Table 1. Early Childhood Development Index items.
Domain and Item | Included in Present Study? | Construct Measured | Age Appropriate? | Similar Item Included in ASQ-III or SDQ for 36-to 60-mo Age Range? | Failure of Attainment Acknowledged by AAP as “Possible Sign of Developmental Delay” for Ages 3–4 y? | Rationale for Inclusion/Exclusion |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Literacy-numeracy | Measures of academic knowledge rather than general capacity; items too difficult for young children | |||||
Can your child identify or name at least ten letters of the alphabet? | No | Early literacy | No | ASQ-III (60 mo), though four letters only | No | |
Can your child read at least four simple, popular words? | No | Early literacy | No | No | No | |
Does your child know the name and recognize the symbol of all numbers from 1 to 10? | No | Early numeracy | No | ASQ-III (54–60 mo), though two numbers only | No | |
Learning/cognition | Age-appropriate measures of cognition | |||||
Does your child follow simple directions on how to do something correctly? | Yes | Cognition | Yes | ASQ-III (36–60 mo) | Yes, “cannot understand two-part commands” | |
When given something to do, is your child able to do it independently? | Yes | Cognition | Yes | No | No, though “shows more independence” listed as positive milestone | |
Physical development | “Too sick to play” not a measure of development; pincer grasp appropriate for under 12 mo | |||||
Is your child sometimes too sick to play? (reverse coded) | No | Health | Yes | No | No | |
Can your child pick up a small object with two fingers, like a stick or a rock from the ground? | No | Fine motor | No | No | Yes, “cannot grasp a crayon between thumb and fingers” | |
Socioemotional development | Age-appropriate measures of socioemotional development | |||||
Does your child kick, bite, or hit other children or adults? (reverse coded) | Yes | Aggressive behavior | Yes | SDQ (36–60 mo), focus on fighting/bullying | Yes, “exhibits aggressive behavior” | |
Does your child get easily distracted? (reverse coded) | Yes | Attention | Yes | SDQ (36–60 mo) | Yes, “is easily distracted” | |
Does your child get along well with other children? | Yes | Social competence | Yes | ASQ-III (60 mo), focus on sharing and taking turns; SDQ (36–60 mo), focus on being well liked | Yes, “shows little interest in playing with other children” |
All ECDI items scored as yes (one)/no (zero). Children were classified as “low development” for a domain if they received a score of zero on more than one item within the domain.
The Ages & Stages Questionnaire, Third Edition, and the Strengths and Difficulties Questionnaire were chosen as comparators because they are well-validated measures of early development used across high-, middle-, and low-income country contexts.
AAP, American Academy of Pediatrics; ASQ-III, Ages & Stages Questionnaire, Third Edition; SDQ, Strengths and Difficulties Questionnaire.