Table 3.
Author | Surgery | No. of patients | Blinding | Duration of surgery | Intervention | Fast | Postop. oral fluid intake | Effect of fluid |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Keane and Murray [65] | Mixed outpatient surgery | 212 in 2 groups | No | 18 min | 1000 mL Hartman’s solution + 1000 mL DW vs. no fluid | ? | ? | ↓ Thirst, drowsiness, headache and dizziness → Nausea |
Spencer [66] | Minor gynecologic surgery | 100 in 2 groups | No | 8 min | 1 L CSL vs. no fluid | ? | ? | ↓ Dizziness and nausea |
Cook et al. [67] | Gynecologic laparoscopy | 75 in 3 groups | Yes | 20 min | CSL 20 mL/kg vs. CSL + DW 20 mL/kg vs. no fluid | 11–16 h | ? | ↓ Dizziness and drowsiness ↓ LOS in Dextrose group |
Yogendran et al. [70] | Mixed outpatient surgery | 200 in 2 groups | Yes | 28 min | Plasmolyte 20 mL/kg (1215 mL) vs. Plasmolyte 2 mL/kg (164 mL) | 8–13 h | ? | ↓ Thirst, dizziness and drowsiness → PONV |
McCaul et al. [71] | Gynecologic laparoscopy | 108 in 3 groups | Yes | 22 min | CSL 1,5 mL/kg/fasting h (1115 mL) vs. CSL + DW 1.5 mL/kg/fasting h (1148 mL) vs. no fluid |
11,5 h | ? | → PONV ↑ Thirst in CSL + DW group |
Magner et al. [68] | Gynecologic laparoscopy | 141 in 2 groups | Yes | 20 min | CSL 30 mL/kg vs. CSL 10 mL/kg | 13 h | ? | ↓ PONV → Dizziness and thirst |
Holte et al. [69] | Laparoscopic cholecystectomy | 48 in 2 groups | Yes | 68 min | LR 15 mL/kg (998 mL) vs. 40 mL/kg (2928 mL) | 2 h | Mean 600 mL | ↓ LOS ↓ Thirst, nausea, dizziness, and drowsiness ↑ Well-being and pulmonary function |
DW Dextrose in water 5 %, CSL compound sodium lactose (Na:131, K:5, Ca:2, Cl:111, Lactate:29 mmol/l), LR lactated Ringers solution, PONV postoperative nausea and vomiting
↑significantly increased, ↓ significantly decreased, → no significant changes, ?: not given