Skip to main content
. 2016 Jun 21;4:16017. doi: 10.1038/boneres.2016.17

Table 3. Comparison of scores at the 3-, 6-, and 12-month follow-up in the two treatment groups.

Outcome External fixation Percentage of uninjured side Plating Percentage of uninjured side P-valve
Three months
 Grip strength 29.34 (±3.12) 20.89 27.54 (±2.45) 24.54 0.151
 Pain/mm 1.82   2.23   0.118
 Extension/% 62.87 (±4.32) 30.12 74.76 (±3.86) 23.76 0.043
 Flexion/% 61.28 (±6.43) 24.76 65.87 (±4.98) 27.65 0.153
 Supination/% 70.12 (±6.53) 28.65 82.76 (±4.83) 23.25 0.047
 Pronation/% 81.76 (±5.87) 21.87 94.76 (±5.65) 13.29 0.001
 Radial deviation/% 65.67 (±4.98) 35.65 65.54 (±7.54) 56.98 0.112
 Ulnar deviation/% 65.57 (±3.76) 35.76 66.87 (±7.65) 36.85 0.142
 Function (DASH score) 26.18 (±1.87)   21.98 (±3.74)   0.176
Six months
 Grip strength 51.76 (±4.21) 35.62 78.97 (±2.87) 32.17 0.021
 Pain/mm 2.65 (±0.43)   2.67 (±0.87)   0.541
 Extension/% 56.29 (±2.98) 14.65 57.87 (±5.87) 17.98 0.565
 Flexion/% 72.13 (±3.53) 13.95 78.55 (±3.39) 15.73 0.342
 Supination/% 84.21 (±3.87) 7.61 86.53 (±2.63) 8.43 0.635
 Pronation/% 61.76 (±5.47) 37.85 95.12 (±5.04) 5.21 <0.001
 Radial deviation/% 90.54 (±8.05) 62.15 84.89 (±7.85) 57.76 0.827
 Ulnar deviation/% 75.94 (±2.97) 9.72 71.45 (±3.07) 12.23 0.397
 Function (DASH score) 33.16 (±5.48)   36.65 (±7.83)   0.647
Twelve months
 Grip strength 98.07 (±8.27) 72.75 93.32 (±5.43) 68.22 0.476
 Pain/mm 1.73 (±0.68)   1.65 (±0.65)   0.836
 Extension/% 85.23 (±3.75) 21.76 86.48 (±5.08) 19.04 0.255
 Flexion/% 81.37 (±6.02) 24.68 82.18 (±3.87) 21.98 0.632
 Supination/% 98.41 (±1.64) 16.03 98.76 (±2.67) 8.98 0.627
 Pronation/% 95.29 (±2.57) 5.23 99.37 (±3.59) 4.87 0.243
 Radial deviation/% 99.53 (±2.76) 77.76 96.78 (±4.97) 7.38 0.347
 Ulnar deviation/% 80.27 (±7.65) 23.65 79.91 (±5.81) 79.07 0.754
 Function (DASH score) 18.79 (±5.54)   16.81 (±5.98)   0.276