Skip to main content
. 2016 Jun 21;11(6):e0157897. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0157897

Table 4. Factors influencing healthcare workers’ choices of strategies for workplace violence prevention.

Dimensions Strategies Variables OR 95% CI P
Individual Use batons, helmets, and other protective equipment Age 0.389 0.252–0.601 0
Years of experience 4.324 2.856–6.547 0
Professional title 1.628 1.371–1.932 0
Working rotating shifts 0.316 0.216–0.462 0
Violence type
physical violence only 3.904 1.596–9.549 0.003
psychological violence only 2.593 1.739–3.868 0
both types of violence 6.279 3.502–11.257 0
Improve competence in diagnosis and treatment Gender
Male 1.401 1.032–1.902 0.03
Violence
physical violence only 5.764 1.917–17.333 0.002
psychological violence only 1.683 1.217–2.327 0.002
both types of violence 1.89 1.096–3.261 0.022
Improve doctor-patient communication skills Anxiety level 1.539 1.294–1.831 0
Violence
physical violence only - - -
psychological violence only 2.575 1.629–4.0071 0
both types of violence - - -
Organisational Target training to strengthen competence in responding to violence Gender
Male 1.609 1.181–2.191 0.003
Years of experience 1.516 1.062–2.163 0.022
Professional title 0.826 0.710–0.960 0.013
Violence
physical violence only - - -
psychological violence only 1.94 1.391–2.707 0
both types of violence - - -
Hospital improvements in violence reporting, statistics, and interventions Gender
Male 1.645 1.196–2.262 0.002
Years of experience 1.675 1.186–2.366 0.003
Anxiety level 1.174 1.038–1.328 0.011
Working rotating shifts 0.714 0.53–0.963 0.027
Professional title 1.343 1.160–1.555 0
Security patrols in the emergency or other key departments Violence
physical violence only 2.381 1.059–5.354 0.036
psychological violence only - - -
both types of violence 1.174 1.038–1.233 0.017
Gender
Male 2.213 1.608–3–046 0
Years of experience 1.73 1.195–2.503 0.004
Professional title 0.819 0.705–0.951 0.009
Profession
General practitioner 0.596 0.432–0.822 0.002
Anxiety level 1.151 1.003–1.319 0.044
Violence
physical violence only - - -
psychological violence only - - -
both types of violence 5.864 2.058–16.709 0.001
Reinforce staff with back-up support Age 0.381 0.253–0.574 0
Years of experience 3.423 2.344–4.998 0
Professional title 1.477 1.262–1.729 0
Profession
General practitioner 0.629 0.453–0.873 0.006
Working rotating shifts 0.533 0.381–0.744 0
Anxiety level 1.308 1.143–1.497 0
Violence
physical violence only 4.465 1.849–10.782 0.001
psychological violence only 2.207 1.534–3.174 0
both types of violence 2.027 1.151–3.568 0.014
Improve the treatment process and shorten wait times Age 0.399 0.265–0.601 0
Gender
Male 1.611 1.177–2.205 0.003
Years of experience 2.833 1.948–4.122 0
Professional title 1.211 1.047–1.400
physical violence only - - -
psychological violence only 1.799 1.281–2.525 0.001
both types of violence - - -
Install cameras on wards, keep work areas bright by using lights at night Years of experience 1.553 1.100–2.192 0.012
Profession
General practitioner 0.714 0.531–0.960 0.026
Anxiety level 1.307 1.152–1.483 0
Violence
physical violence only 2.512 1.040–6.066 0.041
psychological violence only 1.797 1.296–2.491 0
both types of violence 3.356 1.821–6.188 0
Promote transparency of fees, assure fee payment Age 0.553 0.365–0.839 0.005
Professional title 1.222 1.048–1.425 0.011
Working rotating shifts 0.58 0.422–0.797 0.001
Violence
physical violence only 2.572 1.061–6.233 0.036
psychological violence only 5.544 3.805–8.078 0
both types of violence 13.77 6.263–30.264 0
Social Police officers stationed in the hospital Age 0.379 0.253–0.567 0
Gender
Male 1.795 1.266–2.545 0.001
Years of experience 3.544 2.434–5.160 0
Professional title 1.225 1.047–1.435 0.012
Working rotating shifts 0.415 0.300–0.575 0
Violence
physical violence only 3.366 1.403–8.076 0.007
psychological violence only - - -
both types of violence 1.977 1.155–3.384 0.013
Enact workplace violence legislation Age 0.422 0.281–0.634 0
Years of experience 2.473 1.714–3.569 0
Working rotating shifts 0.456 0.335–0.622 0
Violence
physical violence only - - -
psychological violence only 2.14 1.533–2.988 0
both types of violence 24.68 8.666–70.325 0
Develop violence prevention guidelines and plans Age 0.421 0.283–0.626 0
Gender
Male 1.874 1.365–2.573 0
Years of experience 2.259 1.582–3.226 0
Violence
physical violence only 3.244 1.329–7.918 0.01
psychological violence only 1.912 1.376–2.655 0
both types of violence 6.967 3.564–13.622 0
Accurate perspectives and reports by media, promote respect of medical workers Age 0.558 0.377–0.826 0.004
Years of experience 1.551 1.086–2.216 0.016
Working rotating shifts 0.543 0.102–0.733 0
Anxiety level 1.299 1.142–1.478 0
Violence
physical violence only - - -
psychological violence only 2.868 2.028–4.057 0
both types of violence - - -