Skip to main content
. 2016 May 13;7:592. doi: 10.3389/fpls.2016.00592

Table 2.

Response of legume species to isolates of D. pinodes in seedling stage, measured 10 days after inoculation under controlled conditions.

Legume host Code Dp-M07-4 Dp-Esc-13 Dp-KHM-13 Dp-ANN-13 Dp-JAP-03 Dp-PO-03 Dp-CO-99 Dp-PdT-03 Dp-FR-88 Dl-AL10 Dr-Pt04 Df-AU04 Df-857
DRA DSB DR DS DR DS DR DS DR DS DR DS DR DS DR DS DR DS DR DS DR DS DR DS DR DS
PEAS
Pisum sativum Messire3 5 80bc* 5 77b 5 63b 5 63ab 4.7 66bc 5 50a 5 79ab 5 50a 5 50a 0 0 0 0 2 2a 0 0
P. sativum J20 5 87ab 5 93a 5 98a 5 80ab 5 100a 5 62a 5 87a 5 43a 4 35a 0 0 0 0 0 0b 0 0
P. sativum J4 5 95a 5 90ab 5 75ab 5 83ab 5 100a 4.3 40a 5 57bc 5 25a 4 15b 0 0 0 0 0 0b 0 0
P. sativum 6NIL 5 83ab 5 93a 5 82ab 5 92a 5 77b 5 70a 5 47c 5 25a 5 30a 0 0 0 0 0 0b 0 0
P. fulvum IFPI3260 4 67c 3.3 57c 4.7 60b 4 51.7b 4 42c 4.7 63a 1.3 7d 3 25a 3 22b 0 0 0 0 0 0b 0 0
AVERAGE 82A 81A 76A 74A 78A 57A 54A 30A 26A 0B 0B 0.3C 0E
WHITE LUPIN
Lupinus albus Giza 21 – – 5 95a – – 5 40a 4 7b 5 47a 4 15a – – 3 13a – – 0 0 0 0 0 0
L. albus Lup344 3 20a 5 100a 5 47a 5 50a 5 40ab 4.7 43a 5 25a 3.3 40a 3 5a – – 0 0 0 0 0 0
L. albus Lup354 4 35a 5 22b 5 37ab 5 50a 5 67a 4 40a 5 20a 3 9b 3 12a 3.3 20a 0 0 0 0 0 0
L. albus Lup394 4.3 20a 5 25b 5 26b 5 50a 5 40ab 4.7 44a 5 25a 5 46a 3.3 15a 0 0b 0 0 0 0 0 0
AVERAGE 25CDE 53B 37B 47B 38B 43B 21.5BC 33A 9B 10B 0B 0C 0E
CLOVERS
Trifolium pratense E075 4.7 47a 4.3 30a 4.7 37a 5 58a 4 40a 4.7 38a 3 20a 4.7 30a 3 10a 2.7 12a 0 0 3 13a 3 8a
T. subterraneum E085 4 20a 3.3 20a 4 20ab 4 37a 5 32a 3.5 20a 2 17a 3 20a 3 3a 0 0b 0 0 0 0b 2.3 6a
T. repens Anteria1 3.7 26a 4.3 30a 4.3 17b 4.7 30a 4.2 38a 3.3 15a 2 16a 5 32a 3 8a 0 0b 0 0 0 0b 2 7a
AVERAGE 31BCD 27CDE 24BC 42BC 36B 25BC 17BC 27A 7B 4B 0B 4BC 8CD
MEDICKS
Medicago truncatula Parabinga1 – – 3 20ab 2.7 10a 2.3 35a 5 40b 2 5b 2.7 25a 2 5a 1.3 5a 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
M. truncatula Paraggio1 2 20a 2 12b 4 20a 2.3 27a 3.7 37b 2 5b 2 30a – – 2 6a 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
M. truncatula M2634 1.7 18a 3.7 53a 2.7 10a 2 30a 4.5 80a 2.3 30a 2 37a 2 5a 1.3 11a 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
M. orbicularis M2644 2 27a – – 2.7 7a 3 15a 4.3 37b – – 2.7 35a 2 10a – – 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
M. orbicularis M2814 – – 4.3 47a 3 10a 3.3 21a 4.5 60ab 4.7 32a – – 2 8a 3 15a 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
AVERAGE 22DEF 36BCD 12CD 25CD 38B 23C 34B 7BC 9B 0B 0B 0C 0E
ONEFLOWER VETCH
Vicia articulata BGE0133766 4 37a 3 37a 4 27a 4.3 45ab 4 23a 2.3 23a – – 4.3 40a 2.7 8a 0 0 0 0 3 8a 3 4a
V. articulata BGE0139846 4 43a 4.3 60a 3.7 30a 4 43ab 4 53a 3 25a 3 30a 3.7 28a 3 11a 0 0 0 0 0 0b 0 0a
V. articulata BGE0139856 4 40a 3.7 63a 4.3 33a 4.3 53a 5 53a 3.7 33a 2 15a 4.3 30a 3 8a 0 0 2.3 3a 0 0b 2.3 3a
V. articulata BGE0188246 4 43a 4 60a 4.3 32a 4 28b 4 50a 3 35a 3 20a 4.7 33a 2.7 7a 0 0 0 0 0 0b 0 0a
AVERAGE 41BC 55B 30B 43BC 48B 29BC 22BC 35A 9B 0B 0.8B 2BC 2DE
CHICKPEA
Cicer arietinum ILC722 3 15a 4 13a 2.7 6a 4.3 8a 1 1a 4.3 30a 0.7 2a 4.3 7a 1.3 3a 0 0b 0.3 5b 0 0 0 0
C. arietinum M382 3.3 10a 3.4 15a 3.7 5a 4.7 8a 3.3 10a 5 30a 4.5 25b 5 15a 1.3 2a 0 0b 4.7 40a 0 0 0 0
C. arietinum AS182 1.7 9a 3 8a 3 4a – – 3 12a 4.7 21a 3 5a 4.3 7a 1 3a 3 30a 5 37a 0 0 0 0
C. arietinum AS192 2.7 10a 2 13a 3 5a 5 5a 3 12a 5 28a 3 7a 5 8a – – 0 0b 3.8 35a 0 0 0 0
C. arietinum AS232 – – 3 10a – – 5 7a 2.7 5a – – – – 5 10a 1 1a 0 0b 2.6 40b 0 0 0 0
AVERAGE 10EF 12EF 5D 7DE 8D 28BC 8C 10BC 2B 6B 31.4A 0C 0E
LENTIL
Lens culinaris S172 4 29a 4.3 62a 4 47a 4.7 53a 5 48ab 3.7 35a – – 3.7 15a 2 17a 4.3 24a 0 0 0 0 3 6a
L. culinaris S232 4 57a 3.7 60a 4.7 47a 5 67a 5 60a 2.7 25a 2.3 10a 4 33a 2 8ab 4.3 28a 0 0 0 0 1.5 3ab
L. culinaris R52 4 30a 4.7 57a 4 27b 4.7 37a 4 50ab 3.3 30a 3 22a 4 17a 2 4b 4 45a 0 0 0 0 0 0b
L. culinaris R172 4 43a 4 50a 4.5 42ab 4.7 45a 4 32b 3.7 20a 1.3 7a 3.3 7b 0.7 2b 4 48a 0 0 0 0 1.3 1b
AVERAGE 40BCD 58B 40B 49B 46B 27BC 13BC 18AB 6B 35A 0B 0C 3CDE
SOYBEAN
Glycine max PI081005 1.7 8 0 0 3 10 3.3 12 3 30 1 1 2 17 2 5 3 4 0 0 3 4 3.3 17 4 30
AVERAGE 8EF 0F 10CD 12DE 30BC 1D 17BC 5BC 4B 0B 4AB 17A 30A