Comparison between HDR- and NHEJ-mediated reporter knock-in. (A) Schematics showing a zoomed-in view of the sg-1–4 target sites and their positions on the genomic GAPDH locus, as well as the design of ires-eGFP(+HAs) Donor-1, 2, 2.A and 2.B plasmids. Homology arm regions used in the ires-eGFP(+HAs) donor-1 are highlighted in gray, and the HAs used in donor-2, 2.A and 2.B are highlighted in purple. Donor-2.A carries a single sg-A target site at the 3′, and Donor-2.B carries a sg-A target site at the 5′ of the ires-eGFP(+HAs) cassette. (B) FACS analysis of LO2 cells transfected with the ires-eGFP(+HAs) donor-1/Cas9 and sg-1, 2, 3 or 4. Due to the different target positions on the genome and the donor, sg-1 induced HDR-mediated knock-in; sg-2 and sg-3 induced NHEJ-based knock-in; and sg-4 mainly produced GFP+ cells via the HDR-based knock-in through the intact 5′ homology arm. (C) FACS analysis showing HDR-mediated knock-in with circular and linear donor templates. The ires-eGFP(+HAs) Donor-2, 2.A or 2.B were transfected together with Cas9/sg-1 or Cas9/sg-2. The Donor-2.A and 2.B were both examined in the presence of sg-A (linear) as well as in the absence of sg-A (circular). Cas9/sg-A cleaves the Donor-2.A at 3′ of the ires-eGFP(+HAs) cassette and the linearized Donor 2.A produced GFP+ cells via HDR-mediated knock-in. Distinctly, Cas9/sg-A cleaves the Donor-2.B at 5′ of the ires-eGFP(+HAs) cassette, and the linearized Donor 2.B produced high proportion of GFP+ cells via both NHEJ- and HDR-mediated knock-in. (D) FACS results showing NHEJ- and HDR-mediated reporter knock-in at ACTB, SOX17 and T gene loci. Upper panel shows the schematics of ires-eGFP and PGK-eGFP reporters used for knock-in at ACTB and SOX17 or T gene loci, respectively. Single-cut NH-donor was co-transfected with Cas9/sg-A/sgACTB-i or sgACTB-ii to target the ACTB locus (lower left panel, top two rows); while the CE NH-donor was co-transfected with Cas9/sg-A/sgSOX17-i, sgSOX17-ii or sgT-i to target the SOX17 or T gene loci (lower right panel, top two rows). ACTB HDR-donor carrying ires-eGFP, and SOX17 and T HDR-donors containing PGK-eGFP, were co-transfected with Cas9 and corresponding sgRNAs to examine the HDR-based knock-in (lower panel, bottom row). Control samples were transfected without gene-specific sgRNA or sg-A. FACS analysis for the tests at ACTB locus was performed at day 5 after transfection. Cells transfected with PGK-eGFP containing donors for the tests at SOX17 and T loci, were maintained for five passages before FACS analysis. GFP+ cells are gated to the right of the dashed line in each panel.