Table 1.
Study | Starting Substrate | Culture Method | Differentiation Protocol |
Differentiation End Point |
Findings |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
Steenhard et al,37 2005 |
ROSA26 mESCs | Injection into E12–13 kidneys (3–5 d) |
Integration into tubules |
Integration into tubular structures expressing LTL and Na+/K+-adenosine triphosphatase |
|
Kim and Dressier,41 2005 |
ROSA26 mESCs | EB formation | 10% FBS without LIF (2 d) 10% FBS + RA/ activin/BMP7 (5 d) |
Intermediate mesoderm |
Expression of Pax2, WT1, and Lhx1 in EBs by RT-PCR Expression of Pax2 in EBs by IF Integration into LTL+ tubular structures when injected into E12.5 kidneys |
Kobayashi et al,42 2005 |
Wnt4-expressing mESCs |
EB formation | 15% FCS without LIF (2 d) 15% FCS + HGF/ activin (20 d) |
AQP2+ cells in EBs | Expression of AQP2 by RT-PCR Expression of AQP2 by IF Formation of tubular- like structures in 3D culture |
Bruce et al,43 2006 | Pax2-GFP mESCs | EB formation | Serum-free media + BMP4/LIF (16 d) |
Expression of Pax2 in EBs by IF |
|
Yamamoto et al,36 2006 |
mESCs | EB formation | Teratoma formation (2–4 wk) |
Formation of tubular- like structures expressing Pax2 and DBA |
|
Vigneau et al,44 2007 |
T-GFP mESCs | EB formation | Serum-free media + activin (4 d) |
T (Brachyury)+ mesoderm |
T+-GFP cells express cadherin-11, WT1, Pax2, and Wnt4 by RT-PCR T+-GFP cells injected into E11.5 kidneys integrate into the nephrogenic zone T+-GFP cells injected into newborn mice kidneys integrate into proximal tubules |
Nakane et al,50 2009 |
mESCs with tetracycline- inducible Pax2 |
EB formation | Pax2 overexpression | Expression of AQP1 in EBs by IF Expression of Pax2 and integrin α8 by RT-PCR |
|
Morizane et al,45 2009 |
mESCs mi PSCs |
EB formation | 10% FCS (3 d) 10% FCS + GDNF or BMP7 or activin (15 d) |
GDNF and BMP7 induced expression of Pax2 and WT1 Activin induced expression of KSP |
|
Ren et al,46 2010 | mESCs | EB formation | 15% FCS without LIF (2 d) 15% FCS + activin/ RA (6 d) Conditioned media from UB (10 d) |
Renal lineage cells | Expression of Pax2 by IF for IM differentiation Expression of WT1, E-cadherin, POD-1, and Pax2 by IF for renal lineage differentiation |
Mae et al,49 2010 | mESCs | Monolayer | 2% FBS + JAK-inh/ LY294002/ CG1423/RA (8 d) |
Intermediate mesoderm |
Expression of Osr1 and Pax2 by IF |
Nishikawa et al,47 2011 |
mESCs | Monolayer | 10% FBS + activin (2 d) 10% FBS + activin/ BMP4 (2 d) 10% FBS + activin/ BMP4/LiCl (2 d) 10% FBS + activin/ BMP4/LiCl/RA (2 d) Conditioned media from UB and MM cells |
UB-conditioned media induced MM markers. MM-conditioned media induced UB markers |
Expression of T by RT- PCR for PS differentiation Expression of Pax2 and Lhx1 by RT-PCR for IM differentiation Expression of GDNF, WT, and cadherin-11 by RT-PCR for MM differentiation Expression of HoxB7, Wnt11, and c-Ret9 for UB differentiation |
Morizane et al,48 2013 |
mESCs | EB formation Monolayer |
10% FCS + activin (3 d) 10% FCS + activin/ HGF or activin/IGF (15 d) |
Ksp+ cells | Ksp+ cells by FACS Formation of tubular- like structures in Matrigel with expression of kidney markers by IF and RT-PCR Integration of Ksp+ cells into tubular structures of E13.5 kidneys |
Taguchiet al,31 2013 |
mESCs hiPSCs |
EB formation | Serum-free media + activin (1 d) Serum-free media + BMP4/CHIR (2.5 d) Serum-free media + activin/BMP4/ CHIR/ RA/Y27632 (1 d) Serum-free media + CHIR/FGF9/ Y27632 (2 d) |
Metanephric mesenchyme |
Nephron precursors derived from OSR1+ posterior IM and T+ posterior mesoderm Expression of Osr1, WT1, Pax2, Six2, and Sall1 by IF and RT-PCR Co-culture of induced EBs resulted in formation of glomerular-like and tubular-like structures expressing kidney markers Protocol reproducible in hiPSCs with longer time course of differentiation |
FACS, fluorescence-activated cell sorting; FBS, fet al bovine serum; FCS, fet al calf serum; GDNF, glial cell–derived neurotrophic factor; KSP, kidney-specific protein; LIF, leukemia-inhibitory factor; RT-PCR, reverse-transcription polymerase chain reaction.