Skip to main content
. Author manuscript; available in PMC: 2016 Jun 29.
Published in final edited form as: Public Health Genomics. 2015 Jun 16;18(4):216–224. doi: 10.1159/000431250

Table 3.

Responses to PGT scenarios (n = 1,030)

Scenario 1: Alzheimer’s disease risk
(1) Based on these results, what are Lindsay’s chances of developing Alzhiemer’s disease compared to the average woman of her age and ethnicity? [correct answer = much higher] 66.0
(2) Based on her results, which of the following statements best describes Lindsay〉s chances of developing Alzheimer’s disease? [correct answer = she has a 43% chance of developing Alzheimer’s disease by age 79 (23andMe); she has a >13% chance of developing Alzheimer’s disease (Pathway)] 83.2

Scenario 2: Type 2 diabetes risk
(3) Based on his GENETIC results, what are Dan’s chances of developing diabetes compared to the average man of his age and ethnicity? [correct answer = somewhat lower] 59.2
(4) Based on his GENETIC results, will Dan develop diabetes? [correct answer = probably not] 82.3
(5) Which of the following is a true statement about Dan’s risk of diabetes? [correct answer = Dan’s obesity is an important risk factor for diabetes regardless of his genetic results] 93.1

Scenario 3: Carrier screening results
(6) Erin does not carry any variants/mutations for the diseases listed in the report. [correct answer = false] 96.8
(7) Erin herself likely has one of the diseases or conditions listed in the report. [correct answer = false] 81.1
(8) Erin’s children could inherit a variant or mutation for one of the conditions listed in the report. [correct answer = true] 97.4
Phenylketonuria (PKU) resultsa
(9a) Based on these results, what are the chances that Erin has phenylketonuria (PKU)? [correct answer = most likely does not have PKU] 71.0
(10a) The father of Erin’s child is a carrier of a PKU mutation. Based on these results, what is the chance for Erin’s child to have PKU? [correct answer = 25%] 63.6
Cystic fibrosis (CF) resultsa
(9b) Based on these results, what are the chances that Erin has cystic fibrosis (CF)? [correct answer = most likely does not have CF] 67.2
(10b) Based on these results, what is the chance that Erin is a carrier of a CF mutation? [correct answer = most likely is not a carrier] 74.8

Scenario 4: Statin drug response
(11) Based on his statin drug response results, what are Frank’s chances of myopathy while taking statin therapy? [correct answer = higher than average] 92.7

Average of correct responses across items 79.1

The results are presented as % correct.

a

Participants were randomized to receive PKU or CF results.