Table 1.
References | Country setting | Chronic pain type | Therapies considered | Time horizon | Cycle length | Dose titration included | Treatment lines | Model type | Costs | Assumption of efficacy (analgesic effect) |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Coluzzi and Ruggeri [18] | Italy | Non-malignant | Oxycodone/naloxone; tapentadol; oxycodone | 1 year | 15 weeks | No | 1 line | Markov | Direct | Equivalent efficacy |
Dunlop et al. [17] | UK | Non-malignant | Oxycodone/naloxone; oxycodone | 43 weeks | 1 week | No | 1 line | Markov | Direct | Equivalent efficacy |
Frei et al. [7] | Denmark | Non-malignant | Fentanyl; morphine | 1 year | 30 days | No | 2 lines | Markov | Direct | Equivalent efficacy |
Hass et al. [15] | Germany | Non-specific | Buprenorphine; fentanyl; oxycodone; morphine | 6 years | 1 year | No | 1 line | Markov | Direct | Equivalent efficacy |
Ikenberg et al. [13]. Structure later used by: Obradovic et al. [14] | UK | Non-malignant | Tapentadol; oxycodone | 1 year | 4 weeks | Yes | 3 lines | Markov | Direct | Equivalent efficacy |
Neighbors et al. [6]. Structure later used by: Lehmann et al. [11]; Grenier et al. [12]; Hauber et al. [16] | USA | Non-specific | Fentanyl; morphine; oxycodone | 1 year | NA | Yes | 2 lines | Decision tree | Direct | Equivalent efficacy |
NICE [10] | UK | Malignant | Morphine; oxycodone; fentanyl; buprenorphine | 1 year | 1 week | No | 2 lines | Markov | Direct | Equivalent efficacy |
Neil et al. [5] | USA | Non-malignant | Tapentadol; oxycodone | 1 year | NA | Yes | 2 lines | Discrete event simulation | Direct | Equivalent efficacy |