Skip to main content
. 2016 Apr 28;11(4):e0154191. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0154191

Table 3. Results for D = 10, N = 50, FEs = 100,000.

Function Algorithm
CLPSO ECLPSO DNLPSO LILPSO1 LILPSO2
F1 mean 4.94E−19 1.78E−30 5.71E−177 1.64E−58 1.11E−73
sd 2.19E−37 2.34E−60 1.11E−123 7.11E−116 6.27E−146
ttest + + +
F2 mean 1.26E+00 1 1.86E−03 1.00E+00 3.28E−01
sd 1.79E+00 3.80E−09 2.64E−02 6.32E−10 1.71E−01
ttest + + +
F3 mean 2.05E−18 1.03E−30 0.00E+00 0.00E+00 0.00E+00
sd 2.27E−36 9.88E−61 0.00E+00 0.00E+00 0.00E+00
ttest + + = =
F4 mean 1.50E−11 6.22E+00 1.96E−66 2.29E−13 1.50E−16
sd 3.73E−23 5.67E+01 3.31E−54 1.54E−27 1.61E−33
ttest + + +
F5 mean 5.00E−03 2.30E−03 5.21E−01 4.50E−03 1.40E−03
sd 3.34E−06 1.74E−06 1.89E−01 3.40E−06 1.99E−07
ttest + + + +
F6 mean 2.20E−18 2.85E−29 4.71E−32 4.71E−32 4.71E−32
sd 4.46E−36 7.99E−57 0.00E+00 0.00E+00 0.00E+00
ttest + + = =
F7 mean 2.02E−16 1.41E−27 1.35E−32 2.45E−32 1.35E−32
sd 3.24E−32 5.91E−54 0.00E+00 1.44E−65 0.00E+00
ttest + + = =
F8 mean 1.94E−08 3.55E−15 3.26E−15 2.58E−11 1.84E−14
sd 1.49E−16 4.21E−30 1.83E−15 3.02E−22 6.84E−28
ttest + + = +
F15 mean 3.76E−02 2.31E+00 2.02E+01 6.27E−05 2.01E−08
sd 4.01E−04 2.83E+01 4.04E−01 4.38E−09 2.26E−16
ttest + + + +
F16 mean 6.11E+00 7.09E+01 7.57E+00 2.71E+00 2.67E+00
sd 7.02E+00 1.03E+02 4.70E+00 8.83E+00 6.65E+00
ttest + + + +
F17 mean 1.40E−01 1.84E+01 8.07E−03 1.52E−04 9.29E−02
sd 3.10E−03 2.53E+02 1.14E−01 2.01E−08 1.09E−02
ttest + + =