
Kwong et al. [14] Ontario, Canada 2010–2011 Inpatient Admission Unrestricted H3 Yes Month Yes ≥72.8%d
Skowronski et al. [15] Canada Outpatient ILI ≤7d Week Yes 34.9%
Puig-Barberàet al.a [16] Valencia, Spain 2011–2012 Inpatient ILI Not specified H3 No Week No 88%
Jimenez-Jorge et al.a [17] Spain Outpatient ILI ≤7d Week (cat) No 62.9%
Talbot et al. [18] Tennessee, USA 2011–2012 Inpatient ARI ≤10d H3 No Onset to admission Yes 86%
Ohmit et al. [19] USA Outpatient ARI ≤7d Fortnight Yes 25.4%
Cheng et al. [21] Australia 2012 Inpatient Admission Not specified H3 No Not specified Yes 83.2%
Sullivan et al. [22] Australia Outpatient ILI Not specified Month No NA
Martinez-Baz et al. [10] Narrava, Spain 2012–2013 Inpatient ILI ≤7d B Yes Month Yes NA
Martinez-Baz et al. [10] Narrava, Spain Outpatient ILI ≤7d Month Yes NA
Turner et al. [9] Auckland, New Zealand 2013 Inpatient SARI ≤7d H3 Yes Week Yes 64.5%
Turner et al. [9] Auckland, New Zealand Outpatient ILI ≤7d Week Yes NA
Pierse et al. [23] Auckland, New Zealand 2014 Inpatient SARI ≤7d H1pdm Yes Timing of the intervention to peak of season Yes 51%
Pierse et al. [23] Auckland, New Zealand Outpatient ILI ≤7d Timing of the intervention to peak of season Yes 26%
a

Enrolled patients targeted for influenza vaccination. Cases were positive for influenza A(H3N2) virus.

b

Information retrieved either from studies or the WHO website.

c

Information retrieved either from studies or the WHO website.

d

72.8% was the percentage of subjects with chronic cardiovascular disease.