Skip to main content
. 2016 Jun 3;11(6):e0156227. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0156227

Table 6. Comparison of our results with other researchers’ results corresponding to comparable spectral regions.

Nagata et al. [20] Siedlecki et al. [22] Pérez-Merino et al. [23]
Methods (apparatus) of other researchers A modified chromoretinoscopy of Bobier & Sivak Custom visual refractometer PR50 (Rodenstock GmbH) Laser ray tracing
Spectral range (nm) 500~640 nm 470~660 nm 532~785 nm
Previous study Phakic eye (27 eyes) 0.82±0.16 D Alcon (AcrySof series) (SA60AT) (14 eyes) 1.45±0.42 D Alcon (AcrySof series) (SN60WF) (9 eyes) 0.75±0.12 D
PMMA (48 eyes) 0.75±0.18 D Alcon (AcrySof series) (SN60WF) (9 eyes) 1.17±0.52 D AMO (ZB99) (9 eyes) 0.46±0.15 D
Acrylic (AcrySof series) (49 eyes) 1.20±0.22 D
Our previous study Phakic eye (45 eyes) 0.84±0.27 D Phakic eye (45 eyes) 1.19±0.46 D Phakic eye (45 eyes) 1.04±0.12 D
This study Alcon (AcrySof series) (SN60WF, SN60AT) (11 eyes) 0.90±0.24 D Alcon (AcrySof series) (SN60WF, SN60AT) (11 eyes) 1.30±0.40 D Alcon (AcrySof series) (SN60WF, SN60AT) (11 eyes) 1.06±0.16 D
HOYA (XY-1) (11 eyes) 0.83±0.22 D HOYA (XY-1) (11 eyes) 1.16±0.37 D HOYA (XY-1) (11 eyes) 1.08±0.14 D
AMO (ZCB00V) (16 eyes) 0.32±0.29 D AMO (ZCB00V) (16 eyes) 0.45±0.43 D AMO (ZCB00V) (16 eyes) 0.41±0.36 D