Table 1.
Summary of studies included in ALE meta-analysis
Study | n | Task | Site | x | y | z | TT | MNI |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Tremblay et al., 2013 | 39 | Repetition of bisyllabic nouns | L | −46 | −8 | 34 | x | |
R | 49 | −12 | 30 | |||||
Eckers et al., 2013 | 5 | Non-meaningful consonant-vowel syllables or glottal stops in combination with vowels | L | −46 | −4 | 44 | x | |
R | 54 | −6 | 46 | |||||
Grabski et al., 2012 | 13 | Vowel /i/ | L | −60 | −4 | 18 | x | |
−42 | −12 | 39 | ||||||
R | 52 | −6 | 32 | |||||
49 | −7 | 36 | ||||||
Peeva et al., 2010 | 22 | Repetitions of bisyllabic pseudowords | L | −50 | −8 | 30 | x | |
R | 52 | 0 | 42 | |||||
Simonyan et al., 2009 | 13 | Repetitions of the syllable /iʔi/ (/i/ followed by glottal stop and followed by /i/) | L | −50 | −14 | 40 | x | |
−52 | −13 | 40 | ||||||
R | 51 | −15 | 41 | |||||
50 | −14 | 40 | ||||||
Shuster, 2009 | 14 | Production of pseudowords | L | 48 | 10 | 31 | x | |
51 | 14 | 11 | ||||||
R | −50 | 6 | 12 | |||||
−43 | 5 | 26 | ||||||
Chang et al., 2009 | 35 | Meaningless consonant-vowel-consonant syllable production | L | −55 | −15 | 38 | x | |
R | 48 | −11 | 33 | |||||
Olthoff et al., 2008 | 16 | Phonation without intonation | L | −18 | −30 | 58 | x | |
−47 | −12 | 45 | ||||||
−52 | 1 | 23 | ||||||
R | 46 | −9 | 44 | |||||
15 | −31 | 57 | ||||||
55 | 2 | 21 | ||||||
Riecker et al., 2008 | 9 | 64 bisyllabic pseudowords with /tet/ as the 2nd unit | L | −48 | −6 | 36 | x | |
R | 48 | −6 | 33 | |||||
Ghosh et al., 2008 | 10 | Mono-syllables | L | −54 | 2 | 20 | x | |
R | 54 | −8 | 48 | |||||
20 | −28 | 66 | ||||||
Brown et al., 2008 | 16 | Phonation using the schwa vowel or glottal stops | L | −38 | −14 | 32 | x | |
−53 | 0 | 42 | ||||||
−40 | −10 | 30 | ||||||
−51 | 0 | 44 | ||||||
R | 44 | −10 | 34 | |||||
53 | 4 | 42 | ||||||
44 | −8 | 24 | ||||||
50 | −2 | 37 | ||||||
Loucks et al., 2007 | 12 | Repetitions of glottal stop followed by /i/ | L | −44 | −10 | 39 | x | |
R | 36 | −8 | 28 | |||||
Bohland and Guenther, 2006 | 13 | Simple and complex consonant-vowel sequences | L | −46 | −10 | 60 | x | |
−44 | −18 | 64 | ||||||
−60 | 0 | 30 | ||||||
R | 48 | 6 | 32 | |||||
56 | 8 | 32 | ||||||
56 | 6 | 40 | ||||||
50 | −14 | 60 | ||||||
56 | 6 | 40 | ||||||
62 | −4 | 42 | ||||||
56 | 8 | 40 | ||||||
Soros et al., 2006 | 9 | Vowel “ah” | R | 60 | −4 | 42 | x | |
48 | −12 | 44 | ||||||
Terumitsu et al., 2006 | 18 | Phonation without articulatory tongue movements (/e/) and vocalization with tongue movement | L | −40 | −19 | 42 | x | |
−56 | −2.8 | 21 | ||||||
−52 | −11 | 47 | ||||||
−54 | 0 | 23 | ||||||
R | 51 | −11 | 38 | |||||
58 | −6 | 35 | ||||||
Wilson et al., 2004 | 10 | 23 repetitions of a meaningless mono-syllable | L | −51 | −11 | 46 | x | |
−45 | −13 | 34 | ||||||
−56 | −4 | 22 | ||||||
R | 56 | −8 | 44 | |||||
48 | −10 | 35 | ||||||
60 | 0 | 20 | ||||||
Riecker et al., 2002 | 12 | Production of “pa-pa-pa” | L | −59 | 1 | 22 | x | |
−56 | −5 | 25 | ||||||
R | 59 | −4 | 22 | |||||
62 | −2 | 25 | ||||||
Riecker et al., 2000 | 10 | Production of “ta,” “stra,” and “pataka” | L | 39 | −15 | 22 | x | |
−54 | −6 | 27 | ||||||
−57 | −3 | 27 | ||||||
R | 60 | 0 | 24 | |||||
51 | −6 | 21 | ||||||
Lotze et al., 2000 | 7 | Production of “pa,” “ta,” “ka,” and “pataka” | L | −48 | −10 | 52 | x | |
−44 | −8 | 40 | ||||||
−46 | −8 | 26 | ||||||
−36 | −14 | 36 | ||||||
R | 48 | −10 | 56 | |||||
64 | −16 | 28 | ||||||
60 | −6 | 24 | ||||||
54 | −8 | 42 |
We identified 19 overt speech production fMRI studies dating between 2000 and 2013. Search terms in literature review were “syllable AND fMRI,” “vowel AND fMRI,” and “speech production AND fMRI.” By choosing studies of the production of syllables/vowels with minimal linguistic meaning, we purported to identify simple voluntary laryngeal motor tasks rather than more complex tasks with wider cognitive involvement. A total of 82 candidate foci from 283 healthy subjects were chosen, which localized to the primary motor cortex within the precentral gyrus. MNI standard space coordinates were transformed into TT space for analysis with ALE.