Skip to main content
. Author manuscript; available in PMC: 2016 Aug 25.
Published in final edited form as: J Perinatol. 2016 Feb 25;36(7):493–499. doi: 10.1038/jp.2016.14

Table 1. Characteristics of Commonly-Used Breast Pumps.

Characteristic Manual, Battery-Operated, Mini-Electric Double Electric (Includes Personal Use Pumps) Hospital Grade Electric
Usage Single-User Single-User Multi-User
Availability Purchase Purchase Rental (can be purchased)
Collection Kit Single (Sequential milk removal)
Limited or no breast shield size options
Double (Caution: Some models feature Sequential rather than Simultaneous milk removal even with double collection kit)
Limited number of breast shield sizes may be available
Double (Simultaneous milk removal)
Different breast shield sizes available
Breast Pump Suction Pattern (BPSP) Options Limited or no options Most have adjustable suction pressures
Some have adjustable rate and rhythm
Some have limited embedded BPSPs that mimic the breastfeeding infant
Adjustable rate, rhythm and suction strength are standard
Some have embedded BPSPs that mimic the breastfeeding infant
Primary Advantage Convenience Convenience
Greater effectiveness, efficiency, and comfort than manual, battery-operated and mini-electric models
Maximum effectiveness, efficiency and comfort, but
Not as portable as smaller and lighter pumps in other categories
Intended Use Brief separations from an otherwise healthy, breastfeeding infant Return to full-time employment outside the home
Brief (1-2 days) travel separations during established lactation
Partially and completely breast pump dependent mothers during any stage of lactation
Other mothers who value effectiveness, efficiency and comfort over portability
Not Intended For Partially or completely breast pump dependent mothers at any stage of lactation Partially or completely breast pump dependent mothers at any stage of lactation No exclusions--can be used by any category of mother at any stage of lactation

Note: The information in this table reflects both cited evidence and marketing guidelines for product use.