Skip to main content
. 2016 Jan 5;23(2):93–100. doi: 10.1093/dnares/dsv039

Table 1.

Benchmarking for the simulated dataset containing 10 million single-end reads simulated with the BEERS program

RL MR (%) HPG Aligner 1
HISAT
STAR 2
TopHat 2 + Bowtie 2
MapSplice 2
IMR RNM CMR T IMR RNM CMR T IMR RNM CMR T IMR RNM CMR T IMR RNM CMR T
0.1 3.08 0.42 96.5 4.8 4.42 3.22 92.36 4.45 7.32 1.46 91.22 8.28 2.05 0.93 97.02 36.35 2.82 1.16 96.02 26.93
50 1 4.26 0.84 94.9 4.9 9.79 8.61 81.60 4.80 11.23 1.72 87.05 8.73 2.06 3.04 94.90 79.65 2.95 2.03 95.02 26.13
2 5.82 2.26 91.92 5.2 16.29 17.18 66.53 4.58 15.44 3.16 81.40 8.85 2.00 10.18 87.82 374.9 3.21 4.81 91.98 26.08
0.1 3.51 0.24 96.25 5.8 2.30 1.13 96.57 6.21 7.81 0.46 91.73 9.52 0.28 2.98 96.74 48.22 3.31 0.24 96.45 37.32
75 1 4.17 0.94 94.89 6.0 4.64 3.48 91.88 6.40 11.82 1.18 87.00 9.97 1.24 6.90 91.86 50.78 3.59 1.16 95.25 35.05
2 5.64 1.27 93.09 6.4 10.59 10.46 78.95 6.46 16.62 1.55 81.83 11.25 0.94 22.18 76.88 58.93 5.13 2.20 92.67 34.28
0.1 4.07 0.24 95.69 7.4 2.57 1.24 96.19 7.86 7.59 0.64 91.77 11.77 1.69 1.94 96.37 65.08 3.54 0.26 96.20 51.17
100 1 4.95 0.55 94.50 7.5 5.70 4.51 89.79 8.15 11.90 0.62 87.48 12.08 0.99 11.70 87.31 74.02 3.98 0.68 95.34 46.03
2 6.07 0.93 93.00 7.8 15.64 17.19 67.17 8.40 16.48 1.14 82.38 12.35 0.60 36.14 63.26 85.65 6.45 1.50 92.05 45.6
0.1 5.58 0.31 94.11 10.5 3.15 1.56 95.29 11.75 8.40 0.57 91.03 15.07 1.49 3.55 94.96 97.9 5.45 0.21 94.34 56.88
150 1 7.77 1.95 90.28 10.6 12.49 13.03 74.48 11.41 12.88 2.73 84.39 15.08 0.82 27.13 72.05 121.55 8.23 2.67 89.10 53.53
2 7.06 0.78 92.16 10.9 24.42 39.76 35.82 11.91 15.97 0.73 83.30 15.73 0.45 61.84 37.71 140.28 13.65 1.57 84.78 56.73
0.1 8.21 0.66 91.13 16.55 4.49 2.47 93.04 17.80 9.13 0.62 90.25 21.58 1.62 6.70 91.68 185.78 11.51 0.23 88.26 75.55
250 1 8.43 0.81 90.76 16.5 22.28 31.6 46.12 19.28 12.99 0.71 86.30 22.3 0.28 53.29 46.43 256.83 29.85 0.75 69.40 79.28
2 8.72 1.62 89.66 17.45 17.75 77.04 5.21 17.46 18.35 1.43 80.22 23.35 0.07 89.62 10.31 309.85 35.27 1.24 63.49 76.37
0.1 10.02 1.08 88.90 25.45 6.88 5.04 88.08 28.5 9.98 0.56 89.46 32.12 0.99 12.32 86.69 369.58 17.33 0.03 82.64 106.67
400 1 12.94 3.35 83.71 25.6 22.52 66.17 11.31 29.7 14.82 4.26 80.92 33.83 0.09 82.40 17.51 573.18 51.64 1.65 46.71 103.98
2 11.78 2.84 85.38 26.0 3.08 96.82 0.10 27.10 32.75 2.75 64.5 24.5 0.01 99.02 0.97 603.28 54.34 0.51 45.15 106.53

First column, RL, indicated read length in bp. Second column represents the mutation rate (MR). For each program, the table contains the following columns with the percentages of: IMR: incorrectly mapped reads; RNM: reads not mapped; CMR: correctly mapped reads covering the corresponding splice junctions. The last column, T, represents runtimes for producing a BAM file in min.