Table 3.
Culture as reference standard | Cytology as reference standard | Composite reference standard: culture and/or cytology | |||||||||||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Sensitivitya | Specificitya | Cohen’s Kappa | Sensitivitya | Specificitya | Cohen’s Kappa | Sensitivitya | Specificitya | Cohen’s Kappa | |||||||
n/N | n/N | k | n/N | n/N | k | n/N | n/N | k | |||||||
Cytology | 6/9 | 67 % | 22/24 | 92 % | 0.60 | - | - | - | - | - | - | - | - | - | - |
Culture | - | - | - | - | - | 6/8 | 75 % | 22/25 | 88 % | 0.60 | - | - | - | - | - |
ZN | 1/9 | 11 % | 24/25 | 96 % | 0.10 | 3/18 | 17 % | 43/43 | 100 % | 0.22 | 3/21 | 14 % | 41/41 | 100 % | 0.18 |
Xpert | 5/9 | 56 % | 26/27 | 96 % | 0.58 | 11/16 | 69 % | 38/41 | 93 % | 0.64 | 11/19 | 58 % | 40/43 | 93 % | 0.55 |
EasyNAT | 2/9 | 22 % | 30/30 | 100 % | 0.31 | 4/18 | 22 % | 43/43 | 100 % | 0.29 | 4/21 | 19 % | 46/46 | 100 % | 0.24 |
Any diagnostic modality | 6/9 | 67 % | 28/30 | 93 % | 0.62 | 18/18 | 100 % | 40/43 | 93 % | 0.89 | 13/21 | 62 % | 38/41 | 93 % | 0.58 |
aCalculated only for patients without missing data