Table 2.
Study | Starting Substrate |
Culture Method |
Differentiation Protocol | Differentiation End Point |
Findings |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
Schuldiner et al,55 2000 |
hESCs | EB formation | 20% KOSR without LIF and bFGF (5 d) 20% KOSR + HGF or nerve growth factor or activin (10 d) |
Expression of WT1 and RENIN by RT-PCR |
|
Batchelder et al,56 2009 |
hESCs | EB formation Monolayer |
10% FBS + RA/activin/ BMP7 (EB, 2 d) 10% FBS + RA/activin/ BMP7 (monolayer, 6 d) |
PAX2+vimentin+ cells |
Expression of PAX2, WT1, OSR1, EYA1, LHX1, CD24 by RT-PCR Expression of PAX2 and vimentin by IF |
Lin et al,34 2010 | hESCs | Monolayer | 20% FCS (2 d) 5% FCS (12 d) Flow sorting by CD24+podocalyxin+ GCTM2− cells |
Intermediate mesoderm |
Expression of WT1 and PAX2 by IF Up-regulation of renal developmental genes in microarray analysis |
Song et al,57 2012 | hiPSCs | EB formation Monolayer |
2.5% FBS + activin/ BMP7/RA (EB, 3 d) 2.5% FBS + activin/ BMP7/RA (monolayer, 7 d) |
Podocytes | Expression of podocin, synaptopodin, and PAX2 by IF Integration into WT1+ glomerular structures of dissociated- reaggregated E13.5 kidneys |
Narayanan et al,59 2013 |
hESCs | Monolayer | REGM + 0.5% FBS + BMP2 + BMP7 Flow sorting for AQP1+ cells |
Proximal tubular-like cells |
Expression of AQP1 by IF and FACS Integration of AQP1+ cells into tubular compartments of ex vivo newborn mouse kidneys Formation of cord-like structures in Matrigel Parathyroid hormone–stimulated cyclic adenosine monophosphate production, GGT activity, ammonia production |
Mae et al,28 2013 |
OSR1-GFP hiPSCs |
EB formation Monolayer |
Serum-free media + CHIR99021/activin (2 days) Serum-free media + CHIR99021/BMP7 (9–16 d) |
Intermediate mesoderm |
Expression of OSR1-GFP by FACS Expression of PAX2 and WT1 by IF Expression of kidney, adrenal gland, and gonadal markers by IF and RT-PCR Formation of growths with expression of kidney markers when injected into immunocompromised mice Integration into dissociated- reaggregated E11.5 mouse kidneys |
Xia et al,29 2013 | hESCs hiPSCs |
Monolayer | Serum-free media + BMP4/FGF2 (2 d) Serum-free media + RA/ activin/BMP2 (2 d) |
Intermediate mesoderm |
Expression of PAX2, LHX1, OSR1, and WT1 by IF and RT-PCR Integration into ureteric bud structures of dissociated- reaggregated E11.5 kidneys |
Taguchi et al,31 2013 | mESCs hiPSCs |
EB formation | Serum-free media + activin (1d) Serum-free media + BMP4/CHIR (2.5 d) Serum-free media + activin/BMP4/CHIR/ RA/Y27632 (1 d) Serum-free media + CHIR/FGF9/Y27632 (2 d) |
Metanephric mesenchyme |
Nephron precursors derived from OSR1+ posterior IM and T+ posterior mesoderm Expression of Osr1, WT1, Pax2, Six2, and Sall1 by IF and RT- PCR Co-culture of induced EBs resulted in formation of glomerular-like and tubular-like structures expressing kidney markers Protocol reproducible in hiPSCs with longer time course of differentiation |
Takasato et al,30 2013 |
hESCs | Monolayer | Serum-free media + activin/BMP4 or CHIR99021 (2 d) Serum-free media + FGF9 + heparin (4 d) Serum-free media + FGF9 + heparin (6 d) Serum-free media alone (6 d) |
Metanephric mesenchyme |
Expression of PAX2 and LHX1 by IF and RT- PCR (IM) Expression of SIX2, HOXD11, and WT1 by IF (MM) Formation of tubular-like structures expressing ECAD, JAG1, and CADH6 Integration into E12.5–E13.5 kidneys Self-aggregation into tubular-like structures expressing kidney markers |
Lam et al,27 2013 | hESCs hiPSCs |
Monolayer | Serum-free media + CHIR99021 (1.5 d) Serum-free media + FGF2/RA (1.5 d) Serum-free media alone (6 d for tubular structures) or serum-free media + FGF9/activin (3–6 d for MM) |
Intermediate mesoderm |
Expression of PAX2, LHX1, and WT1 by IF Formation of polarized, apically ciliated tubular-like structures expressing LTL, KSP, and NCAD Tubular cells integrate into laminin-bounded structures of E12.5 kidneys Expression of SIX2, SALL1, and WT1 by IF with FGF9 treatment MM cells form LTL+ laminin+ structures in E12.5kidneys |
Araoka et al,63 2014 |
OSR1-GFP hiPSCs |
Monolayer | Serum-free media + CHIR99021 + AM580 or TTNPB (2 d) Serum-free media + AM580 or TTNPB (12 d) |
Intermediate mesoderm |
Expression of OSR1-GFP by FACS Expression of PAX2,WT1, LHX1, and SALL1 by IF Expression of kidney, adrenal gland, and gonadal markers by IF and RT-PCR Integration into dissociated- reaggregated E11.5 kidneys Formation of tubular-like structures in cell aggregates |
FACS, fluorescence-activated cell sorting; FBS, fetal bovine serum; KSP, kidney-specific protein; LIF, leukemia-inhibitory factor; RT-PCR, reverse-transcription polymerase chain reaction.