Table 3.
Characteristic | Response rate in the experimental arm | |
---|---|---|
No. of studies | RR % (95% CI) | |
Personalized status | ||
Personalized | 44 | 48 (42 to 55) |
Nonpersonalized | 67 | 23 (20 to 27) |
P (univariate) | <.001 | |
P (meta-regression)* | <.001 | |
Study design† | ||
Randomized | 56 | 25 (21 to 31) |
Nonrandomized | 55 | 40 (35 to 45) |
P (univariate) | <.001 | |
P (meta-regression)* | .14 | |
Tumor type | ||
Solid | 66 | 24 (20 to 28) |
Hematologic | 45 | 46 (40 to 53) |
P (univariate) | <.001 | |
P (meta-regression)* | <.001 | |
Treatment status | ||
Naïve | 30 | 40 (33 to 49) |
Pretreated | 81 | 29 (25 to 34) |
P (univariate) | .01 | |
P (meta-regression)* | <.001 | |
Class of agent | ||
Cytotoxic | 23 | 30 (24 to 36) |
Targeted | 88 | 33 (28 to 38) |
P (univariate) | .44 | |
P (meta-regression)* | NA | |
Single agent | ||
Yes | 87 | 31(27 to 36) |
No | 24 | 35 (28 to 43) |
P (univariate) | .39 | |
P (meta-regression)* | NA | |
Patients per arm‡ | ||
6–178 | 56 | 38 (33 to 44) |
179–839 | 55 | 27 (22 to 32) |
P (univariate) | .04 | |
P (meta-regression)* | .19 | |
Route | ||
Oral | 53 | 26 (23 to 35) |
Intravenous | 58 | 36 (31 to 41) |
P (univariate) | .09 | |
P (meta-regression)* | NA | |
Approval date‡ | ||
09/1998-09/2007 | 53 | 35 (29 to 42) |
10/2007-06/2013 | 58 | 30 (25 to 35) |
P (univariate) | .23 | |
P (meta-regression)* | NA |
* Meta-regression analysis was performed, including only factors considered statistically significant in univariate analysis; otherwise, analysis was not applicable for the characteristic. All P values were two-sided. CI = confidence interval; RR = rate ratio.
† Response rates (95% CI) in the experimental arm were 41% (30%-52%) for randomized personalized trials (n = 18 studies), 20% (15%-25%) for randomized nonpersonalized trials (n = 38), 54% (46%-61%) for nonrandomized personalized trials (n = 26), and 29% (26%-34%) for nonrandomized nonpersonalized trials (n = 29); all P values were less than .001 for comparison of personalized vs nonpersonalized trials within randomized and nonrandomized trials.
‡ Cutoff used was the median of distribution.