Table 3.
Ablation modalities | Description of the technique | Outcome | Ref. |
RFA | RFA uses a balloon-based circumferential array of closely spaced electrodes to deliver radiofrequency energy to the esophageal mucosa. With this technique, the mucosa is ablated to the submucosal level. A smaller, endoscope-mounted, radiofrequency catheter ablation device could be used for the focal ablation of metaplasia that could remain after treatment with the circumferential system. A follow-up endoscopy is at 3 mo when any remaining metaplasia is ablated, with a further follow-up endoscopy at 1 yr | A landmark large, multicentre, randomized trial showed that RFA can eliminate HGD, reducing the risk of EAC compared with a sham procedure. Overall, the eradication rates for HGD range from 79% to 90% and from 69% and 97% for NDBE/LGD patients RFA is safer and easier to administer, and it causes fewer major complications, particularly stricture formation, than PDT | [133,145] |
APC | APC produces a flow of ionized argon plasma that generates a high-frequency monopolar current to the BE surface under direct vision | Different eradication rates for NDBE and LGD in the short term ranged from 36% to 100% for NDBE and rates of recurrence between 62% and 100% for LGD patients | [133] |
PDT | PDT is based on the injection of a light sensitizing drug (e.g., porfimer sodium) into the patient and then the exposure of a portion of the esophagus to light of a specific wavelength, which would lead to dysplasia cell death. Once the photosensitizer is activated by the light, it generates oxygen free radicals that result in cytotoxicity to the mucosal cells | The eradication rates for HGD range from 77% to 100%, and those for NDBE/LGD range from 50%-100% of patients The limitations include the cost of the intravenous agent, the prolonged period (weeks) of photosensitivity following exposure, and an appreciable post-treatment stricture rate | [133] |
CRY | CRY is a non-contact method of cryotherapy that involves an endoscopically directed spray of liquid nitrogen at -196 °C directly onto the Barrett’s mucosa The advantage is a lack of contact with mucosa and hence can be applied to irregularity, which would make the application of contact therapies such as RFA challenging | The rates of complete eradication are approximately 68%-97% for HGD and 57% for NDBE The current literature is inadequate to assess the ability of CRY to achieve sustained reversion of the metaplastic mucosa to normal-appearing squamous epithelium in subjects at any stage of BE. Further longitudinal studies are needed | [133,156] |
MPEC | MPEC uses an endoscopic multipolar electrical probe, which is used to control gastrointestinal haemorrhage that applies electrical energy at 50 W so that all BE surfaces are treated | Complete eradication in 65%-100% of NDBE. This technique is very much operator dependent and causes dysphagia as the most common side effect | [133] |
RFA: Radiofrequency ablation; APC: Argon plasma coagulation; PDT: Photodynamic therapy; CRY: Cryoablation; MPEC: Multipolar electrocoagulation; EAC: Esophageal adenocarcinoma; BE: Barrett’s esophagus; IM: Intestinal metaplasia; NDBE: Non-dysplastic Barrett’s esophagus; LGD: Low-grade dysplasia; HGD: High-grade dysplasia.