Table 3.
Diagnostic components included in NIH definition and corresponding criteria applied to the P1041 data base
Diagnostic components | Summary of NIH definitions | Criteria applied to P1041 data base |
---|---|---|
Microbiologic confirmation | At least one positive culture (with confirmed M. tb speciation) from sputum | At least one positive culture, defined as M. tb isolated on gastric washing and/or induced sputum |
Clinical signs and symptoms suggestive of tuberculosis1 | Persistent cough (>2 weeks, unremitting) | Any cough (>2 weeks) present at TB diagnosis |
Persistent unexplained fever (>1 week, >38°C) | Any fever (>1 week) present at TB diagnosis | |
Persistent, unexplained lethargy or reduced playfulness | Any lethargy present at TB diagnosis | |
Unexplained weight loss >5% reduction in weight compared to the highest weight recorded in the last 3 months | Any weight loss >5% reduction in weight compared to the highest weight recorded in the last 3 months, assessed at TB diagnosis or closest prior visit within 3 months.1 | |
One of following indicators of FTT: (1) clear deviation from a growth trajectory, (2) documented crossing of percentile lines in preceding 3 months, (3) weight-for-age z-score ≤−2 in the absence of previous/recent growth trajectory or weight-for-height z-score ≤−2 in the absence of previous/recent growth trajectory. In addition, not responding to nutritional rehabilitation (or ARV if HIV infected). |
One of the following: (1) documented diagnosis of FTT present at TB diagnosis, (2) weight-for-age or weight-for-height that crossed one major percentile line (3, 10, 25, 50, 75, 90, 97) within a 3-month period, recorded in the preceding 3 months1, (3) weight-for-age z-score or weight-for-height z-score ≤−2 in the preceding 3 months.1 Data on response to nutritional rehabilitation was not available. | |
Additional signs and symptoms suggestive of TB for infants 0–60 days include (a) neonatal pneumonia, (b) unexplained hepatosplenomegaly, or (c) sepsis-like illness | Data not available. All infants in P1041 were at least 91 days of age at enrollment. | |
Interpretation of CXR | CXR reading and reporting procedure: minimum of 2 independent and blinded readers, a third expert reader in case of discordant reading, overall quality of CXR indicated, and standardized forms. CXR is classified as “consistent with tuberculosis” if there is a positive response for any 1 of the following radiographic features at the same location, by at least 2 expert reviewers: airway compression and/or tracheal displacement, soft tissue density suggestive of lymphadenopathy, air space opacification, widespread bilateral nodular picture, either miliary or larger lesions, pleural effusion, cavities, ghon focus, or vertebral spondylitis. | CXRs not required to be read by more than one reader. Acceptable quality of CXR indicated. Positive response for any 1 of the following radiographic features: airway compression and/or tracheal displacement, soft tissue density suggestive of lymphadenopathy, air space opacification, widespread bilateral nodular picture, either miliary or larger lesions, pleural effusion, cavities, or ghon focus, within 3 months of TB diagnosis. |
Tuberculosis exposure | History of exposure to M. tb was defined as reported exposure to a case of TB (household/close contact with documented or verbal report of smear positive and/or culture positive TB or TB treatment), within preceding 24 months | Reported exposure to a case of TB (household or non-household contact with a positive TB result or receipt of TB treatment), within preceding 24 months. |
Immunologic evidence of M. tb infection was defined as either (1) a positive tuberculin skin test (using 5TU PPD or 2TU RT23) defined as ≥10 mm if HIV uninfected or ≥ 5 mm if HIV-infected or severely malnourished or (2) a positive IGRA test | TST of ≥10 mm for HIV-uninfected or ≥ 5 mm for HIV-infected or severely malnourished patient, within 3 months1 of TB diagnosis. IGRA testing was not conducted as part of the diagnostic work up for TB in P1041. | |
Response to anti-tuberculosis treatment | Appropriate anti-TB treatment should meet the following criteria: treatment with standard regimens in accordance with local or international treatment guidelines and satisfactory adherence proposed as 80% adherence by pill count or self-reported. Response to anti-TB treatment should be evaluated at 2 months after anti-TB treatment has commenced using standardized forms with tick-box options for recording. Response to anti-TB therapy was defined as clinical features suggestive of TB disease that were present at baseline have improved, and there is no new clinical feature suggestive of TB. | TB patients in P1041 were not evaluated specifically for response to anti-TB treatment, as described in the NIH consensus guidelines. Response to treatment was based on resolution of sign/symptoms, diagnoses and changes in anthropometric measurements. A positive response to anti-tuberculosis treatment was defined as 1) resolution or improvement in all clinical signs/symptoms (as defined above) that contributed to the TB diagnosis or documentation that TB diagnosis resolved within 3 months1 after treatment initiation, and 2) no new clinical signs/symptoms within 3 months1 after treatment initiation. Data on adherence to anti-TB treatment was not available. |
A 4-week allowance was added to the 3 month windows during which S/S and response to anti-TB treatment were evaluated for consistency with the P1041 study visit schedule and to allow for late visits.