Skip to main content
. 2016 Jun 10;2(6):e1600377. doi: 10.1126/sciadv.1600377

Table 3. Performance of atlas predictions for different data sets.

Negative values indicate that the observed skies were brighter than predicted. The top entries are used to calibrate the atlas. The final three entries are independent data sets used for verification. PS, professional scientist; CS, citizen scientist.

Provider Location Mode Mean σ Scientist
All data Worldwide Both 0.008 0.17 Mixed
Various Catalonia, Spain Car 0.03 0.14 PS
Universidad Complutense de Madrid Madrid, Spain Car −0.04 0.17 PS
Kyba/Sanchez Berlin, Germany Car 0.12 0.11 PS
Globe at Night Worldwide Hand −0.21 0.34 CS
Haenel/Frank Europe and North America Hand 0.05 0.17 PS
Unihedron Worldwide Hand −0.01 0.24 CS
Loss of the Night app Worldwide Hand −0.02 0.29 CS
Espey/Owens Ireland Hand −0.08 0.14 Mixed
Royal Astronomical Society of Canada Canada Hand −0.01 0.28 CS
Giubbilini Italy Hand 0.03 0.09 PS
International Dark Sky Places Wales Hand 0.01 0.27 CS
U.S. National Park Service United States CCD 0.11 0.13 PS
Falchi Italy CCD −0.04 0.19 PS
SQM stations Worldwide Permanent stations −0.06 0.46 Mixed