Skip to main content
. Author manuscript; available in PMC: 2016 May 5.
Published in final edited form as: Prog Cardiovasc Dis. 2014 Aug 12;57(2):215–225. doi: 10.1016/j.pcad.2014.08.003

Table 4.

Studies Assessing Frailty and Outcome in TAVI vs. Cardiac Surgery.

Study Parameter(s) Result HR/OR; 95% CI,
P value*
Green et al.(68) Gaits speed, grip
strength, serum
albumin, ADL status
in frailty score with
TAVI
↑ frailty score correlates
with ↑ 1 year mortality
HR 3.5; CI: 1.4 to
8.5, p< 0.007
Afialo et al.(83) Frailty and disability
score in cardiac
surgery
5 meter gait speed and Nagi
disability score ≥ 3, ↑
mortality
Gait: OR 2.63; CI,
1.17 to 5.90
Nagi: OR 2.98; CI,
1.35–6.56
De Areza et
al.(84)
EuroSCORE + 6
minute walk test for
SAVR
6 minute walk distance
associated with composite
CV outcome
HR 0.28; CI, 0.09
to 0.85, p=0.025
Lee et al.(85) Frailty based on
impairment of ADLs,
ambulation, or history
of dementia in
cardiac surgery
Frailty - ↑ hospital mortality
and ↑ hospital stay
OR 1.8; CI, 1.1 to
3.0 for mortality
Schoenenberger
et al.(86)
Frailty index to assess
functional decline
after TAVI
Frailty index strongly
predicted functional decline
OR 1.56; CI, 1.20
to 2.04; p= 0.001
Stortecky et
al.(67)
Multidimensional
Geriatric Assessment
(MGA) tool to predict
adverse events in
TAVI
Frailty characteristics-
cognitive impairment,
malnutrition, mobility
impairment, limitations in
ADLs - were predictive of
increased mortality.
OR 3.29; CI, 1.06
to 10.15; for MGA

ADL = activity of daily living, CV= cardiovascular

*

p value given if available.