Table C4.
Results from Full Specification to Investigate Intensive Margin
(1a) | (1b) | (1c) | (1d) | (1e) | (1f) | ||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
w | Log(w) | w | Log(w) | w | Log(w) | ||
Weekly earnings / baseline hours per week |
Weekly earnings / baseline hours per week |
Weekly earnings / baseline hours per week |
Weekly earnings / baseline hours per week |
Weekly earnings / baseline hours per week |
Weekly earnings / baseline hours per week |
||
| |||||||
SAMPLE |
Workers with a paid job and wages>0 in the given period |
Workers with a paid job and wages>0 over the entire period |
Workers with a paid job and wages>0 and no job switch over the entire period |
||||
MA* ESHI* After* Large | β1 | 1.682*** | 0.358*** | 2.920*** | 0.615*** | 2.611*** | 0.656*** |
[0.999, 2.756] | [0.320, 0.419] | [1.825, 3.971] | [0.570, 0.679] | [1.192, 3.823] | [0.581, 0.732] | ||
MA* ESHI* During* Large | β1d | −0.532 | 0.0213 | −0.0587 | 0.0869** | 0.615 | 0.119*** |
[−1.420, 0.619] | [−0.0160, 0.0720] | [−1.375, 1.120] | [0.0320, 0.133] | [−0.871, 1.745] | [0.0595, 0.178] | ||
MA* ESHI* Large | β8 | 3.124*** | 0.118*** | 3.564*** | 0.113*** | 3.264*** | 0.104*** |
[2.681, 3.610] | [0.0910, 0.141] | [3.043, 4.244] | [0.0890, 0.157] | [2.564, 3.876] | [0.0653, 0.143] | ||
MA* After* Large | β11 | −2.635*** | −0.356*** | −4.742*** | −0.650*** | −4.363*** | −0.691*** |
[−3.584, −1.615] | [−0.415, −0.309] | [−5.720, −3.166] | [−0.710, −0.597] | [−5.596, −2.736] | [−0.770, −0.612] | ||
MA* During* Large | β11d | 0.518 | −0.000265 | −0.242 | −0.112*** | −0.679 | −0.140*** |
[−0.307, 1.654] | [−0.0530, 0.0380] | [−1.228, 1.392] | [−0.159, −0.0590] | [−1.592, 1.071] | [−0.195, −0.0849] | ||
ESHI* After* Large | β12 | −0.599 | −0.0695*** | −0.293 | −0.0681* | 0.186 | −0.0625* |
[−1.487, 0.274] | [−0.119, −0.0150] | [−1.054, 0.912] | [−0.107, 0.00300] | [−0.891, 1.370] | [−0.136, 0.0113] | ||
ESHI* During* Large | β12d | −0.00128 | −0.0539** | 0.420 | −0.0400 | 0.478 | −0.0367 |
[−0.936, 0.958] | [−0.0950, −0.00800] | [−0.643, 1.671] | [−0.0810, 0.0180] | [−0.698, 1.792] | [−0.0920, 0.0185] | ||
ESHI* Large | β19 | 0.677** | 0.0736*** | 0.617** | 0.0689*** | 0.616* | 0.0651*** |
[0.190, 1.054] | [0.0510, 0.0950] | [0.033, 1.241] | [0.0390, 0.0990] | [−0.0500, 1.184] | [0.0349, 0.0952] | ||
After* Large | β22 | 0.785 | 0.0507* | 0.814 | 0.0570 | 0.579 | 0.0579 |
[−0.302, 1.678] | [−0.00700, 0.102] | [−0.757, 1.764] | [−0.00900, 0.0960] | [−0.789, 1.789] | [−0.0203, 0.136] | ||
During* Large | β22d | 0.203 | 0.0344 | −0.123 | 0.0222 | 0.000 | 0.0271 |
[−0.968, 0.967] | [−0.0130, 0.0750] | [−1.639, 0.822] | [−0.0350, 0.0580] | [−1.586, 1.004] | [−0.0275, 0.0817] | ||
Large | β23 | 1.140 | 0.00659 | 0.738 | −0.0705 | 2.128 | −0.0133 |
[−2.200, 1.807] | [−0.110, 0.0630] | [−2.727, 1.618] | [−0.135, 0.0350] | [−2.930, 2.768] | [−0.116, 0.0896] | ||
MA* Large | β24 | −1.243 | −0.0222 | −1.865 | −0.0336 | −3.712 | −0.0804 |
[−1.975, 2.199] | [−0.0880, 0.108] | [−2.739, 1.715] | [−0.155, 0.0320] | [−4.437, 1.479] | [−0.190, 0.0288] | ||
MA* ESHI* After | β1e | −3.124*** | −0.321*** | −4.002*** | −0.454*** | −4.805*** | −0.486*** |
[−4.075, −2.436] | [−0.365, −0.288] | [−5.176, −3.271] | [−0.506, −0.420] | [−5.881, −3.592] | [−0.545, −0.426] | ||
MA* ESHI* During | β1ed | −1.672*** | −0.196*** | −2.285*** | −0.245*** | −2.755*** | −0.261*** |
[−2.408, −0.763] | [−0.231, −0.151] | [−3.218, −1.152] | [−0.284, −0.193] | [−3.774, −1.680] | [−0.315, −0.207] | ||
MA* ESHI | β8e | −0.873*** | 0.0167 | −1.234*** | 0.00925 | −0.749** | 0.0260 |
[−1.444, −0.531] | [−0.0150, 0.0400] | [−2.051, −0.739] | [−0.0430, 0.0330] | [−1.571, −0.197] | [−0.0245, 0.0765] | ||
MA* After | β11e | 4.489*** | 0.347*** | 6.086*** | 0.506*** | 6.300*** | 0.520*** |
[3.625, 5.099] | [0.298, 0.381] | [5.306, 7.042] | [0.463, 0.545] | [5.240, 7.104] | [0.464, 0.576] | ||
MA* During | β11ed | 1.879*** | 0.186*** | 2.774*** | 0.274*** | 2.916*** | 0.289*** |
[0.693, 2.471] | [0.139, 0.222] | [1.276, 3.552] | [0.223, 0.310] | [1.450, 3.716] | [0.238, 0.340] | ||
ESHI* After | β12e | −0.116 | −0.0240 | −0.276 | −0.0123 | −0.597 | −0.0214 |
[−0.934, 0.688] | [−0.0670, 0.0120] | [−1.291, 0.579] | [−0.0650, 0.0190] | [−1.660, 0.393] | [−0.0710, 0.0281] | ||
ESHI* During | β12ed | −0.587 | −0.00417 | −0.794 | −0.00678 | −0.929* | −0.00966 |
[−1.424, 0.219] | [−0.0440, 0.0300] | [−1.797, 0.261] | [−0.0480, 0.0400] | [−1.956, 0.133] | [−0.0578, 0.0384] | ||
ESHI | β19e | 1.317*** | 0.101*** | 1.327*** | 0.0960*** | 1.304*** | 0.0870*** |
[0.907, 1.717] | [0.0810, 0.119] | [0.677, 1.861] | [0.0680, 0.123] | [0.655, 1.817] | [0.0600, 0.114] | ||
After | β22e | 0.969*** | 0.0985*** | 0.760** | 0.0690*** | 0.630 | 0.0603*** |
[0.390, 1.650] | [0.0660, 0.141] | [0.0610, 1.605] | [0.0410, 0.113] | [−0.201, 1.528] | [0.0158, 0.105] | ||
During | β22ed | 0.928*** | 0.0589*** | 1.043*** | 0.0568*** | 0.859** | 0.0425* |
[0.321, 1.983] | [0.0280, 0.100] | [0.293, 2.320] | [0.0190, 0.100] | [0.0400, 2.202] | [−0.00371, 0.0886] | ||
| |||||||
Observations | 370,996 | 370,996 | 307,438 | 307,438 | 281,624 | 281,624 | |
R-squared | 0.792 | 0.750 | 0.790 | 0.763 | 0.794 | 0.772 |
(2a) | (2b) | (2c) | (2d) | (2e) | (2f) | ||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
L | Log(L) | L | Log(L) | L | Log(L) | ||
Hours per week | Hours per week | Hours per week | Hours per week | Hours per week | Hours per week | ||
| |||||||
SAMPLE |
Workers with a paid job and wages>0 in the given period |
Workers with a paid job and wages>0 over the entire period |
Workers with a paid job and wages>0 and no job switch over the entire period |
||||
MA* ESHI* After* Large | ϒ1 | 5.761*** | 0.215*** | 11.883*** | 0.480*** | 12.771*** | 0.498*** |
[5.358, 6.567] | [0.204, 0.245] | [11.085, 13.147] | [0.454, 0.527] | [11.780, 13.719] | [0.462, 0.534] | ||
MA* ESHI* During* Large | ϒ1d | 2.377*** | 0.0787*** | 5.711*** | 0.199*** | 5.638*** | 0.206*** |
[1.755, 2.903] | [0.0540, 0.100] | [4.670, 6.083] | [0.154, 0.220] | [4.536, 6.233] | [0.162, 0.251] | ||
MA* ESHI* Large | ϒ8 | 1.244*** | 0.0544*** | −0.134 | 0.0218 | 0.106 | 0.0248* |
[0.665, 1.585] | [0.0350, 0.0650] | [−0.786, 0.372] | [−0.00400, 0.0370] | [−0.624, 0.720] | [−0.00241, 0.0519] | ||
MA* After* Large | ϒ11 | −6.243*** | −0.260*** | −12.60*** | −0.544*** | −12.21*** | −0.541*** |
[−7.000, −5.584] | [−0.288, −0.240] | [−13.544, −11.280] | [−0.580, −0.508] | [−13.201, −11.216] | [−0.578, −0.504] | ||
MA* During* Large | ϒ11d | −2.557*** | −0.0885*** | −6.162*** | −0.231*** | −5.647*** | −0.220*** |
[−3.209, −1.923] | [−0.114, −0.0660] | [−6.680, −5.331] | [−0.253, −0.199] | [−6.384, −4.731] | [−0.253, −0.187] | ||
ESHI* After* Large | ϒ12 | −0.828*** | −0.0275*** | −0.766 | −0.0279 | −0.692* | −0.0307* |
[−1.436, −0.256] | [−0.0510, −0.00900] | [−1.584, 0.199] | [−0.0560, 0.00300] | [−1.540, 0.0170] | [−0.0632, 0.00182] | ||
ESHI* During* Large | ϒ12d | −0.833*** | −0.0288** | −0.779** | −0.0266* | −0.629* | −0.0246* |
[−1.228, −0.294] | [−0.0460, −0.00800] | [−1.229, −0.152] | [−0.0470, 0.00200] | [−1.254, 0.0940] | [−0.0514, 0.00226] | ||
ESHI* Large | ϒ19 | 0.794*** | 0.0240*** | 0.651*** | 0.0178*** | 0.452** | 0.0117 |
[0.530, 1.121] | [0.0120, 0.0350] | [0.400, 1.096] | [0.00600, 0.0350] | [0.0400, 0.897] | [−0.00757, 0.0310] | ||
After* Large | ϒ22 | 0.509 | 0.0110 | 0.586 | 0.0177 | 0.502 | 0.0185 |
[−0.159, 1.110] | [−0.0100, 0.0320] | [−0.558, 1.366] | [−0.0210, 0.0440] | [−0.286, 1.255] | [−0.0147, 0.0518] | ||
During* Large | ϒ22d | 0.544* | 0.0120 | 0.601* | 0.0151 | 0.550 | 0.0144 |
[−0.0420, 0.977] | [−0.0140, 0.0330] | [−0.0310, 1.046] | [−0.0120, 0.0350] | [−0.285, 1.120] | [−0.0134, 0.0423] | ||
Large | ϒ23 | −2.100 | −0.0621 | −1.527 | −0.0328 | −0.501 | −0.0143 |
[−2.597, 4.995] | [−0.0760, 0.258] | [−2.015, 7.011] | [−0.0520, 0.392] | [−0.999, 6.232] | [−0.0492, 0.0206] | ||
MA* Large | ϒ24 | 2.053 | 0.0565 | 2.330 | 0.0429 | 1.400 | 0.0336 |
[−5.041, 2.853] | [−0.263, 0.0840] | [−6.070, 3.228] | [−0.375, 0.0800] | [−5.303, 2.368] | [−0.0123, 0.0794] | ||
MA* ESHI* After | ϒ1e | −3.789*** | −0.131*** | −6.904*** | −0.268*** | −8.296*** | −0.303*** |
[−4.529, −3.252] | [−0.160, −0.112] | [−8.162, −6.135] | [−0.311, −0.246] | [−9.240, −7.228] | [−0.342, −0.264] | ||
MA* ESHI* During | ϒ1ed | −3.202*** | −0.0792*** | −5.816*** | −0.161*** | −5.896*** | −0.170*** |
[−3.724, −2.629] | [−0.0970, −0.0590] | [−6.137, −4.876] | [−0.170, −0.125] | [−6.503, −5.110] | [−0.198, −0.142] | ||
MA* ESHI | ϒ8e | 0.613** | −0.00170 | 1.913*** | 0.0380*** | 2.032*** | 0.0460** |
[0.0220, 1.127] | [−0.0210, 0.0160] | [1.133, 2.608] | [0.0130, 0.0650] | [1.087, 2.836] | [0.00541, 0.0867] | ||
MA* After | ϒ11e | 4.601*** | 0.182*** | 7.600*** | 0.331*** | 7.656*** | 0.340*** |
[3.841, 5.159] | [0.159, 0.205] | [6.397, 8.355] | [0.295, 0.360] | [6.571, 8.542] | [0.302, 0.378] | ||
MA* During | ϒ11ed | 3.796*** | 0.101*** | 6.437*** | 0.201*** | 6.321*** | 0.200*** |
[3.102, 4.357] | [0.0780, 0.121] | [5.483, 6.824] | [0.166, 0.212] | [5.506, 6.995] | [0.172, 0.228] | ||
ESHI* After | ϒ12e | −0.241 | −0.0122 | −0.177 | −0.00713 | −0.114 | −0.00333 |
[−0.834, 0.356] | [−0.0300, 0.0100] | [−0.904, 0.647] | [−0.0290, 0.0220] | [−0.856, 0.604] | [−0.0319, 0.0252] | ||
ESHI* During | ϒ12ed | −0.0257 | −0.00173 | −0.0786 | −0.00428 | −0.132 | −0.00297 |
[−0.425, 0.286] | [−0.0150, 0.0110] | [−0.517, 0.326] | [−0.0220, 0.0110] | [−0.589, 0.326] | [−0.0192, 0.0133] | ||
ESHI | ϒ19e | 1.218*** | 0.0491*** | 1.265*** | 0.0500*** | 1.296*** | 0.0507*** |
[0.876, 1.427] | [0.0370, 0.0590] | [0.814, 1.499] | [0.0310, 0.0590] | [0.758, 1.656] | [0.0298, 0.0717] | ||
After | ϒ22e | 0.542** | 0.0326*** | 0.225 | 0.0158 | 0.0720 | 0.0115 |
[0.0140, 1.244] | [0.0130, 0.0530] | [−0.504, 0.949] | [−0.0100, 0.0380] | [−0.551, 1.023] | [−0.0145, 0.0375] | ||
During | ϒ22ed | 0.385** | 0.0236*** | 0.298 | 0.0196** | 0.201 | 0.0151 |
[0.00900, 0.844] | [0.0100, 0.0390] | [−0.107, 0.676] | [0.00400, 0.0330] | [−0.263, 0.691] | [−0.00387, 0.0341] | ||
| |||||||
Observations | 344,315 | 344,315 | 287,144 | 287,144 | 263,033 | 263,033 | |
R-squared | 0.720 | 0.698 | 0.708 | 0.679 | 0.718 | 0.691 |
(3a) | (3b) | (3c) | (3d) | (3e) | (3f) | ||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
w,L | Log(w),Log(L) | w,L | Log(w),Log(L) | w,L | Log(w),Log(L) | ||
Compensating and Hours Differentials, Sufficient Statistics, and Welfare Impact of Health Reform | |||||||
| |||||||
Workers with a paid job and wages>0 in the given period |
Workers with a paid job and wages>0 over the entire period |
Workers with a paid job and wages>0 and no job switch over the entire period |
|||||
wD−wA | 2.251*** | 0.135*** | 2.33*** | 0.123*** | 2.515*** | 0.130*** | |
[1.797, 2.465] | [0.11, 0.146] | [1.775, 2.628] | [0.098, 0.138] | [1.789, 2.842] | [0.108, 0.156] | ||
wF−wB | 0.809*** | 0.172*** | 1.248*** | 0.284*** | 0.321 | 0.300*** | |
[0.418, 1.09] | [0.125, 0.217] | [0.266, 1.371] | [0.244, 0.312] | [−0.467, 0.725] | [0.253, 0.338] | ||
wD−wB | 4.886*** | 0.49*** | 7.072*** | 0.773*** | 6.878*** | 0.821*** | |
[3.655, 5.84] | [0.432, 0.557] | [4.968, 8.184] | [0.714, 0.839] | [4.802, 8.225] | [0.747, 0.903] | ||
wF−wA | −1.826*** | −0.184*** | −3.494*** | −0.366*** | −4.042*** | −0.391*** | |
[−2.779, −0.903] | [−0.234, −0.138] | [−4.675, −2.768] | [−0.425, −0.319] | [−5.132, −3.158] | [−0.488, −0.381] | ||
LD−LA | 1.857*** | 0.053*** | 1.779*** | 0.06*** | 2.138*** | 0.071*** | |
[1.264, 2.205] | [0.033, 0.063] | [1.215, 2.149] | [0.04, 0.073] | [1.551, 2.509] | [0.056, 0.093] | ||
LF−LB | 3.829*** | 0.137*** | 6.758*** | 0.271*** | 6.613*** | 0.266*** | |
[3.27, 4.293] | [0.117, 0.154] | [6.138, 7.214] | [0.247, 0.294] | [5.963, 7.122] | [0.247, 0.294] | ||
LD−LB | 8.1*** | 0.313*** | 14.379*** | 0.604*** | 14.348*** | 0.612*** | |
[7.198, 8.819] | [0.285, 0.341] | [12.895, 15.24] | [0.561, 0.64] | [13.063, 15.45] | [0.572, 0.665] | ||
LF−LA | −2.414*** | −0.123*** | −5.842*** | −0.273*** | −5.598*** | −0.275*** | |
[−3.197, −1.649] | [−0.153, −0.098] | [−6.664, −4.743] | [−0.308, −0.241] | [−6.601, −4.718] | [−0.303, −0.240] | ||
s | 0.170 | 0.100 | 0.170 | 0.100 | 0.170 | 0.100 | |
- | - | - | - | - | - | ||
d | −0.350 | −0.200 | −0.350 | −0.200 | −0.350 | −0.200 | |
- | - | - | - | - | - | ||
b | 2.671*** | 0.209*** | 5.538*** | 0.421*** | 6.001*** | 0.446*** | |
[1.523, 3.838] | [0.161, 0.262] | [4.629, 6.933] | [0.369, 0.484] | [4.992, 7.319] | [0.404, 0.519] | ||
ρ | 0.053*** | 0.68*** | 0.026*** | 0.337*** | 0.024*** | 0.318*** | |
[0.037, 0.094] | [0.542, 0.88] | [0.02, 0.031] | [0.293, 0.384] | [0.019, 0.028] | [0.287, 0.364] | ||
α+λ−μx | 0.53*** | 0.823*** | 0.451*** | 0.806*** | 0.515*** | 0.815*** | |
[0.304, 0.641] | [0.778, 0.846] | [0.379, 0.552] | [0.785, 0.824] | [0.436, 0.579] | [0.796, 0.829] | ||
ESHIAfter | 0.740 | 0.740 | 0.740 | 0.740 | 0.740 | 0.740 | |
- | - | - | - | - | - | ||
|
1.000 | 1.000 | 1.000 | 1.000 | 1.000 | 1.000 | |
- | - | - | - | - | - | ||
DWLm | 1.126*** | 0.01*** | 6.572*** | 0.017*** | 6.033*** | 0.017*** | |
[0.529, 1.971] | [0.01, 0.011] | [4.333, 8.549] | [0.015, 0.019] | [4.291, 8.39] | [0.015, 0.018] | ||
|
0.164*** | 0.144*** | 0.223*** | 0.057*** | 0.174*** | 0.052*** | |
[0.096, 0.361] | [0.096, 0.235] | [0.149, 0.285] | [0.047, 0.069] | [0.131, 0.236] | [0.045, 0.061] |
p<0.01,
p<0.05,
p<0.1, 95% confidence intervals reported; CIs block bootstrapped by state.
Including full 18–64 population; only includes interview months.
All specifications include individual, state, and state*large firm fixed effects. Monthly weights used.
Large firm defined as >25 employees.