Skip to main content
. 2016 Apr 28;11(4):e0154191. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0154191

Table 7. results for D = 50, N = 100, FEs = 500,000.

Function Algorithm
CLPSO ECLPSO DNLPSO LILPSO1 LILPSO2
F1 mean 1.07E−08 8.06E+03 9.44E−74 2.60E−57 4.77E−74
sd 5.82E−18 1.26E+07 9.13E−32 1.22E−113 5.61E−147
ttest + + + +
F2 mean 3.16E+01 1.08E+01 1.86E−03 1.00E+00 2.28E−01
sd 2.04E+02 8.00E+02 2.64E−02 6.23E−14 1.89E−01
ttest + + +
F3 mean 3.19E−08 2.03E+04 0.00E+00 0.00E+00 0.00E+00
sd 4.15E−17 1.14E+08 0.00E+00 0.00E+00 0.00E+00
ttest + + = =
F4 mean 2.59E−05 1.27E+02 7.02E−09 8.85E−09 3.84E−13
sd 2.80E−11 2.38E+02 2.29E−06 1.99E−18 5.09E−25
ttest + + + +
F5 mean 2.69E−02 1.97E−02 6.11E−01 1.32E−02 9.30E−03
sd 1.64E−05 2.05E−05 2.20E−01 1.92E−06 8.08E−06
ttest + + + +
F6 mean 1.73E−09 1.35E+02 1.50E−32 1.28E−32 9.42E−33
sd 3.25E−19 3.25E+05 0.00E+00 2.57E−66 0.00E+00
ttest + + + +
F7 mean 1.69E−06 1.92E+02 1.34E−32 8.75E−31 9.42E−33
sd 2.23E−13 7.26E+05 0.00E+00 1.77E−60 0.00E+00
ttest + + + +
F8 mean 3.95E−04 1.58E+01 1.90E+01 8.13E−08 3.05E−14
sd 1.20E−08 1.43E+01 0.00E+00 1.87E−15 1.55E−27
ttest + + + +
F15 mean 6.80E+00 1.81E+01 2.07E+01 1.86E−01 3.07E−01
sd 2.47E−01 9.77E−02 1.13E−02 2.86E−02 3.61E−01
ttest + + +
F16 mean 1.07E+02 1.65E+02 3.40E+01 8.83E+01 8.13E+01
sd 5.02E+01 2.03E+02 8.03E+00 2.27E+02 1.22E+04
ttest + + =
F17 mean 2.63E+00 4.40E+02 1.11E−02 2.75E−01 2.54E−01
sd 1.61E−01 4.54E+01 1.12E−02 2.46E−02 4.04E−02
ttest + + =