Skip to main content
. 2016 Mar 29;2016:5645632. doi: 10.1155/2016/5645632

Table 3.

Summary of meta-analyses.

Study outcomes Number of trials Number of participants Statistical method Effect estimate Test for overall effect Heterogeneity (I 2)
Z P
Overall assessment of acupoints stimulation: acupoints stimulation versus different comparisons (for anxiety)
Acupoints stimulation versus standard methods of treatment/care 3 567 NR NR NR NR NA
Acupoints stimulation versus sham acupoints stimulation 2 137 Mean difference (IV, random, 95% CI) −0.65 [−2.84, 1.53] 0.59 0.56 >50%

Overall assessment of acupoints stimulation: acupoints stimulation versus different comparisons (for depression)
Acupoints stimulation versus standard methods of treatment/care 5 485 Mean difference (IV, random, 95% CI) −1.08 [−1.97, −0.19] 2.39 0.02 >50%
Acupoints stimulation versus sham acupoints stimulation 2 137 Mean difference (IV, random, 95% CI) −0.27 [−2.66, 2.12] 0.23 0.82 50%

Subgroup analysis: different types of acupoints stimulation versus standard methods of treatment/care (for anxiety)
Electroacupuncture 2 112 NR NR NR NR NA
Acupuncture 2 302 NR NR NR NR NA

Subgroup analysis: different types of acupoints stimulation versus standard methods of treatment/care (for depression)
Electroacupuncture 2 159 NR NR NR NR NA
Acupuncture 4 393 Mean difference (IV, random, 95% CI) −2.55 [−3.61, −1.49] 4.72 <0.00001 >50%

Subgroup analysis: different types of acupoints stimulation versus sham comparison (for anxiety)
Acupuncture 2 152 NR NR NR NR NA
Acupressure 1 57 NR NR NR NR NA

Subgroup analysis: different types of acupoints stimulation versus sham comparison (for depression)
Acupuncture 2 152 NR NR NR NR NA
Acupressure 1 57 NR NR NR NR NA

IV: inverse variance, CI: confidence interval, NR: not reported because pooling was not conducted due to the insufficient number of studies, different models of data, or absence of data, NA: not applicable

Sample was adopted from one study (as the sample of the other study was based on the study we adopted).